gene-annotate dashboard LLM annotation (Dark Protein Atlas) External predictions
View prediction review YAML Β· Synpcc7942_0873-dashboard-predictions-review.yaml Β· Review status: COMPLETE
The KBase gene-annotate dashboard (Dark Protein Atlas) LLM call for S. elongatus CP088958.1_900 is "DUF4062 domain-containing protein, putative NACHT-family NTPase." (tier B). Its one GO term is GO:0017111 ribonucleoside triphosphate phosphatase activity (NTPase). The dashboard sequence is identical to PCC 7942 Synpcc7942_0873 (Q31PW6) over its full 362 residues, so the call is scored on Q31PW6. The DUF4062 part of the call is correct. The NTPase part is wrong. Its only basis is the STRING orthogroup label COG5635 ("Predicted NTPase, NACHT family domain"). The protein has no Walker A or Walker B motif and no NACHT or P-loop domain. Among DUF4062 proteins of 450 aa or less, only 1.3% carry a P-loop domain, compared with 86% of longer ones. The NTPase label therefore comes from multidomain DUF4062-NACHT relatives through the shared DUF4062 domain. The DUF4062 domain itself is a TIR-like NAD+ hydrolase (PMID:42146377), and the query keeps its conserved catalytic Glu (Glu83). The predicted activity is thus the wrong kind of hydrolase: an NADase, not an NTPase. The dashboard model did not see this evidence; the preprint postdates the evidence it was given. Dashboard verdict saved: wrong, the author's decision, concurring with a second dashboard reviewer who independently found no NTPase link in CDD or InterPro and read the predicted structure as a TIR domain plus a winged helix. An "overreach" verdict was considered, since the DUF4062 clause is correct and the NTPase extension is hedged and attributed to the COG5635 description, but was not adopted. On either reading the step too far is the same: a propagated orthogroup label became the headline of the annotation, although the STRING block supplying it states the matched homolog's annotation is withheld and is to be used as corroborating context rather than a primary annotation source, and although InterProScan on the query returned DUF4062 alone at 22.7% coverage. The GO term is a separate and harder error: the extractor turned a hedged family name into an unqualified activity term while recording that the trace had rejected ATPase activity. Corrected annotation: "DUF4062 (TIR-like) domain protein, probable NAD+ hydrolase; putative antiphage defence effector; no NTPase domain".
Source documents: genes/SYNE7/Synpcc7942_0873/Synpcc7942_0873-dashboard-prediction-evidence/dashboard_call.json Β· genes/SYNE7/Synpcc7942_0873/Synpcc7942_0873-dashboard-prediction-evidence/dashboard_page.txt Β· genes/SYNE7/Synpcc7942_0873/Synpcc7942_0873-bioinformatics/RESULTS.md
Review score: 2 = concordant with evidence; 1 = uncertain; 0 = discordant with evidence. This is an assessment score, not a model probability.
- file:SYNE7/Synpcc7942_0873/Synpcc7942_0873-bioinformatics/RESULTS.md: "The query has no Walker A motif (GxxxxGK[ST]: 0 hits; relaxed [GA]xxxxGK[ST]: 0 hits; any GK[ST]: 0 hits) and no Walker B motif (hhhhD[DE]: 0 hits)."
- file:SYNE7/Synpcc7942_0873/Synpcc7942_0873-bioinformatics/RESULTS.md: "DUF4062 proteins of 450 aa or less, like this 362-aa protein, almost never carry an NTPase domain."
- PMID:42146377: "In human NWD1, NWD2, TEP1, and NPHP3, the DUF4062 domain lies adjacent to a NACHT ATPase"
- file:SYNE7/Synpcc7942_0873/Synpcc7942_0873-dashboard-prediction-evidence/dashboard_page.txt: "Tier B: the identical STRING homolog provides a named NTPase-family assignment, supporting a qualified family-level annotation alongside the query's DUF4062 domain."