Part of the category-4 counter-example set in
projects/NONPHYSIOLOGICAL_REACTIONS.md. Reviewing it surfaced the project's
most actionable GO finding.
LinA has no molecular function annotation in GOA at all. The specific term
GO:0018830 gamma-hexachlorocyclohexane dehydrochlorinase activity was obsoleted
in go-ontology#28108, a bulk action over 160 leaf catalytic terms selected for:
leaf status, a partial EC xref, zero annotations, no RHEA xref, and no
MetaCyc/KEGG xref. The obsoletion comment reads "This term was obsoleted
because there is no evidence that this specific activity exists."
For this term that statement is wrong. The activity has:
The selection criteria tracked curation coverage, not evidence. "Zero
annotations" and "no Rhea xref" were both true of this term at the time and
both are properties of the annotation pipeline rather than of the biology. The
sibling GO:0018833 DDT-dehydrochlorinase activity survived the same action only
because it had an EC number and a Rhea mapping.
Proposed in the review: restore the term under GO:0016848 carbon-halide lyase
activity with a skos:exactMatch to RHEA:45480, and interim-annotate GO:0016848
as NEW so the gene is not left with nothing.
Follow-up for the project: audit the other 159 terms from #28108 against
current UniProt catalytic activity records and Rhea mappings.