No deep-research provider was available; literature collected by PubMed search
and cached abstracts or full texts. The PseudoCAP-cited paper (PMID:16030218,
Kosono et al. 2005) is abstract-only here: its PMC copy (PMC1196046) is a
scanned PDF with no text, and the PDF could not be retrieved.
contributes_to, not enables.| PTN node | node term | n_seeds | leaf IBAs | seed annotation (term, evidence, PMID) | verdict | rationale |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PTN002160376 | GO:0015385 sodium:proton antiporter activity | 1 (sole) | 24 | GO:0015385, IMP, PMID:16030218 | INDIRECT-PHENOTYPE | The abstract describes no PA1055 mutant. The row rests on a PA1054 (shaA) disruption and on complementation of E. coli TO114 by the whole PA1054-PA1059 cluster. That shows the Sha complex is a Na+/H+ antiporter, not that PA1055 enables antiport alone. Biologically right as contributes_to (a subunit of the antiporter complex), wrong as enables + IMP. The node is the LUCA root of the subunit-C family and includes MBH/MBX hydrogenase subunits (TK2086, TK1221), for which a stand-alone antiporter MF is doubtful. |
| PTN002160376 | GO:0035725 sodium ion transmembrane transport | 1 (sole) | 24 | GO:0035725, IMP, PMID:16030218 | SOUND | As a subunit of the complex responsible for Na+ extrusion, PA1055 takes part in Na+ transmembrane transport. Structural work places MrpC at the putative Na+ pathway. The process fits the whole clade, MBH Na+-translocating modules included. Caveat: the IMP code looks wrong for PA1055, since the abstract describes no PA1055 mutant; filed as a CHECK. |
PMID:16030218 is still abstract-only here: the PubMed MCP returns no body
text (the PMC copy, PMC1196046, is a scanned PDF the publisher does not
release as XML), and the PMC, Europe PMC and ASM pages were not retrievable.
The WRONG_EVIDENCE_CODE (IMP) defects on this gene rest on the abstract not
describing a mutant of this gene, so they are lowered from PROBABLE to
SUSPECTED. The WRONG_QUALIFIER defects (enables vs contributes_to) rest on
positive statements in other Mrp papers and stay PROBABLE. The reference
correctness for PMID:16030218 is changed from MISCITED to UNVERIFIED.
Annotation actions are unchanged.
The full text of Kosono et al. 2005 was supplied by the user and read. It
supersedes the earlier notes above that describe this paper as abstract-only.
The only sha mutant the paper constructs is the PA1054 insertion; the
cluster-level evidence comes from expressing the whole PA1054-PA1059 cluster,
or the cluster with PA1054 disrupted, in an antiporter-deficient E. coli
strain. There is no PA1055 mutant, so the IMP evidence-code defects on PA1055 are CONFIRMED.