What entity performs swarming? The flagellum, its stators, pili and
rhamnolipid surfactant. PA5208 is a cytoplasmic PhoU-like protein of unknown
activity; a single insertion with a growth defect reduces swarming and biofilm,
which is necessity evidence at most, and possibly a polar or
phosphate-homeostasis effect. Neither row passes the participation test.
Clade check: the PTN002194937 leaves are Coxiella burnetii CBU_0015 (Pit
accessory protein; non-motile), Haemophilus influenzae HI_1603 (non-motile,
no flagellar genes), Shewanella SO_3770, Vibrio cholerae VC_2441 ("phosphate
transport regulator") and PA5208. A flagellum-dependent swarming term cannot
hold for organisms without flagella, so the IBD is wrong for the clade as well
as for the seed.
| PTN node | node term | n_seeds | leaf IBAs | seed annotation (term, evidence, PMID) | verdict | rationale |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PTN002194937 | GO:0071978 bacterial-type flagellum-dependent swarming motility | 1 (sole) | 5 (5 taxa) | GO:0071978, IMP, PMID:17158671 (PseudoCAP) | INDIRECT-PHENOTYPE | A transposon-screen hit with a growth defect; PA5208 is a PhoU-like putative Pit-transporter accessory protein, not a motility component. The node also propagates a flagellar term to non-flagellated Haemophilus and Coxiella. Withdraw the IBD. |
Audit of the GO_CENTRAL defect on PTN002194937, which made two claims that
needed separating: that the family is "a putative Pit phosphate transporter
accessory/regulator" (a prediction) and that two leaves are in organisms that
lack flagella (a taxon fact, and the load-bearing one). Leaf membership
confirmed with panther_tree.py node PTN002194937 --leaves: 5 leaves, all
PTHR36536:SF3.
| Leaf | Name and its evidence | Experimental annotations found | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| P44271 (Haemophilus influenzae HI_1603) | Curated RecName "UPF0111 protein HI_1603" — a family placeholder, asserting no function; PE 1 |
None. GO:0071978 IBA is its only GO row |
Taxon claim SURVIVES (verified below) |
| Q83FC5 (Coxiella burnetii CBU_0015) | SubName "Pit accessory protein" ECO:0000313 |
EMBL:AAO89585.2 — submitter name, unvetted; PE 3 | None. GO:0071978 IBA is its only GO row |
| Q9KPD1 (Vibrio cholerae VC_2441) | RecName "Phosphate transport regulator" ECO:0008006 |
Google:ProtNLM — machine-generated name | None. GO:0071978 IBA only |
| Q8EAX1 (Shewanella oneidensis SO_3770) | RecName ECO:0008006 |
Google:ProtNLM; PE 1 | None. GO:0071978 IBA only |
| Q9HTY2 (PA5208, the seed) | RecName "TIGR00153 family protein" ECO:0008006 |
Google:ProtNLM | PseudoCAP IMP rows only (screen phenotypes) |
Family description, marked as predicted. All five leaves match Pfam
PF01865 PhoU_div, NCBIfam TIGR00153 and InterPro IPR018445, whose own name
is "putative phosphate transport regulator". No leaf has any experimental
annotation, and two of the five "phosphate" names are a submitter SubName and
a ProtNLM name. The entry no longer asserts that the family regulates
phosphate transport; it asserts only that no leaf carries a flagellar
component or motor domain.
Taxon fact, verified. UniProt proteome query (rest.uniprot.org,
2026-11-06) for the six core flagellar structural and motor genes fliF,
flgB, flgE, flhA, fliC, motA:
| Organism (taxon) | Entries | Core flagellar genes found |
|---|---|---|
| Haemophilus influenzae Rd KW20 (71421) | 1704 | 0 |
| Coxiella burnetii RSA 493 (227377) | 1812 | 0 |
| Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAO1 (208964) | 5583 | 6 (all) |
| Shewanella oneidensis MR-1 (211586) | 4070 | 6 (all) |
A free-text flagell* search over the H. influenzae and C. burnetii
proteomes likewise returns no flagellar structural protein. Both organisms are
non-motile. So two of the five leaves cannot perform a flagellum-dependent
process at all.
Confidence raised PROBABLE -> CONFIRMED: the decisive fact is a live resource
query run here, not an inference from a protein name.