No deep-research provider was available; this is my own literature review
(PubMed MCP plus cached publications).
Summary: PilM is the cytoplasmic, ATP-binding, actin-like component of the
PilMNOP alignment subcomplex of the type IVa pilus machine. It docks on the
inner membrane through the PilN N-terminus and links the alignment subcomplex
to the motor (PilB, PilT, PilC). It is not a pilus fibre subunit.
QuickGO IBA rows for both GO:0044096 and GO:0043107 from PTN001286216 (23
leaves each, WITH UniProtKB:G3XD28 only). Leaves include genuine PilM
orthologs (Neisseria NMB1808, Xanthomonas XCC3232, Shewanella SO_0281,
Geobacter GSU2032, Synechocystis, Deinococcus DR_0770, Vibrio VC_2634), but
also ethanolamine utilization protein EutJ of E. coli K-12 (P77277, b2454) and
Salmonella LT2 (P0A206, STM2462), an EutJ-named Fusobacterium protein
(Q8RI50), Listeria lmo1161 and other uncharacterised FtsA-like proteins (UniProt
REST, PANTHER PTHR32432:SF3 for all). EutJ belongs to the eut microcompartment
operon and is not a pilus protein, so the node is broader than the PilM clade:
both IBDs over-propagate to EutJ leaves.
| PTN node | node term | n_seeds | leaf IBAs | seed annotation (term, evidence, PMID) | verdict | rationale |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PTN001286216 | GO:0044096 type IV pilus | 1 (sole) | 23 (20 taxa) | GO:0044096 type IV pilus, located_in, IMP, PMID:7565110 (PseudoCAP) | WRONG | A mutant phenotype (no fimbriae) annotated as a location. PilM is a cytoplasmic, inner-membrane-docked component of the assembly machine, not part of the surface fibre the term defines. The IBD has no other support; it also reaches EutJ proteins. |
| PTN001286216 | GO:0043107 type IV pilus-dependent motility | 1 (sole) | 23 (20 taxa) | GO:0043107, IMP, PMID:7565110 and PMID:19857645 (PseudoCAP) | SOUND (seed); node too broad | The seed is right for PilM: a core T4P machine component whose loss abolishes twitching. But the node includes E. coli and Salmonella EutJ and other non-pilus FtsA-like proteins, so the clade-wide claim over-propagates; GO_CENTRAL asked to move the IBD to a PilM-only node. |
Audit of the leaf claims in the GO_CENTRAL source defects on PTN001286216.
Leaf membership and subfamily confirmed with
uv run python projects/PSEUDOCAP/panther_tree.py node PTN001286216 --leaves
(23 leaves, all PTHR32432:SF3); UniProt flat files fetched for all 23 accessions.
Discriminator found: the seed and 14 other leaves match InterPro IPR005883 PilM
with Pfam PF11104 PilM_2 (10 of those also NCBIfam TIGR01175 pilM); four leaves
match InterPro IPR013366 EutJ with Pfam PF14450 FtsA and none of the PilM
signatures; four match neither family. No leaf other than G3XD28 carries any
experimental GO annotation.
| Leaf | Name and its evidence | Experimental annotations | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| P77277 (E. coli b2454) | RecName "Ethanolamine utilization protein EutJ", curated (Reviewed); PE 3 | none; FUNCTION by ECO:0000250 from P0A206. Lies in the E. coli eut operon (CC CAUTION) | Claim survives on domain + operon context, not on the name: IPR013366 EutJ, PF14450 FtsA, no PilM signature |
| P0A206 (S. typhimurium STM2462) | RecName "Ethanolamine utilization protein EutJ", curated; GN from ECO:0000303 PubMed:7868611; PE 2 | no experimental GO rows, but curated ECO:0000269 FUNCTION/DISRUPTION PHENOTYPE from eutJ deletion and eutJ/eutS overexpression (PubMed:10464203, 16585748, 27063436), placing it in the 17-gene eut operon and its microcompartment | Claim survives, now on experimental curated statements |
| Q8RI50 (F. nucleatum FN1783) | SubName "Ethanolamine utilization protein eutJ" {ECO:0000313|EMBL}; PE 3 | none | Name is not evidence; the EutJ claim is downgraded to the signature match (IPR013366, no PilM signature; Pfam HSP70 rather than FtsA) |
| Q8Y7V8 (L. monocytogenes lmo1161) | SubName "Lmo1161 protein" {ECO:0000313|EMBL}; PE 4 Predicted | none | Not a pilus protein on two checkable grounds: IPR013366 EutJ / PF14450 FtsA with no PilM signature, and gene neighbourhood (lmo1160 phosphate propanoyltransferase, lmo1164 corrinoid adenosyltransferase) places it in the B12-dependent catabolic microcompartment locus |
| A0A0H2W2G1 (Y. pestis YPO0146) | SubName "Uncharacterized protein"; PE 4 | none | Carries IPR005883 PilM / PF11104, so the Enterobacteriaceae subclade PTN002089606 is mixed, not an "EutJ branch" |
Correction to the earlier entry: the tree offers no PilM-only node for the
seed. The smallest clade holding G3XD28 with other PilM-signature leaves is
PTN001596234, which already contains P77277 and P0A206, and the
Enterobacteriaceae clade below it is mixed (above). The requested change is
therefore NOT/IKR on the four EutJ-signature leaves, not a move.
Confidence: GO:0043107 defect PROBABLE -> CONFIRMED; GO:0044096 defect
PROBABLE -> CONFIRMED (the decisive fact for the latter is G3XD28's own
GO:0005737 cytoplasm EXP:UniProtKB annotation plus PMID:19857645, independent
of any leaf name).