Fetched with just fetch-gene PSEAE dctQ (UniProt read timeouts on early
attempts; a re-run completed). Accession Q9HU17 matches the worklist (rank 49).
Swiss-Prot reviewed entry (DCTQ_PSEAE, PE 1). No deep-research provider was
used.
Evidence type: growth phenotypes of an operon deletion (in a dctA background) and
competition experiments. The readout is indirect (growth), but the perturbation
removes only transporters, and the substrates are specific. DctQ is part of the
TRAP translocator, so it does some of the transport work; the claim holds for
DctQ. The abstract does not say whether a dctQ-only mutant was tested.
24 leaves in 11 taxa: E. coli YiaM (P37674) and Salmonella YiaM; Haemophilus
HI_0051 and HI_1030; nine or more Bradyrhizobium japonicum paralogs; Geobacter
GSU2056; Dictyoglomus Dtur_1773; Yersinia YPO1578; P. aeruginosa DctQ. The node
also carries a YiaM-seeded GO:0022857 IBD. E. coli YiaM has experimental
annotations for carbohydrate transmembrane transporter activity and
2,3-diketo-L-gulonate transport (EcoCyc IDA, PMID:16385129), not a
C4-dicarboxylate. TRAP substrate specificity is set by the DctP-type binding
protein. So the C4-dicarboxylate IBD, seeded only by DctQ, is over-specific for
this clade and wrongly propagated to YiaM and to the many uncharacterised
paralogs.
| PTN node | node term | n_seeds | leaf IBAs | seed annotation (term, evidence, PMID) | verdict | rationale |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PTN002169725 | GO:0015740 C4-dicarboxylate transport | 1 (sole) | 24 (11 taxa) | GO:0015740, IMP, PMID:21725012 (PseudoCAP) | OVER-SPECIFIC | The seed is sound for DctQ (dctA dctPQM double mutant cannot grow on malate or fumarate; DctPQM is the high-affinity succinate carrier). But the node is a YiaM-type TRAP small-permease clade (PANTHER named for YiaM) containing E. coli YiaM, whose characterised substrate is 2,3-diketo-L-gulonate, plus many paralogs of unknown substrate; in TRAP systems the binding protein sets the substrate. |
Defects filed: GO_CENTRAL WRONG_TERM (CHECK) for the PTN002169725 IBD on the IBA
row. No PSEUDOCAP defect; the IMP row is correct, only refined to the specific
import terms.