The research report should be a detailed narrative explaining the function, biological processes, and localization of the gene product. Citations should be given for all claims.
You should prioritize authoritative reviews and primary scientific literature when conducting research. You can supplement
this with annotations you find in gene/protein databases, but these can be outdated or inaccurate.
We are specifically interested in the primary function of the gene - for enzymes, what reaction is catalyzed, and what is the substrate specificity? For transporters, what is the substrate? For structural proteins or adapters, what is the broader structural role? For signaling molecules, what is the role in the pathway.
We are interested in where in or outside the cell the gene product carries out its function.
We are also interested in the signaling or biochemical pathways in which the gene functions. We are less interested in broad pleiotropic effects, except where these elucidate the precise role.
Include evidence where possible. We are interested in both experimental evidence as well as inference from structure, evolution, or bioinformatic analysis. Precise studies should be prioritized over high-throughput, where available.
The requested protein is correctly identified as the Arabidopsis thaliana ζ-carotene desaturase encoded by At3g04870, corresponding to UniProt Q38893. In Arabidopsis literature the same locus is called ZDS/ZDS1, CLB5, SPC1, and PDE181. Mapping, independent mutant alleles, molecular lesions, transgene complementation, and loss of transcript/protein in strong alleles establish this identity. This report does not use results concerning unrelated genes named “ZDS1” in other organisms as evidence for Q38893. (avendanovazquez2014anuncharacterizedapocarotenoidderived pages 2-3, dong2007thearabidopsisspontaneous pages 1-2, avendanovazquez2014anuncharacterizedapocarotenoidderived pages 1-2)
ZDS is a plastid-targeted, FAD-dependent carotene desaturase that performs the second pair of desaturations in the plant poly-cis carotenoid pathway. Its accepted reaction is:
9,15,9′-tri-cis-ζ-carotene → 9,9′-di-cis-neurosporene → 7,9,9′-tri-cis-lycopene (prolycopene),
introducing the 7–8 and 7′–8′ double bonds. The enzyme is assigned EC 1.3.5.6. Prolycopene is subsequently isomerized to all-trans-lycopene, which feeds carotene cyclization and production of photoprotective carotenes, xanthophylls, ABA precursors, and other apocarotenoids. Arabidopsis desaturases expressed heterologously established that higher-plant carotenoid biosynthesis proceeds through this poly-cis route. (rosassaavedra2016biosynthesisofcarotenoids pages 11-14, moreno2021plantapocarotenoidsfrom pages 31-33)
The strongest biological conclusion is that AtZDS is indispensable both for carotenoid metabolic flux and for normal chloroplast differentiation, photoprotection, and plastid-to-nucleus signaling. Strong loss-of-function alleles are albino and seedling-lethal. Importantly, some unusual developmental effects appear to result not merely from carotenoid deficiency but from accumulation of an unidentified upstream cis-carotene-derived signal, commonly designated ACS1. Its chemical identity and biosynthetic mechanism remain unresolved. (escobar‐tovar2021deconvolutingapocarotenoid‐mediatedretrograde pages 5-8, moreno2021plantapocarotenoidsfrom pages 13-15, dong2007thearabidopsisspontaneous pages 1-2)
| Annotation | Best evidence | Confidence / caveat |
|---|---|---|
| Identity and aliases | Direct Arabidopsis evidence: Arabidopsis thaliana locus At3g04870, corresponding to UniProt Q38893, encodes ζ-carotene desaturase and is the locus independently characterized as ZDS/ZDS1, CLB5, SPC1, and PDE181. Three clb5 alleles mapped to this locus; a wild-type 35S:ZDS transgene complemented the phenotype, while strong alleles lacked detectable transcript or protein. The spc1 allelic series independently associated this locus with ζ-carotene desaturase function. (avendanovazquez2014anuncharacterizedapocarotenoidderived pages 2-3, dong2007thearabidopsisspontaneous pages 1-2, avendanovazquez2014anuncharacterizedapocarotenoidderived pages 1-2) | High. Genetic mapping, independent alleles, molecular lesions, complementation, and protein/transcript measurements establish identity. “ZDS1” can denote unrelated genes in other organisms; organism and accession must therefore accompany the symbol. |
| Catalytic function and pathway step | Direct/near-direct Arabidopsis evidence: ZDS performs the second pair of desaturations in the plastid carotenoid pathway, downstream of phytoene desaturase and Z-ISO, converting poly-cis ζ-carotene intermediates toward poly-cis lycopene (prolycopene), which is subsequently isomerized before carotenoid cyclization. The accepted sequence is 9,15,9′-tri-cis-ζ-carotene → 9,9′-di-cis-neurosporene → 7,9,9′-tri-cis-lycopene, introducing double bonds at the 7–8 and 7′–8′ positions; EC 1.3.5.6. Arabidopsis desaturases expressed heterologously in E. coli established a poly-cis route to prolycopene. (rosassaavedra2016biosynthesisofcarotenoids pages 11-14, moreno2021plantapocarotenoidsfrom pages 31-33) | High for pathway role; moderate for exact AtZDS stereochemical sequence from the retrieved evidence. The precise reaction assignment is supported by the 1999 heterologous biochemical study and conserved plant ZDS chemistry, but the available excerpts do not provide purified AtZDS kinetics or numerical substrate-preference measurements. |
| Cofactors, electron transfer, and domains | Plant-family biochemical inference consistent with Q38893: Plant ZDS proteins are membrane-associated, FAD-dependent oxidoreductases. Electrons removed during desaturation are transferred to plastid quinones and ultimately through plastid terminal oxidase (PTOX) to oxygen. This agrees with the stated Q38893 amino-oxidase/FAD–NAD-binding fold, Amino_oxidase (PF01593), and ζ-carotene-desaturase-family annotations. (rosassaavedra2016biosynthesisofcarotenoids pages 11-14) | Moderate to high. Family membership and pathway biochemistry strongly support FAD/quinone coupling, but the retrieved literature does not document direct FAD binding, membrane topology, or electron-acceptor assays using purified At3g04870 protein. |
| Subcellular localization | Direct Arabidopsis evidence: A fusion containing the first 120 amino acids of AtZDS linked to GFP produced punctate/needle-like fluorescence inside chloroplasts, resembling plastoglobule-associated localization. Its plastid targeting is also consistent with carotenoid biosynthesis and the annotated N-terminal transit peptide/precursor status. (avendanovazquez2014anuncharacterizedapocarotenoidderived pages 2-3) | High for chloroplast targeting; moderate for the precise intraplastid compartment. The transit-peptide fusion establishes import into chloroplasts, but resemblance to plastoglobuli is morphological and does not alone prove stable plastoglobule residence or define thylakoid-envelope partitioning of full-length native ZDS. |
| Loss-of-function phenotypes | Direct Arabidopsis evidence: Weak spc1-1 plants show leaf bleaching, mosaic spontaneous cell death, superoxide accumulation, reduced downstream carotenoids, and decreased chlorophyll; strong spc1-2 and null-like clb5 alleles arrest shortly after germination, are albino/seedling-lethal, and display severe defects in chloroplast differentiation, photoprotection, leaf polarity, and cell expansion. Photosynthesis-associated nuclear transcripts such as Lhcb1.1, Lhcb1.4, and RbcS were absent in spc1-2. (avendanovazquez2014anuncharacterizedapocarotenoidderived pages 2-3, dong2007thearabidopsisspontaneous pages 1-2, avendanovazquez2014anuncharacterizedapocarotenoidderived pages 1-2) | High. Multiple alleles and complementation connect the phenotypes to AtZDS. These broad effects arise both from loss of downstream photoprotective carotenoids and from signaling caused by accumulated upstream intermediates, so not every phenotype reflects the catalytic block alone. |
| Apocarotenoid retrograde signaling | Direct Arabidopsis evidence: clb5 accumulates a still-unidentified signal termed ACS1, proposed to derive from phytofluene and/or ζ-carotenoids. Relative to pds3, clb5 had 2,193 differentially expressed genes—626 induced and 1,567 repressed—and 81% shifted back toward the pds3 state in ccd4 clb5. About 31 of 57 chloroplast 70S ribosomal-protein genes fell by more than 2 log₂-fold, linking the signal to inhibited plastid translation and GUN1-dependent leaf-development signaling. (escobar‐tovar2021deconvolutingapocarotenoid‐mediatedretrograde pages 5-8, escobar‐tovar2021deconvolutingapocarotenoid‐mediatedretrograde pages 8-10) | High for existence of a ZDS-block-dependent retrograde-signaling state; low to moderate for ACS1 identity and biosynthetic mechanism. Reviews note that CCD4 cannot directly cleave relevant cis-ζ-carotene isomers under tested conditions, so rescue by ccd4 may be indirect. The active molecule remains chemically unidentified. (moreno2021plantapocarotenoidsfrom pages 13-15) |
| Applications and real-world relevance | Direct Arabidopsis use: AtZDS mutants are research tools for dissecting carotenoid metabolism, chloroplast biogenesis, plastid translation, photoprotection, and plastid-to-nucleus signaling. Comparative tomato evidence—not direct evidence about Q38893 physiology: Arabidopsis ZDS overexpression bypassed endogenous tomato ZDS co-suppression, identifying ZDS as an engineering bottleneck in fruit carotenogenesis. Tomato ZDS-RNAi fruit accumulated 21.7–78.9 μg g⁻¹ FW ζ-carotene versus 0.3 μg g⁻¹ in wild type, while lycopene declined to 1.1–2.0 μg g⁻¹ from 105.7 μg g⁻¹ and ABA fell by at least 75%. (mcquinn2020manipulationofzds pages 5-6) | High for experimental utility; moderate for crop-engineering translation. The tomato results demonstrate potential control of fruit color, carotenoid composition, and ABA-linked development, but they concern a different species and do not establish an approved agricultural implementation. Strong AtZDS suppression is generally deleterious because downstream carotenoids are indispensable. |
Table: Evidence-weighted annotation of Arabidopsis thaliana At3g04870 (UniProt Q38893), separating direct Arabidopsis findings from plant-family inference and comparative tomato data. Confidence notes identify unresolved issues such as the chemical identity and production mechanism of ACS1.
The evidence supports the following identity:
The 2014 CLB5 study characterized three lesions: clb5-1, a nonsense allele; clb5-2, a 28-bp deletion affecting splicing; and clb5-3, a conserved Lys-to-Glu substitution. A wild-type 35S:ZDS construct rescued the mutant phenotype, while clb5-1 and clb5-2 lacked detectable ZDS transcript and protein. These findings provide stronger locus identification than symbol matching alone. (avendanovazquez2014anuncharacterizedapocarotenoidderived pages 2-3)
The independent spc1 allelic series reached the same functional assignment. The weak spc1-1 allele retained partial function, whereas spc1-2 produced severe early arrest and seedling lethality. Thus, the aliases describe alleles or discovery contexts at the same Arabidopsis ZDS locus, not separate proteins. (dong2007thearabidopsisspontaneous pages 1-2)
ZDS is an oxidoreductase of the central carotenoid-biosynthesis pathway. PDS first introduces two double bonds into phytoene-derived substrates; Z-ISO adjusts cis/trans geometry; ZDS then introduces two additional conjugated double bonds. The accepted two-step sequence is:
Accordingly, the biologically relevant specificity is for poly-cis, linear C40 carotene intermediates with the appropriate 15-trans configuration rather than for all-trans-ζ-carotene generally. The products remain linear carotenoids; ZDS does not cyclize lycopene or cleave carotenoids. (rosassaavedra2016biosynthesisofcarotenoids pages 11-14)
The 1999 biochemical work by Bartley, Scolnik, and Beyer, using Arabidopsis carotene desaturases expressed in Escherichia coli, established the poly-cis pathway leading to prolycopene. However, the retrieved evidence does not provide purified-Q38893 kinetic constants, turnover numbers, or numerical comparisons among alternative isomers. Therefore, the reaction assignment is strong, while claims about relative catalytic efficiency for individual cis-isomers would exceed the available evidence. (moreno2021plantapocarotenoidsfrom pages 31-33)
Plant ZDS enzymes are FAD-dependent, membrane-associated desaturases. Electrons removed from carotene substrates enter the plastid quinone pool and are ultimately passed through the plastid terminal oxidase system to oxygen. This chemistry is consistent with Q38893’s amino-oxidase/FAD–NAD-binding fold and ζ-carotene-desaturase-family annotations. (rosassaavedra2016biosynthesisofcarotenoids pages 11-14)
The supplied InterPro/Pfam assignments—Amino_oxidase (IPR002937/PF01593), FAD/NAD-binding superfamily (IPR036188), Zeta_caro_desat (IPR014103), and Zeta-carotene-desaturase/oxidoreductase (IPR050464)—therefore align with the literature. Nevertheless, direct FAD-binding stoichiometry, membrane topology, and quinone preference have not been demonstrated in the retrieved studies using purified At3g04870 itself. Those features should be described as strongly supported family-level mechanism rather than Q38893-specific structural measurements.
ZDS acts inside plastids, the site of plant carotenoid biosynthesis. Direct Arabidopsis localization evidence comes from a construct containing the first 120 amino acids of ZDS fused to GFP. It produced punctate or needle-like fluorescence inside chloroplasts, demonstrating that the N terminus contains plastid-targeting information. The pattern resembled plastoglobuli. (avendanovazquez2014anuncharacterizedapocarotenoidderived pages 2-3)
The safest annotation is therefore chloroplast/chromoplast-localized, plastid membrane-associated enzyme. The experiment establishes plastid import but does not, by itself, prove that full-length endogenous ZDS resides exclusively in plastoglobuli rather than partitioning among plastoglobule, thylakoid, or envelope-associated membrane environments. The “precursor” flag is consistent with synthesis in the cytosol followed by N-terminal transit-peptide-dependent import.
ZDS lies between Z-ISO/PDS-dependent cis-carotene formation and carotenoid isomerase-dependent production of cyclizable all-trans-lycopene. Downstream products include α- and β-carotene, lutein and other xanthophylls, photoprotective pigments, and substrates for ABA and diverse apocarotenoid signals. Blocking ZDS therefore has two simultaneous biochemical consequences:
This dual consequence explains why ZDS mutants combine metabolic deficiency—loss of pigments and photoprotection—with signaling phenotypes that differ from some other albino carotenoid mutants. (rosassaavedra2016biosynthesisofcarotenoids pages 11-14, avendanovazquez2014anuncharacterizedapocarotenoidderived pages 1-2)
The 2007 SPC1 study showed that weak spc1-1 plants undergo leaf bleaching, superoxide accumulation, mosaic spontaneous cell death, reduced downstream carotenoids, and reduced chlorophyll. Strong spc1-2 seedlings arrest soon after germination and are lethal. Photosynthesis-associated nuclear genes including Lhcb1.1, Lhcb1.4, and RbcS were undetectable in spc1-2, linking the plastid metabolic defect to retrograde control of nuclear transcription. (dong2007thearabidopsisspontaneous pages 1-2)
The CLB5 work showed very early arrest during proplastid-to-chloroplast differentiation, severe leaf-polarity and cell-expansion defects, and broad disruption of plastid- and nucleus-encoded gene expression. Genetic or pharmacological reduction of upstream PDS activity suppressed important clb5 phenotypes. This is critical mechanistic evidence: the distinctive developmental syndrome is not explained solely by absence of downstream carotenoids; accumulation of an upstream metabolite or derivative is also required. (avendanovazquez2014anuncharacterizedapocarotenoidderived pages 2-3, avendanovazquez2014anuncharacterizedapocarotenoidderived pages 1-2)
The clb5/ZDS block is proposed to permit formation of an unidentified apocarotenoid signal termed ACS1, derived from phytofluene and/or ζ-carotene-related metabolites. ACS1 remodels nuclear expression of chloroplast ribosomal proteins, inhibits plastid translation, and triggers a second, GUN1-dependent developmental pathway that produces the characteristic finger-like or needle-like leaves. Light and an early developmental window are important components of this signaling cascade. (escobar‐tovar2021deconvolutingapocarotenoid‐mediatedretrograde pages 5-8, escobar‐tovar2021deconvolutingapocarotenoid‐mediatedretrograde pages 8-10)
The 2021 transcriptomic analysis found 2,193 differentially expressed genes in clb5 relative to pds3: 626 induced and 1,567 repressed. In the ccd4 clb5 double mutant, 81% of these genes shifted back toward the pds3 expression state. Approximately 31 of 57 genes encoding large- or small-subunit chloroplast 70S ribosomal proteins fell by more than 2 log2-fold; 28 of the affected genes were nuclear-encoded. Plastid proteins including ClpP1 and Rpl2 and photosynthetic proteins RbcL and PetA were strongly reduced, consistent with impaired plastid translation. (escobar‐tovar2021deconvolutingapocarotenoid‐mediatedretrograde pages 5-8, escobar‐tovar2021deconvolutingapocarotenoid‐mediatedretrograde pages 8-10)
The signal’s chemical identity remains unknown. Although genetic rescue by ccd4 initially suggested that CCD4 generates ACS1, authoritative review analysis notes that CCD4 did not cleave the relevant cis-ζ-carotene configurations in tested in-vivo or in-vitro systems. The ccd4 rescue could consequently reflect an indirect metabolic effect rather than direct production of ACS1 by CCD4. (moreno2021plantapocarotenoidsfrom pages 13-15)
Expert interpretation should therefore distinguish two conclusions:
A 2023 Plant Journal study reported that deregulating ZDS in Arabidopsis and tomato exposes carotenoid-derived, partly redundant regulation of floral-meristem identity and function: McQuinn et al., “Deregulation of ζ-carotene desaturase in Arabidopsis and tomato exposes a unique carotenoid-derived redundant regulation of floral meristem identity and function,” published March 2023, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/tpj.16168. This extends interest in ZDS-associated metabolites beyond seedling chloroplast and leaf development to reproductive meristem regulation. However, the full experimental text was not retrievable in the present evidence set, so specific floral counts, metabolite changes, or mechanistic assignments are not asserted here.
Recent research has increasingly treated cis-carotenes as potential regulatory precursors rather than merely pathway intermediates. A relevant 2024 study by Hou et al., published online in November 2023 and in Journal of Experimental Botany volume 75 (2024), investigated how reduced phytoene-synthase activity tunes a cis-carotene-derived signal controlling the PIF3/HY5 module and plastid biogenesis; DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/jxb/erad443. This supports the broader concept that changing flux upstream of ZDS can alter developmental signaling, but it does not chemically identify clb5 ACS1 or change Q38893’s primary enzymatic annotation.
Thus, 2023–2024 work broadens the developmental scope of cis-carotene signaling, while the central unresolved problem remains chemical identification and direct biosynthetic validation of the signal.
Arabidopsis clb5/spc1 alleles are valuable experimental tools for separating three coupled processes:
Because null alleles are severely pleiotropic and often lethal, inducible, partial-loss, tissue-specific, or flux-tuning approaches are more informative than complete knockout for biotechnology.
Comparative work in tomato illustrates ZDS’s engineering potential but must not be mistaken for direct Arabidopsis physiology. Tomato ZDS repression increased ripe-fruit ζ-carotene from 0.3 μg g⁻¹ fresh weight in wild type to 21.7–78.9 μg g⁻¹, while lycopene declined from 105.7 μg g⁻¹ to 1.1–2.0 μg g⁻¹. ABA accumulation in developing repressed fruit was at least 75% lower. Conversely, expression of Arabidopsis ZDS bypassed endogenous tomato co-suppression, supporting the conclusion that ZDS can become a bottleneck in ripening-associated carotenogenesis. (mcquinn2020manipulationofzds pages 5-6)
Potential applications include modification of fruit color, carotenoid composition, nutritional traits, and apocarotenoid/ABA-related development. However, strong ZDS inhibition compromises photoprotective pigments and development; successful implementation would require organ-, stage-, or tissue-specific control. The retrieved evidence establishes experimental proof of concept, not a currently commercialized ZDS1-based Arabidopsis or crop product.
High-confidence annotations are the locus identity, ζ-carotene-desaturase activity, plastid targeting, placement in the poly-cis carotenoid pathway, and necessity for chloroplast development and photoprotection. Genetic complementation, independent alleles, heterologous biochemistry, localization constructs, pigment phenotypes, and transcriptomic data converge on these conclusions. (avendanovazquez2014anuncharacterizedapocarotenoidderived pages 2-3, dong2007thearabidopsisspontaneous pages 1-2, moreno2021plantapocarotenoidsfrom pages 31-33)
Moderate-confidence annotations include the precise native intraplastid membrane compartment and Q38893-specific details of FAD/quinone handling, because these are supported chiefly by family biochemistry and targeting experiments rather than a purified native enzyme structure or membrane-topology study. (rosassaavedra2016biosynthesisofcarotenoids pages 11-14)
Open questions are ACS1’s chemical identity, its immediate carotenoid precursor, whether CCD4 acts directly or indirectly, and how cis-carotene-derived signals intersect with floral-meristem and broader developmental regulation. (moreno2021plantapocarotenoidsfrom pages 13-15)
References
(avendanovazquez2014anuncharacterizedapocarotenoidderived pages 2-3): Aida-Odette Avendaño-Vázquez, Elizabeth Cordoba, Ernesto Llamas, Carolina San Román, Nazia Nisar, Susana De la Torre, Maricela Ramos-Vega, María de la Luz Gutiérrez-Nava, Christopher Ian Cazzonelli, Barry James Pogson, and Patricia León. An uncharacterized apocarotenoid-derived signal generated in ζ-carotene desaturase mutants regulates leaf development and the expression of chloroplast and nuclear genes in arabidopsis[c][w]. Plant Cell, 26:2524-2537, Jun 2014. URL: https://doi.org/10.1105/tpc.114.123349, doi:10.1105/tpc.114.123349. This article has 151 citations and is from a highest quality peer-reviewed journal.
(dong2007thearabidopsisspontaneous pages 1-2): Haili Dong, Yan Deng, Jinye Mu, Qingtao Lu, Yiqin Wang, Yunyuan Xu, Chengcai Chu, Kang Chong, Congming Lu, and Jianru Zuo. The arabidopsis spontaneous cell death1 gene, encoding a ζ-carotene desaturase essential for carotenoid biosynthesis, is involved in chloroplast development, photoprotection and retrograde signalling. Cell Research, 17:458-470, May 2007. URL: https://doi.org/10.1038/cr.2007.37, doi:10.1038/cr.2007.37. This article has 91 citations and is from a domain leading peer-reviewed journal.
(avendanovazquez2014anuncharacterizedapocarotenoidderived pages 1-2): Aida-Odette Avendaño-Vázquez, Elizabeth Cordoba, Ernesto Llamas, Carolina San Román, Nazia Nisar, Susana De la Torre, Maricela Ramos-Vega, María de la Luz Gutiérrez-Nava, Christopher Ian Cazzonelli, Barry James Pogson, and Patricia León. An uncharacterized apocarotenoid-derived signal generated in ζ-carotene desaturase mutants regulates leaf development and the expression of chloroplast and nuclear genes in arabidopsis[c][w]. Plant Cell, 26:2524-2537, Jun 2014. URL: https://doi.org/10.1105/tpc.114.123349, doi:10.1105/tpc.114.123349. This article has 151 citations and is from a highest quality peer-reviewed journal.
(rosassaavedra2016biosynthesisofcarotenoids pages 11-14): Carolina Rosas-Saavedra and Claudia Stange. Biosynthesis of carotenoids in plants: enzymes and color. Sub-cellular biochemistry, 79:35-69, Jan 2016. URL: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-39126-7_2, doi:10.1007/978-3-319-39126-7_2. This article has 136 citations.
(moreno2021plantapocarotenoidsfrom pages 31-33): Juan C. Moreno, Jianing Mi, Yagiz Alagoz, and Salim Al‐Babili. Plant apocarotenoids: from retrograde signaling to interspecific communication. The Plant Journal, 105:351-375, Jan 2021. URL: https://doi.org/10.1111/tpj.15102, doi:10.1111/tpj.15102. This article has 238 citations.
(escobar‐tovar2021deconvolutingapocarotenoid‐mediatedretrograde pages 5-8): Lina Escobar‐Tovar, Julio Sierra, Arihel Hernández‐Muñoz, Ryan P. McQuinn, Sandra Mathioni, Elizabeth Cordoba, Catherine Colas des Francs‐Small, Blake C. Meyers, Barry Pogson, and Patricia León. Deconvoluting apocarotenoid‐mediated retrograde signaling networks regulating plastid translation and leaf development. Mar 2021. URL: https://doi.org/10.1111/tpj.15134, doi:10.1111/tpj.15134. This article has 32 citations.
(moreno2021plantapocarotenoidsfrom pages 13-15): Juan C. Moreno, Jianing Mi, Yagiz Alagoz, and Salim Al‐Babili. Plant apocarotenoids: from retrograde signaling to interspecific communication. The Plant Journal, 105:351-375, Jan 2021. URL: https://doi.org/10.1111/tpj.15102, doi:10.1111/tpj.15102. This article has 238 citations.
(escobar‐tovar2021deconvolutingapocarotenoid‐mediatedretrograde pages 8-10): Lina Escobar‐Tovar, Julio Sierra, Arihel Hernández‐Muñoz, Ryan P. McQuinn, Sandra Mathioni, Elizabeth Cordoba, Catherine Colas des Francs‐Small, Blake C. Meyers, Barry Pogson, and Patricia León. Deconvoluting apocarotenoid‐mediated retrograde signaling networks regulating plastid translation and leaf development. Mar 2021. URL: https://doi.org/10.1111/tpj.15134, doi:10.1111/tpj.15134. This article has 32 citations.
(mcquinn2020manipulationofzds pages 5-6): Ryan P. McQuinn, Nigel E. Gapper, Amanda G. Gray, Silin Zhong, Takayuki Tohge, Zhangjun Fei, Alisdair R. Fernie, and James J. Giovannoni. Manipulation of zds in tomato exposes carotenoid‐ and aba‐specific effects on fruit development and ripening. Plant Biotechnology Journal, 18:2210-2224, Apr 2020. URL: https://doi.org/10.1111/pbi.13377, doi:10.1111/pbi.13377. This article has 68 citations and is from a highest quality peer-reviewed journal.