Fbxo42 (Q9W281): evidence and ProtNLM claim review

Fbxo42 is the substrate-recognizing F-box subunit of an SCF ubiquitin ligase. In Drosophila oocytes, SCF-Fbxo42 downregulates the PP2A-B56 phosphatase subunit and promotes assembly and maintenance of the synaptonemal complex. Its F-box and kelch-like architecture support substrate recognition and complex assembly rather than intrinsic ubiquitin transfer.

Exact input: Q9W281, 667 residues. The accession was fetched explicitly with the gene-directory alias; no canonical-sequence substitution is made.

Raw emitted predictions: Fbxo42-predictions-source.json. Source features: Fbxo42-uniprot.txt, with an exact extraction in Fbxo42-sequence-evidence.json.

Sequence and domain evidence

These are sequence/domain observations or explicitly named feature predictions, not measurements of biological function. ARBA assertions and ProtNLM-derived UniProt names are not counted as validation.

DR   InterPro; IPR036047; F-box-like_dom_sf.
DR   InterPro; IPR001810; F-box_dom.
DR   InterPro; IPR052821; F-box_only_SRC.
DR   InterPro; IPR015915; Kelch-typ_b-propeller.
FT   DOMAIN          21..70
FT                   /note="F-box"
FT                   /evidence="ECO:0000259|PROSITE:PS50181"

ProtNLM claims

The snapshot emits names and location/keyword statements, with no GO or EC prediction for this target. Each actual statement is assessed below; no GO term has been substituted for it. Categories follow the function-prediction rubric, with nonspecific “uncharacterized” names marked UNC because they contain no testable function. CNN records an independently supported existing annotation; it does not assert a particular training-set composition.

Kind Verbatim emitted statement Assessment Evidence and limitation
Name F-box domain-containing protein CNN The F-box at residues 21-70 is independently supported by IPR001810, and PMID:33382409 directly establishes an SCF-Fbxo42 complex. The architecture name is correct but less informative than the known substrate-adaptor function.
Location Nucleus (SL-0191) UNC A role in nuclear meiotic chromosome organization does not by itself establish nuclear localization of the adaptor. The inspected experiments establish SCF association and a PP2A-B56-dependent phenotype; direct localization of Fbxo42 to nuclei is needed to resolve this claim.

Literature evidence

Annotation decisions

Research provenance

Genuine external literature research is requested through the repository Falcon wrapper, with perplexity-lite configured as fallback. Provider output is retained separately as Fbxo42-deep-research-<provider>.md; its source leads are checked against the underlying publications and exact sequence record.

2026-10-21 — Full re-review, independent of the ProtNLM2 predictions

ProtNLM2 output was not consulted for this re-review.

Identity. Q9W281 is the sole UniProt entry (unreviewed TrEMBL, 667 aa, 74.4 kDa) for FlyBase FBgn0034704/CG6758. It is the full-length canonical product, not a fragment, isoform or alternative gene model. Its architecture is an N-terminal F-box (21-70, PS50181) followed by a kelch-type beta-propeller (PF13415 Beta-prop_FBX42, IPR015915). PMID:40804044 reports the expected 74.4 kDa band, which is absent in Su226 mutants PMID:40804044.

Evolutionary placement. PANTHER PTHR46432 (F-BOX ONLY PROTEIN 42), subfamily SF1. SF1 also contains human FBXO42 (Q6P3S6), mouse Fbxo42 (Q6PDJ6) and Pongo FBXO42 (interpro/panther/PTHR46432/PTHR46432-entries.csv), so these are 1:1 orthologs PMID:33382409. Both IBA rows come from PTN002924600, and their WITH/FROM is the fly gene itself, so the clade-level PAINT call was seeded by the fly IDA. The family review interpro/panther/PTHR46432/PTHR46432-review.yaml places Q9W281 in SF1, in agreement with UniProt, so there is no placement disagreement. It does not yet cite PMID:40804044.

New literature. The falcon deep-research report built its Ataxin-2/Xbp1 account from an unpublished dissertation and missed PMID:33382409. I found and cached the peer-reviewed version, Santos et al. 2025 Nat Commun (PMID:40804044, full text). Its findings:
- SkpA binds Fbxo42 in a way that depends on the F-box PMID:40804044.
- Ataxin-2 binds Fbxo42 and is ubiquitylated and degraded by the proteasome in a way that depends on Fbxo42 PMID:40804044.
- Under stress, Fbxo42 is recruited to Ataxin-2 granules PMID:40804044.
- Degrading Ataxin-2 frees Xbp1 mRNA for translation PMID:40804044.

Decisions. All 7 GOA rows are ACCEPTed (3 SCF complex, 2 adaptor activity, 1 SCF-dependent proteasomal catabolism, 1 positive regulation of synaptonemal complex assembly). The changes from the earlier review are:
- GO:0031146 is now supported by direct Ataxin-2 evidence, not only by the F-box sequence model.
- Supporting text that was copied identically into every row has been replaced with row-specific quotes.
- The IPI row notes that the Fbxo42 IPs contained the PP2A A and C subunits. Wrd (FBgn0042693) is the curator-recorded partner; I deferred to the curators, who saw the full figures.
- The description now covers both characterised roles (Ataxin-2/UPR in somatic tissues, PP2A-B56/synaptonemal complex in the germline) and expression.
- There are two core functions: the generic SCF adaptor function, and the germline synaptonemal-complex regulation.

No NEW annotations. A stress-granule CC and a UPR-regulation BP are raised as suggested_questions instead. The localization is recruitment to the granule surface, not shown constituency. The retinal-degeneration and cell-death readouts are downstream phenotypes in an Xbp1s overexpression model, and the paper itself places Fbxo42 upstream of the apoptotic machinery.

Relative to review next. Human FBXO42 (Q6P3S6) is the 1:1 ortholog in the same PANTHER subfamily SF1, and it has no review in the repo (no genes/human/FBXO42). Human literature mentioned in PMID:40804044: "loss of Fbxo42 leads to cell cycle progression delays and aberrant mitosis". Web search also turns up reports of human FBXO42 regulating p53 and PP4; these have not been verified here.

Modules. No module includes Fbxo42. Related modules: modules/dmel_scf_slimb_ubiquitin_ligase.yaml (shares the SkpA-Cul1-Roc1a core; SCF-Slimb acts alongside SCF-Fbxo42 in synaptonemal-complex regulation per PMID:33382409) and modules/er_unfolded_protein_response.yaml (pathway context for the Ataxin-2/Xbp1 role).