SCR (SCARECROW) curation notes — Arabidopsis thaliana, UniProt Q9M384, AT3G54220
Overview
SCR is a plant-specific GRAS-family transcriptional regulator. Core role: with the mobile
GRAS factor SHORT-ROOT (SHR), it controls the asymmetric (formative) cell division that
generates the cortex and endodermis, and it specifies/maintains the root quiescent centre (QC)
and surrounding stem-cell niche. It acts in a nuclear SHR–SCR heterodimer that recruits
BIRD/IDD zinc-finger transcription factors (JKD, MGP, NUC) to control ground-tissue patterning.
Molecular function — DNA binding vs coregulator
Key point for MF curation: GRAS proteins including SHR–SCR are best characterised as transcription
cofactors that act through DNA-binding partners (BIRD/IDD zinc fingers), not as direct
sequence-specific DNA binders.
- PMID:28211915
- PMID:28211915
- The crystal structures (PDB 5B3G binary SHR-SCR; 5B3H ternary JKD-SHR-SCR) show JKD ZF3-ZF4 docks into a groove on SHR; SCR makes no direct contact with JKD. PMID:28211915
- SCR has its own groove corresponding to the SHR ZF-binding groove, suggesting SCR also binds partner proteins via this groove. PMID:28211915
Implication: The MF annotations GO:0003700 (DNA-binding transcription factor activity, ISS/IMP)
and GO:0043565 (sequence-specific DNA binding, IDA from PMID:17446396) likely over-state a direct
DNA-binding activity for SCR. SCR/SHR bind target promoters (e.g. MGP, NUC, CYCD6;1) but the
structural and biochemical evidence (PMID:28211915) argues this is indirect, via BIRD/IDD partners.
The IDA "sequence-specific DNA binding" from PMID:17446396 (the SHR-sequestration paper, abstract
does not describe an EMSA/DNA-binding assay for SCR itself) is questionable; best treated as
over-annotation rather than core direct activity. The ISS GO:0003700 calls (PMID:11118137 genome-wide
TF survey; PMID:8756724 original cloning) derive from family/sequence classification of GRAS as
"putative transcription factors," appropriate as a broad classification but better expressed as
transcription regulator / coregulator given current evidence.
Asymmetric cell division and radial patterning (core BP)
- Original cloning: scr mutant roots miss one cell layer due to disruption of the asymmetric
division generating cortex and endodermis. PMID:8756724 SCR deduced as a putative TF, expressed in cortex/endodermal initial and endodermal lineage. PMID:8756724
- SCR acts cell-autonomously in the ACD; autoregulates its own expression; limits SHR movement.
PMID:15314023
- Radial patterning common to root and shoot: scr loses ground-tissue layer in root, and starch
sheath in hypocotyl/stem. PMID:10631180
- SHR/SCR/JKD/BIRDs throughout root growth control lineage identity, divisions and patterning.
PMID:26494755
QC / stem-cell niche
- SCR required for QC specification and maintenance of surrounding stem cells (UniProt FUNCTION,
PMID:12569126). QC and stem cells specified by parallel PLT and SHR/SCR routes.
PMID:29352064
Protein interactions (replace bare "protein binding")
- SHR (Q9SZF7 / AT4G37650): direct heterodimer partner; central to function.
PMID:17446396; structure PMID:28211915. Also Y2H confirmation PMID:18500650.
- JKD (JACKDAW, Q700D2 / AT5G03150) and MGP (MAGPIE, Q9ZWA6 / AT1G03840): BIRD/IDD zinc-finger TFs;
in the ternary complex JKD binds SHR (not SCR directly), but SHR-SCR-BIRD is the functional unit.
PMID:17785527
- RBR1 (RETINOBLASTOMA-RELATED, Q9LKZ3): binds SCR directly via SCR's LxCxE motif (residues 295-299);
this represses SHR-SCR target activation and constrains ACD to the niche.
PMID:22921914; PMID:22921914 Mutation LQCAE->AQCAA abolishes RBR1 interaction (UniProt MUTAGEN 295-299).
- AN3/GIF1 (AT5G26840): AN3/GIF coregulator complexes bind the SCR promoter region (SCR is a target,
not necessarily a direct physical SCR partner). PMID:29352064 — the GOA "protein binding" with AN3 (PMID:29352064) reflects this regulatory relationship; treat cautiously.
- GA2OX7 (Q9C6I4): a binary Y2H/interactome hit in the phytohormone protein network.
PMID:32612234 Large-scale interactome; biological significance for SCR unestablished — keep but non-core/over-annotated.
- SCL23 (AT5G41920): redundant paralog with SCR in bundle-sheath fate; IGI partner.
PMID:24517883
- Cell-type-specific complexes confirmed in vivo by FRET-FLIM (SHR, SCR, JKD higher-order complexes).
PMID:28746306
Maintenance of protein location in nucleus (SHR sequestration)
- SCR sequesters SHR in the endodermal nucleus, restricting SHR's intercellular movement to a single
cell layer. PMID:17446396 This supports GO:0051457 (maintenance of protein location in nucleus) for the SHR target. Note: the GOA NOT|protein homodimerization (GO:0042803, PMID:17446396) records that SCR does NOT homodimerize (it heterodimerizes with SHR).
Gravitropism (shoot)
- SCR = SGR1; endodermis/starch sheath is the site of gravity perception in shoots; scr/sgr1 lacks
shoot gravitropism. PMID:10322541 This is a downstream consequence of SCR's radial-patterning role (starch-sheath formation), not a distinct molecular function → non-core developmental/physiological output.
Leaf bundle sheath / redox
- SCR + SCL23 + SHR control bundle-sheath cell fate; SCR involved in sugar transport in BS cells.
PMID:24517883 → bundle sheath cell fate specification, leaf development = non-core (tissue-specific developmental outputs).
- SCR coordinates root elongation, endodermal differentiation, redox homeostasis and oxidative
stress; scr accumulates ROS in the elongation zone (decreased Peroxidase 3). PMID:34056773 → GO:0045454 cell redox homeostasis is acts_upstream_of_or_within (indirect, downstream physiological output), non-core.
Localization
- Nucleus. UniProt SUBCELLULAR LOCATION: Nucleus. IDA nuclear localization in PMID:26494755 and
PMID:15314023; SHR sequestration into the SCR-expressing nucleus (PMID:17446396). Accept nucleus.
Domain architecture (UniProt)
- 653 aa; single C-terminal GRAS domain (281-650) with LHRI, VHIID, LHRII, PFYRE, SAW subdomains;
N-terminal disordered region (1-69, 193-265); LxCxE motif at 295-299 (RBR1 binding).
Deep research synthesis (Falcon / Edison Scientific)
The Falcon deep-research report (file:ARATH/SCR/SCR-deep-research-falcon.md) corroborates and
slightly extends the existing review; it introduced no contradictions and no UNDECIDED items needed
resolving. Key corroborated points:
- Core MF/BP: SCR is a putative transcriptional regulator required for the formative periclinal
division generating cortex and endodermis [falcon "SCR is a putative transcriptional regulator/transcription factor required for the asymmetric periclinal division that generates cortex and endodermis."]; in scr the division fails and a single heterogeneous ground-tissue layer forms [falcon "In scr mutants, the second asymmetric division fails and a single heterogeneous ground-tissue layer forms instead of separate cortex and endodermis"], establishing normal radial organization [falcon "generating separate cortex and endodermis layers and thus normal radial organization"].
- SHR interaction / nuclear sequestration: confirms direct SHR–SCR interaction and SCR confining SHR
to nuclei [falcon "Reviews further emphasize SCR’s direct interaction with SHR and SCR’s role in confining SHR to nuclei"; "restricting SHR to the nucleus and coordinating downstream patterning and stem cell niche functions"; "SCR co-localizes with SHR in nuclei in primordia, and supports direct SHR–SCR interaction in these contexts"].
- In vivo complexes: FRET-FLIM JKD-YFP + SCR-RFP lifetime reduction up to 0.17 ± 0.02 ns supports
SCR–JKD complex formation [falcon "coexpression of JKD-YFP with SCR-RFP reduced fluorescence lifetime by up to 0.17 ± 0.02 ns, supporting close interaction/complex formation in meristem peripheral/primordia regions"].
- Gravitropism (non-core): amyloplasts in scr fail to sediment, explaining impaired shoot gravitropism
[falcon "amyloplasts in scr do not sediment in response to gravity"].
- New (untracked) context: the report highlights an expanded SAM role (Bahafid et al. 2023, eLife;
PMID not in current GOA) where SCR within the SHR network is needed for normal auxin-maxima
formation and lateral organ initiation, and regulation of CYCD6;1. This is consistent with SCR's
patterning role but does not map to a verifiable new GO term from the existing GOA/UniProt set, so
no NEW annotation was added on this basis.
No new GO ID verifiable from GOA/UniProt warranted a NEW annotation; the GRAS-cofactor mechanism
remains captured by the existing proposed_new_terms entry.
Action summary rationale
- Core MF: transcription coregulator/cofactor function via SHR heterodimer + BIRD/IDD recruitment.
The existing set lacks a clean coregulator MF term and over-relies on direct DNA-binding terms.
- Core BP: asymmetric cell division / radial pattern formation / root development (QC + ground tissue).
- Non-core: gravitropism, bundle-sheath/leaf development, redox homeostasis, GA2OX7 interactome hit.
- protein binding (GO:0005515) IPI entries: uninformative; recommend replacing with specific partner
capture (SHR especially) — per curation guidance, avoid bare protein binding.
PR #1417 review follow-up (ai4c-agent)
- GO:0043565 "sequence-specific DNA binding" (IDA, PMID:17446396): changed action
MARK_AS_OVER_ANNOTATED -> REMOVE. Rationale: PMID:28211915 structurally REFUTES direct
DNA binding by SHR-SCR/GRAS proteins ("no evidence for direct binding ... to DNA"; no
DNA-binding motif; negatively charged surface unfavorable for DNA binding). The activity
is actively contradicted, not merely broad, so removal (not over-annotation flag) is correct.
- Internal consistency: SHR is itself a GRAS-family coregulator that does NOT bind DNA directly.
Reworded the GO:0140297 annotation reasons so SHR is no longer called a "DNA-binding
transcription factor". For SHR-only IPI interactions (PMID:17446396, PMID:18500650),
switched proposed replacement from GO:0140297 -> GO:0019904 "protein domain specific binding"
(verified non-obsolete via QuickGO API), capturing GRAS-GRAS heterodimerization. GO:0140297
retained only where genuine DNA-binding partners (JKD/MGP, BIRD/IDD) are involved
(PMID:17785527, PMID:28211915, PMID:28746306); PMID:28211915 reason now attributes GO:0140297
to the JKD partner and describes SHR as a GRAS coregulator.
- core_functions directly_involved_in: all three already YAML lists; no change needed.
- Validation:
uv run ai-gene-review validate genes/ARATH/SCR/SCR-ai-review.yaml -> Valid.