Only one paper studies PA5458: Hao et al. 2013 mBio, PMID:23341552 (full text cached).
Assessment: PA5458 is very probably the membrane-bound O-acyltransferase that
decorates CPA (probably O-acetylation), i.e. a modification step of O-antigen
biosynthesis. The mutant phenotype (altered polymer structure, not merely amount)
fits the gene acting on the polymer itself, so involvement in O antigen
biosynthesis is acceptable at the gene level. The IDA evidence code on the
PseudoCAP O-antigen row is wrong: the evidence is mutant (IMP) and overexpression
analysis, not a direct assay.
Acyltransferase-3 (AT3, PF01757) proteins are polytopic inner-membrane
acyltransferases that O-acylate cell-surface glycans, with different substrates in
different lineages: S. aureus OatA O-acetylates peptidoglycan muramic acid
PMID:15661003, and
Salmonella OafA acetylates O antigen. Both sit in the same PAINT node as PA5458
(see bioinformatics).
See PA5458-bioinformatics/RESULTS.md.
Comparator check: S. aureus OatA (Q2FV54) and L. monocytogenes OatA (Q8Y7I6), whose
function is peptidoglycan O-acetylation, carry only IBA GO:0009103 for process in
QuickGO (queried 2026-10-28): the propagated term is wrong for them.
| PTN node | node term | n_seeds | leaf IBAs | seed annotation (term, evidence, PMID) | verdict | rationale |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PTN000546841 | GO:0009103 lipopolysaccharide biosynthetic process | 1 | 31 | GO:0009103 IMP PMID:23341552 (plus GO:0009243 IDA, same paper) | WRONG | The seed is sound for PA5458 itself (the deletion alters CPA structure), but one Gram-negative O-antigen seed cannot justify LPS biosynthesis at a node that also contains Gram-positive peptidoglycan O-acetyltransferases (OatA of S. aureus and L. monocytogenes) and mycobacterial/streptomycete members: 15 of 31 leaves are in organisms that make no LPS. The node term should be withdrawn or moved to a Gram-negative O-antigen subclade (with OafA). |
| PTN000546715 | GO:0000271 polysaccharide biosynthetic process | 1 | 113 | GO:0009103 IMP PMID:23341552 (plus GO:0009243 IDA) | WRONG | Generalising one bacterial O-antigen modification phenotype to a deep node whose leaves are 109/113 eukaryotic (97 nematode, 9 oomycete) AT3 proteins of unknown function. The seed shows modification of an already made polymer, not synthesis; no evidence for polysaccharide synthesis in the propagated clade. |
Seed rows themselves: GO:0009103 IMP is acceptable but under-specific (the gene
already carries GO:0009243); GO:0009243 is the right term but its IDA code should be
IMP.