ADAMTSL3 (P82987) - analyses supporting the GO annotation review

Generated by analyze_adamtsl3.py. Every number below is recomputed on each run from primary sources (PANTHER PAINT GAFs, UniProt, QuickGO, IntAct); nothing is hardcoded.

1. PAINT projection across PANTHER family PTHR13723

Node-level annotations come from PANTHER's IBD.gaf; the leaf column entries come from gene_association.paint_uniprot.gaf.gz, i.e. the projections PAINT actually exports, not a reconstruction of them.

Curated node annotations in this family:

node GO id evidence negated taxon
PTN000347317 GO:0004222 metalloendopeptidase activity IBD no taxon:
PTN000347317 GO:0006508 proteolysis IBD no taxon:
PTN000347317 GO:0030198 extracellular matrix organization IBD no taxon:
PTN000347317 GO:0031012 extracellular matrix IBD no taxon:
PTN002673039 GO:0004222 metalloendopeptidase activity IKR yes taxon:117571
PTN002673039 GO:0006508 proteolysis IRD yes taxon:117571

Which of those four terms each family member actually receives:

member accession GO:0031012
extracellular matrix
GO:0030198
extracellular matrix organization
GO:0004222
metalloendopeptidase activity
GO:0006508
proteolysis
ADAMTS1 Q9UHI8 is_active_in involved_in enables involved_in
ADAMTS9 Q9P2N4 is_active_in involved_in enables involved_in
ADAMTS10 Q9H324 is_active_in involved_in enables involved_in
ADAMTS17 Q8TE56 is_active_in involved_in enables involved_in
ADAMTSL1 Q8N6G6 - - - -
ADAMTSL2 Q86TH1 is_active_in involved_in NOT -
ADAMTSL3 P82987 is_active_in - - -
ADAMTSL4 Q6UY14 is_active_in involved_in - -
ADAMTSL5 Q6ZMM2 is_active_in - - -
PAPLN O95428 - - - -
THSD4 Q6ZMP0 is_active_in involved_in - -
Adamtsl1_mouse Q8BLI0 is_active_in - - -
Adamtsl2_mouse Q7TSK7 is_active_in involved_in NOT -
Adamtsl3_mouse G3UXC7 is_active_in - - -
Adamtsl4_mouse Q80T21 is_active_in involved_in - -
Papln_mouse Q9EPX2 - - - -
Thsd4_mouse Q3UTY6 is_active_in involved_in - -
madd-4_worm P90884 - - - -

2. Donors behind the single IBA row

GO:0031012 carries 17 WITH/FROM tokens: 16 protein donors (0 self-referential) plus PANTHER tree nodes. 16 of 16 carry their own experimental annotation to GO:0031012 or a descendant.

The specific terms those donors hold experimentally: GO:0001527, GO:0005604, GO:0005614, GO:0031012 - i.e. the donor set is heterogeneous in which matrix compartment it occupies, so the general parent is the least common ancestor rather than a curator failing to be specific.

token resolves to reviewed own experimental evidence for the term
FB:FBgn0003137 [2 candidates] Q868Z9 Ppn (Drosophila melanogaster) Swiss-Prot GO:0005604 IDA (PMID:11076767), GO:0005604 IDA (PMID:3320045)
FB:FBgn0032252 [4 candidates] Q9VKV3 loh (Drosophila melanogaster) TrEMBL GO:0031012 IDA (PMID:23874219)
MGI:MGI:109249 [5 candidates] P97857 Adamts1 (Mus musculus) Swiss-Prot GO:0005604 IDA (PMID:16061471), GO:0031012 IDA (PMID:12907688), GO:0031012 IDA (PMID:9593739)
MGI:MGI:1347346 [5 candidates] Q68SA9 Adamts7 (Mus musculus) Swiss-Prot GO:0031012 IDA (PMID:15192113)
MGI:MGI:1347356 [4 candidates] Q8C9W3 Adamts2 (Mus musculus) Swiss-Prot GO:0031012 IDA (PMID:16556917)
MGI:MGI:1913798 [4 candidates] D3Z689 Adamtsl5 (Mus musculus) TrEMBL GO:0031012 HDA (PMID:22159717), GO:0031012 IDA (PMID:23010571)
MGI:MGI:1925044 [4 candidates] Q7TSK7 Adamtsl2 (Mus musculus) Swiss-Prot GO:0031012 IDA (PMID:17509843)
MGI:MGI:2386139 [3 candidates] Q9EPX2 Papln (Mus musculus) Swiss-Prot GO:0031012 HDA (PMID:22159717), GO:0005604 IDA (PMID:18757743)
MGI:MGI:2389008 [3 candidates] Q80T21 Adamtsl4 (Mus musculus) Swiss-Prot GO:0005614 IDA (PMID:18757743), GO:0031012 IDA (PMID:18757743)
MGI:MGI:2672033 [4 candidates] Q3UTY6 Thsd4 (Mus musculus) Swiss-Prot GO:0001527 IDA (PMID:19940141), GO:0031012 IDA (PMID:19940141)
PANTHER:PTN000347317 PANTHER tree node PTN000347317 (not a protein) - -
RGD:621241 [3 candidates] Q9WUQ1 Adamts1 (Rattus norvegicus) Swiss-Prot GO:0031012 IDA (PMID:15777654)
UniProtKB:Q6ZMM2 Q6ZMM2 ADAMTSL5 (Homo sapiens) Swiss-Prot GO:0031012 IDA (PMID:23010571)
UniProtKB:Q8TE56 Q8TE56 ADAMTS17 (Homo sapiens) Swiss-Prot GO:0031012 IDA (PMID:28176809)
UniProtKB:Q9H324 Q9H324 ADAMTS10 (Homo sapiens) Swiss-Prot GO:0031012 IDA (PMID:21402694)
UniProtKB:Q9P2N4 Q9P2N4 ADAMTS9 (Homo sapiens) Swiss-Prot GO:0031012 IDA (PMID:12514189)
WB:WBGene00003242 O76840 mig-6 (Caenorhabditis elegans) Swiss-Prot GO:0005604 IDA (PMID:19297413)

3. The GO:0005515 partner set

15 IPI rows over 13 distinct partners. Gene-level IntAct detection-method counts for P82987: anti tag coip x15, proximity-dependent biotin identification x1, two hybrid array x16, two hybrid prey pooling approach x16, validated two hybrid x16.

That gene-level tally must not be read as evidence about these 13 pairs. It also covers partners that are not in GOA. Disaggregating per pair is what answers the question, and it is done below.

Every partner resolves to a reviewed Swiss-Prot entry at canonical length: True (no TrEMBL/ORFeome substitutions).

ADAMTSL3 itself has 30 distinct IntAct partners; the median for its 13 annotated partners is 188.

partner length protein name UniProt subcellular location IntAct methods for THIS pair distinct IntAct partners
CYSRT1 (A8MQ03) 144 aa Cysteine-rich tail protein 1 Cornified envelope two hybrid array; two hybrid prey pooling approach; validated two hybrid 516
MDFI (Q99750) 246 aa MyoD family inhibitor Nucleus; Cytoplasm two hybrid array; two hybrid prey pooling approach; validated two hybrid 483
KRT40 (Q6A162) 431 aa Keratin, type I cytoskeletal 40 not annotated two hybrid array; two hybrid prey pooling approach; validated two hybrid 448
KRTAP10-8 (P60410) 259 aa Keratin-associated protein 10-8 not annotated two hybrid array; two hybrid prey pooling approach; validated two hybrid 415
NOTCH2NLA (Q7Z3S9) 236 aa Notch homolog 2 N-terminal-like protein A Secreted; Cytoplasm two hybrid array; two hybrid prey pooling approach; validated two hybrid 276
GLRX3 (O76003) 335 aa Glutaredoxin-3 Cytoplasm, cytosol; Cytoplasm, cell cortex; Cytoplasm, myofibril, sarcomere, Z line two hybrid array; two hybrid prey pooling approach; validated two hybrid 190
KRTAP1-1 (Q07627) 177 aa Keratin-associated protein 1-1 not annotated two hybrid array; two hybrid prey pooling approach; validated two hybrid 188
KRTAP12-3 (P60328) 96 aa Keratin-associated protein 12-3 not annotated two hybrid array; two hybrid prey pooling approach; validated two hybrid 141
KRTAP2-4 (Q9BYR9) 128 aa Keratin-associated protein 2-4 not annotated two hybrid array; two hybrid prey pooling approach; validated two hybrid 89
KRTAP3-2 (Q9BYR7) 98 aa Keratin-associated protein 3-2 not annotated two hybrid array; two hybrid prey pooling approach; validated two hybrid 84
KRTAP10-6 (P60371) 365 aa Keratin-associated protein 10-6 not annotated two hybrid array; two hybrid prey pooling approach; validated two hybrid 77
KRTAP5-7 (Q6L8G8) 165 aa Keratin-associated protein 5-7 not annotated two hybrid array; two hybrid prey pooling approach; validated two hybrid 61
KRTAP2-3 (P0C7H8) 128 aa Keratin-associated protein 2-3 not annotated two hybrid array; two hybrid prey pooling approach; validated two hybrid 10

GOA partners with any non-Y2H detection method: 0 of 13 - every one of these pairs rests on yeast two-hybrid sub-methods alone, with no orthogonal assay.

For contrast, the 17 IntAct partners that are not in GOA are where the other methods live: anti tag coip, proximity-dependent biotin identification, two hybrid array, two hybrid prey pooling approach, validated two hybrid. These are separate publications and are out of scope for this review, but they are why the gene-level method counter cannot settle the question.

4. Review coverage against the GOA table

GOA rows: 18. Reviewed rows derived from GOA: 18. Reviewer-proposed (NEW) rows: 4. Coverage OK: True.

Actions: ACCEPT x2, KEEP_AS_NON_CORE x1, MARK_AS_OVER_ANNOTATED x15, NEW x4.