statA (Dd-STATa, DICDI, UniProt O00910) — Adjudication of GO:0042127 (regulation of cell population proliferation) and GO:0006952 (defense response) OpenScientist openscientist-autonomous 4 citations 2 artifacts 2026-09-20T19:14:17.316595 citations file

OpenScientist final report (text/html)

OpenScientist final report (application/pdf)

statA (Dd-STATa, DICDI, UniProt O00910) — Adjudication of GO:0042127 (regulation of cell population proliferation) and GO:0006952 (defense response)

Focus type: function_assignment · Hypothesis slug: proliferation-and-defense-response
Iteration: 3 of 3 (final)

Executive Judgment

Both arms of the hypothesis are WEAKLY SUPPORTED / OVER-ANNOTATED (paralog- and ortholog-based carry-over).

Decisive provenance (QuickGO PAINT, GO_REF:0000033, ECO:0000318/IBA):
- GO:0042127 is propagated to statA from with/from leaves = mammalian STAT3/5A/5B/1, Drosophila Stat92E, zebrafish, and the Dictyostelium paralog STATb (dstB / DDB_G0268638 / Q70GP4) — statA itself has no experimental leaf. The experimental proliferation evidence belongs to STATb: PMID:14701681 (Zhukovskaya et al. 2004) — "It has a subtle role in growth, so that Dd-STATb-null cells are gradually lost from the population when they are co-cultured with parental cells." This is a textbook paralog-based overannotation of statA.
- GO:0006952 is propagated from with/from leaves that are 100% metazoan — Drosophila Stat92E, mouse Stat1/2/6, rat Stat, human STAT1 (P42224) and STAT2 (P52630) (the interferon/antiviral STATs), C. elegans sta-1 — with zero Dictyostelium leaves. Pure ortholog carry-over of the metazoan immune role.

GO:0042127 "regulation of cell population proliferation" — over-annotated (recommend do-not-accept as core; treat as non-core IBA lead). In UniProt this term carries only an IBA (Inferred from Biological Ancestor, GO_Central) evidence code. There is no primary Dictyostelium experimental evidence that statA modulates the frequency/rate/extent of cell division (vegetative growth). Every experimentally-supported statA annotation concerns developmental differentiation and morphogenesis (culmination, stalk-cell differentiation), which the seed correctly asks to distinguish from proliferation. The IBA reflects mammalian STAT3/STAT5 growth-promoting roles, not amoebal biology.
GO:0006952 "defense response" — over-annotated (recommend do-not-accept as core; treat as non-core IBA lead). Also IBA:GO_Central only. Dictyostelium innate/defense functions are mediated by sentinel (S) cells and the TIR-domain protein TirA (PMID:17673666), with no reported role for statA. The one Dictyostelium STAT with a stress role is the paralog STATc (hyperosmotic shock; PMID:17517120), which is (a) a different gene and (b) a stress response (GO:0006950), not a defense response (GO:0006952) — the seed's "generic stress vs. defense" distinction is decisive here. The IBA reflects metazoan STAT1/STAT2 antiviral/immune roles.

Core function (what the primary evidence actually supports): statA/Dd-STATa is a cAMP-activated STAT-family transcription factor that acts as both a repressor (of stalk/ecmB genes prior to stalk-tube entry) and an activator (of pstA/pstAB genes such as cudA), driving prestalk patterning, stalk-cell differentiation and culmination during sorocarp development, with an additional early role in chemotaxis/aggregation (PMID:10393118, 10821768, 11269945, 15470642).

Evidence Matrix

Citation (PMID)	Evidence type	Supports/Refutes/Qualifies	Claim tested	Key finding	Context	Confidence / limitations
UniProt O00910 / QuickGO (GO_REF:0000033)	Database/annotation	Qualifies both	Evidence tier of the two seed terms	GO:0042127 and GO:0006952 are IBA-only for statA; all statA experimental (IMP/IDA/HMP) annotations are developmental/transcriptional	Curated record	High for provenance; IBA ≠ species evidence
PMID:14701681 (Zhukovskaya 2004)	Mutant phenotype (paralog STATb null)	Competing (paralog)	Which Dictyostelium STAT regulates proliferation?	STATb (dstB/Q70GP4), not statA, has the experimental proliferation phenotype (STATb-null cells lost from population in co-culture); source of the ancestral IBA	D. discoideum growth/early dev	High; assigns proliferation to the paralog
QuickGO with/from for GO:0006952	Structural/evolutionary (orthology)	Refutes/Competes	Origin of defense-response term	with/from leaves are 100% metazoan (human STAT1/STAT2 etc.), no Dictyostelium leaf	Cross-species PAINT	High; pure ortholog carry-over
10393118	Mutant phenotype (null)	Supports core; Refutes proliferation	Does statA null affect growth or development?	Dd-STATa null: delayed aggregation, slow chemotaxis, aberrant prestalk gene expression, fails to culminate; acts as repressor of stalk commitment. No growth/proliferation defect reported	D. discoideum, development	High; classic reference
10821768	Direct assay + mutant	Supports core (TF activity)	Mechanistic TF role	Dd-STATa is a direct activator of cudA in prestalk cells and binds promoter elements	D. discoideum	High
11269945	In vitro binding + mutant	Supports core (repressor)	Repressor mechanism	Dd-STATa binds ecmB ST-promoter elements and represses stalk-tube gene transcription	D. discoideum	High
15470642	Expression profiling (in situ)	Supports core	Target-gene regulation	Identifies pstA/pstAB genes directly induced by Dd-STATa	D. discoideum slug	High
17673666	Discovery + mutant (TirA)	Refutes/Competes (defense)	Who mediates Dictyostelium defense?	Sentinel cells + TIR-domain TirA provide innate immune/detoxification defense and bacterial feeding — statA not implicated	D. discoideum slug	High; defines the true defense machinery
17517120	Mutant + microarray	Competes (defense/stress)	Which STAT handles stress?	STATc (paralog) is the key regulator of the hyperosmotic-shock transcriptional response	D. discoideum	High; term is stress (GO:0006950), not defense
InterPro/Pfam (O00910)	Structural/evolutionary	Qualifies	Domain architecture	STAT coiled-coil, STATa Ig, SH2, EF-hand-12, p53-like DNA-binding fold — canonical STAT TF, no phagocytic/immune effector domain	Sequence	High

GO Curation Implications (leads — require curator verification)

GO term	Aspect	Current evidence	Recommended action
GO:0042127 regulation of cell population proliferation	BP	IBA:GO_Central only	Do not treat as core; flag as non-core / candidate for removal for DICDI. No species-specific evidence; statA's role is differentiation, not population expansion. If retained, keep strictly as low-confidence IBA.
GO:0006952 defense response	BP	IBA:GO_Central only	Do not treat as core; flag as non-core / candidate for removal for DICDI. Defense in Dictyostelium = TirA/S-cells (PMID:17673666); no statA evidence.
GO:0031149 / 0031154 / 0030587 / 0045892 / 0010628 / 0097696	BP	IMP/IDA/HMP	Retain — these are the experimentally-grounded core annotations.

Curator note: the recommendation is to downgrade/remove the two IBA seed terms as core annotations, not to assert a NOT-qualifier without a dedicated negative experiment. Preferred, more-informative core BP terms already exist (sorocarp stalk cell differentiation; culmination in sorocarp development).

Mechanistic Scope

Immediate molecular function: sequence-specific DNA-binding transcription factor (SH2-mediated cAMP/tyrosine-phosphorylation-dependent activation → nuclear translocation in prestalk tip cells).
Direct activity: transcriptional repression (ecmB/stalk genes) and activation (cudA, pstA/pstAB genes).
Downstream/developmental outcomes (not the molecular function): stalk-cell differentiation, culmination, fruiting-body (sorocarp) morphology, chemotaxis efficiency.
Neither "proliferation regulation" nor "defense response" is an immediate molecular activity nor an experimentally-observed loss-of-function phenotype for statA.

Conflicts and Alternatives

Paralog confusion (proliferation): The experimental "regulation of cell population proliferation" phenotype in Dictyostelium belongs to the paralog STATb (dstB/Q70GP4; PMID:14701681, IMP), whose null cells are competitively lost in co-culture. statA has only IBA, propagated from the ancestral node that STATb helps define. The proliferation function should be attributed to STATb, not statA.
Paralog confusion (stress ≠ defense): The stress-responsive STAT is STATc, not statA — and its role is osmotic stress (GO:0006950), a different GO branch from defense response (GO:0006952).
Ortholog carry-over (defense): The GO:0006952 with/from set is entirely metazoan (human STAT1/STAT2, Drosophila Stat92E, mouse Stat1/2/6, C. elegans sta-1) with no Dictyostelium leaf — the term reflects the metazoan interferon/antiviral STAT role, a classic ortholog-overannotation.
True defense effector is unrelated: TirA (TIR domain) and sentinel cells (PMID:17673666) provide Dictyostelium defense independently of STAT signaling.

Knowledge Gaps

Vegetative growth rate of statA-null — Not directly quantified in the retrieved literature. Matters because a documented proliferation phenotype would be the only way to legitimately support GO:0042127. Resolve: growth-curve / doubling-time assay of statA-null vs. parental in axenic and bacterial-lawn growth.
statA in bacterial killing / S-cell function — Untested. Matters for GO:0006952. Resolve: bacterial-clearance and S-cell assays in statA-null.
GO_Central PAINT node — RESOLVED this run. Both seed terms trace to PAINT reference GO_REF:0000033 at PANTHER node PTN000927860; GO:0042127 with/from includes paralog STATb (Q70GP4, experimental IMP) plus mammalian STAT3/5, and GO:0006952 with/from is 100% metazoan (human STAT1 P42224, STAT2 P52630). Remaining uncertainty: whether curators intend a taxon constraint on these ancestral annotations for the amoebozoan branch.

Discriminating Tests

Proliferation: compare doubling time and saturation density of statA-null vs WT (axenic HL5 and on Klebsiella lawns). Prediction under the null hypothesis: no difference → refutes GO:0042127.
Defense: intracellular bacterial-killing assay and sentinel-cell counting in statA-null; compare with tirA-null positive control. Prediction: statA-null behaves like WT → refutes GO:0006952.
Paralog control: run STATc-null in the osmotic/defense assays to confirm the phenotype tracks with STATc, not statA.

Curation Leads (require curator verification)

Action change: Reclassify GO:0042127 and GO:0006952 for statA from accepted to non-core / remove (IBA-only, no DICDI experimental support).
Candidate references to cite in the review:
PMID:14701681 — proliferation phenotype belongs to paralog STATb, not statA (snippet: "It has a subtle role in growth, so that Dd-STATb-null cells are gradually lost from the population when they are co-cultured with parental cells"). Use to justify removing/de-coring GO:0042127 on statA.
PMID:17673666 — Dictyostelium defense = TirA/sentinel cells (snippet: "A Toll/interleukin-1 receptor (TIR) domain protein, TirA, was also required for some S cell functions and for vegetative amoebae to feed on live bacteria.").
PMID:17517120 — stress response belongs to paralog STATc (snippet: "STATc … is a key regulator of the transcriptional response to hyperosmotic shock.").
PMID:10393118 — statA core developmental/repressor + chemotaxis role.
Preferred core BP terms (retain): GO:0031149 sorocarp stalk cell differentiation; GO:0031154 culmination involved in sorocarp development; GO:0045892 negative regulation of DNA-templated transcription.
Suggested curator questions: Is there any unpublished/dictyBase growth or immunity phenotype for statA? Was the STAT-node IBA reviewed for taxon restriction?

Provenance (computed artifacts)

statA_GO_evidence_tiers.csv — GO evidence-tier table from UniProt O00910 (2 IBA-only seed terms isolated vs. experimental core).
statA_IBA_provenance.csv — QuickGO PAINT with/from leaves for both seed terms, showing paralog STATb + metazoan STAT1/2/3/5 as the propagation sources.
statA_experimental_annotations.csv — statA's IMP/IDA/HMP core annotations with PMIDs.
Domain architecture from InterPro/Pfam (STAT coiled-coil, STATa-Ig, SH2, EF-hand-12, p53-like DNA-binding fold).
Key computed facts: statA GO:0042127 & GO:0006952 = IBA (GO_REF:0000033) only; paralog STATb (Q70GP4) carries experimental IMP GO:0042127 (PMID:14701681); GO:0006952 with/from = 100% metazoan (human STAT1 P42224, STAT2 P52630).