PTN000532509 is an Enzyme I node that also carries a GO:0008965 IBD seeded by
E. coli PtsI (P08839) and E. coli PtsP (P37177, EI-Ntr). Its 43 GO:0015764 leaf
IBAs (25 taxa) include general PtsI proteins (E. coli, Salmonella, B. subtilis,
S. aureus, Streptococcus, Chlamydia, Mycoplasma, Neisseria and others), the
nitrogen-PTS PtsP/EI-Ntr proteins (E. coli, Salmonella, Yersinia, Geobacter,
Shewanella, Bradyrhizobium, Coxiella, and P. aeruginosa G3XD36), multiphosphoryl
transfer proteins dedicated to other sugars (FruB, E. coli FryA and PtsA),
P. aeruginosa FruI, and PA3760.
| PTN node | node term | n_seeds | leaf IBAs | seed annotation (term, evidence, PMID) | verdict | rationale |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PTN000532509 | GO:0015764 N-acetylglucosamine transport | 1 (sole) | 43 (25 taxa) | GO:0015764, IMP, PMID:18833300 (PseudoCAP) | OVER-SPECIFIC | The seed is sound for PA3760: no growth on GlcNAc, GlcNAc induction and the operon context agree. The node term does not fit the clade. Enzyme I is a general PTS component, so a single sugar substrate is arbitrary for general PtsI. EI-Ntr (PtsP) works in the nitrogen-regulatory PTS, not sugar uptake. FruB, FryA, PtsA and P. aeruginosa FruI belong to systems for other sugars. FruI cannot replace PA3760 for GlcNAc growth, and the FruI mutant is defective only on fructose. The IBD should be withdrawn, or moved to a node confined to the GlcNAc-dedicated fused EIIA-HPr-EI clade if one exists. |
A GO_CENTRAL source defect is filed on the IBA row (CHECK: withdraw or
re-place the IBD). The PseudoCAP IMP row itself is correct, so no PseudoCAP
defect is filed.
Audit of the GO_CENTRAL defect on PTN000532509, which previously argued from
what the other leaves of the Enzyme I node are called. Leaf membership
confirmed with panther_tree.py node PTN000532509 --leaves (43 leaves, 25
taxa); UniProt entries fetched from rest.uniprot.org.
| Leaf | Name and its evidence | Experimental annotations found | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| P08839 (E. coli ptsI) | Curated RecName "Phosphoenolpyruvate-protein phosphotransferase", ECO:0000303 |
PubMed:2960675; EC 2.7.3.9 ECO:0000269 | PubMed:12705838 |
| P37177 (E. coli ptsP, EI-Ntr) | Curated RecName, ECO:0000303 |
PubMed:8973315; EC 2.7.3.9 ECO:0000269 | PubMed:10473571 |
| Q9HY55 (P. aeruginosa PA3562, "fruI") | RecName and EC from ARBA (ECO:0000256 |
ARBA:ARBA00012232) — a predicted name; gene name fruI is ECO:0000313 |
EMBL (submitter) |
| P77439 (E. coli fryA, MTP 1) | RecName ECO:0000305 |
PubMed:11361063; PE 1 | No experimental GO; GO:0008965 ISS |
| P32670 (E. coli ptsA, MTP 2) | RecName ECO:0000303 |
PubMed:7773398; PE 3 | None; GO:0008965 ISS, two NAS rows from ComplexPortal |
| P45597 (X. campestris fruB) | RecName ECO:0000303 |
PubMed:7496537; PE 3 | None; GO:0008965 ISS |
PA3760 itself (Q9HXN5) carries a type-1 PTS EIIA domain (Pfam PF00358,
PROSITE PS51093, PS00371), while all four fused multiphosphoryl leaves carry
the type-2 fructose-class EIIA; P08839 and P37177 carry no EIIA or HPr
domain at all. That domain split, not the names fruB/ptsA/fruI, is what
the node-level objection now rests on, together with the PA3562 growth
phenotype and the experimental non-specificity of E. coli PtsI.
Confidence raised PROBABLE -> CONFIRMED: PMID:18833300 is cached full text and
states the decisive PA3562 fact outright, and the domain content is primary
data checked here.