id: MODULE:hif_oxygen_sensing
title: HIF oxygen sensing — prolyl hydroxylation of HIF-alpha by PHD1-3, CRL2(VHL) ubiquitination and degradation, FIH asparaginyl hydroxylation, and HIF-alpha/ARNT dimerisation with p300/CBP; EGLN1/EGLN2/EGLN3/OS9/VHL/ELOB/ELOC/CUL2/RBX1/SAT2/HIF1AN/HIF1A/EPAS1/HIF3A/ARNT/ARNT2/EP300/CREBBP/RACK1/SAT1
description: >-
  Hypoxia-inducible factor (HIF) is the master transcriptional regulator of the metazoan
  response to low oxygen. It is a heterodimer of an oxygen-labile alpha subunit (HIF-1alpha,
  HIF-2alpha/EPAS1, or HIF-3alpha) and a constitutive bHLH-PAS beta subunit (ARNT, also called
  HIF-1beta, or its paralog ARNT2). The oxygen signal is read by two families of
  Fe(II)- and 2-oxoglutarate-dependent dioxygenases that use molecular O2 as a cosubstrate, so
  their activity falls as oxygen falls. The prolyl hydroxylases PHD1, PHD2 and PHD3 (EGLN2,
  EGLN1 and EGLN3) hydroxylate two prolines in the oxygen-dependent degradation domain of the
  alpha subunit. trans-4-Hydroxyproline creates the recognition mark for the von Hippel-Lindau
  protein (VHL), the substrate receptor of a cullin-2 RING ubiquitin ligase (CRL2) in which the
  Elongin B/C module (ELOB, ELOC) bridges VHL's VHL-box to the CUL2 scaffold and the RING
  subunit RBX1 transfers ubiquitin. Polyubiquitinated HIF-alpha is destroyed by the proteasome,
  giving the protein a half-life of minutes in oxygenated cells. In parallel, the asparaginyl
  hydroxylase FIH (HIF1AN) hydroxylates a conserved asparagine in the C-terminal
  transactivation domain, which blocks binding of the coactivators p300 (EP300) and CBP
  (CREBBP) and so silences the fraction of alpha subunit that escapes degradation. When oxygen
  is scarce both hydroxylations fail: the alpha subunit accumulates, enters the nucleus,
  dimerises with ARNT through its bHLH and PAS domains, binds hypoxia response elements and
  recruits p300/CBP to activate transcription of genes for angiogenesis, erythropoiesis,
  glycolysis and iron handling. Several proteins tune the switch without sensing oxygen
  themselves: OS-9 scaffolds HIF-1alpha with the prolyl hydroxylases, SSAT2 (SAT2) stabilises
  the VHL-Elongin C interaction, and RACK1 with SSAT1 (SAT1) recruits the Elongin B/C ligase to
  HIF-1alpha independently of hydroxylation and of VHL. Loss of VHL abolishes degradation and
  gives constitutive HIF activity, the basis of von Hippel-Lindau disease and of clear-cell
  renal carcinoma; EPAS1 and EGLN1 mutations cause erythrocytosis and paraganglioma.
status: DRAFT
scope: CONCRETE
evidence:
  - source_id: PW:0000360
    title: hypoxia inducible factor pathway
    statement: >-
      The module boundary follows the RGD Pathway Ontology term and its interactive diagram.
      The diagram centres on the hydroxylated alpha subunit (drawn as Hif1a+O2) and draws
      Egln1 positively affecting it and associated with Os9; Hif1a+O2 associated with Os9,
      Sat1, Sat2 and Vhl; Hif1an positively affecting Hif1a+O2; Hif1a+O2 negatively affecting
      Crebbp and EP300; Gnb2l1 (Rack1) associated with Hif1a+O2, Sat1 and Tceb1; Sat2
      associated with Tceb1 and Vhl; Tceb1 associated with Vhl and with the Tceb1 recruited
      complex; and the deoxygenated alpha subunit (Hif1a-O2) positively affecting Hif target
      genes, with the labels "Hif-alpha ubiquitination, proteasomal degradation", "P-OH" and
      "N-OH". The record text adds the three alpha genes, the second beta subunit Arnt2, the
      three prolyl hydroxylases with Egln1/Phd2 as the essential one, and the oxygen-independent
      Rack1 route. Derived through projects/RGD_PATHWAY_ONTOLOGY (pathways/PW_0000360.yaml).
  - source_id: GO:0097411
    title: hypoxia-inducible factor-1alpha signaling pathway
    statement: >-
      The curated narrowMatch recorded for PW:0000360 in
      projects/RGD_PATHWAY_ONTOLOGY/data/pw_go_curated.sssom.yaml, and this module's process
      concept. The mapping comment notes that GO:0097411 is HIF-1alpha only while the PW
      pathway also covers HIF-2alpha (EPAS1), which is why the alpha subunit is modelled as a
      variant set rather than as HIF1A alone.
  - source_id: GO:0071456
    title: cellular response to hypoxia
    statement: >-
      The curated broadMatch recorded for PW:0000360 in the same SSSOM file. It is the parent
      process under which GO:0097411 sits (GO:0097411 part_of GO:0071456), and the process the
      human GO-CAM gomodel:689e7a5d00004061 places the HIF1A transcription-factor activity in.
      It is kept as prose context rather than as the module's core concept, since a broad
      cellular-response term is less informative than the signalling-pathway term.
  - source_id: gomodel:689e7a5d00004061
    title: Regulation of Respiratory chain complex I by COXFA4L2 upon hypoxia. (Human)
    statement: >-
      The closest human GO-CAM to this module's transcriptional output: it enables HIF1A
      DNA-binding transcription factor activity, RNA polymerase II-specific (GO:0000981) as part
      of GO:0071456 cellular response to hypoxia, driving COXFA4L2 expression. No production
      GO-CAM models the oxygen-sensing switch itself (checked gocams/index.tsv, October 2026):
      there is no model containing VHL, HIF1AN, EGLN1 or EGLN2, and the only EGLN3 model
      (gomodel:680ad14200007201) hydroxylates GPX4 rather than a HIF alpha subunit.
  - source_id: gomodel:63f809ec00000611
    title: The CRL2(KLHDC10) complex catalyzes ubiquitination via the DesCEND (destruction via C-end degrons) pathway (Human)
    statement: >-
      The CRL2 core of this module (CUL2 ubiquitin ligase complex scaffold activity GO:0160072,
      RBX1 ubiquitin protein ligase activity GO:0061630) is grounded on this curated human
      CRL2 model, which uses a different substrate receptor (KLHDC10 rather than VHL) and
      therefore grounds the scaffold and RING activities, not the substrate choice.
  - source_id: PMID:11292861
    title: Targeting of HIF-alpha to the von Hippel-Lindau ubiquitylation complex by O2-regulated prolyl hydroxylation.
    statement: >-
      The founding result for the module: prolyl hydroxylation of the alpha subunit is the
      oxygen-dependent step that licenses pVHL binding, and the hydroxylase is the oxygen sensor.
    supporting_text: An absolute requirement for dioxygen as a cosubstrate and iron as cofactor suggests that HIF-PH functions directly as a cellular oxygen sensor.
  - source_id: PMID:11823643
    title: Asparagine hydroxylation of the HIF transactivation domain a hypoxic switch.
    statement: >-
      Establishes the second, transcription-blocking hydroxylation as a part of the same switch,
      so the module has two oxygen-sensing arms rather than one.
    supporting_text: Full induction of HIF-1alpha and -2alpha, therefore, relies on the abrogation of both Pro and Asn hydroxylation, which during normoxia occur at the degradation and COOH-terminal transactivation domains, respectively.
  - source_id: PMID:10353251
    title: The tumour suppressor protein VHL targets hypoxia-inducible factors for oxygen-dependent proteolysis.
    statement: >-
      Places pVHL in the degradation arm and shows that losing it is sufficient for constitutive
      HIF activity, which is why the ligase is a part of the module and not external regulation.
    supporting_text: In VHL-defective cells, HIF alpha-subunits are constitutively stabilized and HIF-1 is activated.
  - source_id: PMID:7539918
    title: Hypoxia-inducible factor 1 is a basic-helix-loop-helix-PAS heterodimer regulated by cellular O2 tension.
    statement: >-
      The heterodimer definition, and the basis for modelling the beta subunit as a shared,
      constitutive partner that also serves other bHLH-PAS factors.
    supporting_text: HIF-1 beta is a series of ARNT gene products, which can thus heterodimerize with either HIF-1 alpha or AHR.
  - source_id: PMID:8917528
    title: An essential role for p300/CBP in the cellular response to hypoxia.
    statement: >-
      p300/CBP recruitment is the transcriptional output step that the asparaginyl hydroxylation
      arm switches off, so both coactivators are modelled as parts.
    supporting_text: Hypoxic conditions lead to the formation of a DNA binding complex containing both HIF-1 alpha and p300/CBP.
notes: >-
  Derived from the RGD Pathway Ontology diagram PW:0000360 through the RGD_PATHWAY_ONTOLOGY
  project's diagram->module route. RGD curates 20 human genes to PW:0000360 (ARNT ARNT2 CREBBP
  CUL2 EGLN1 EGLN2 EGLN3 ELOB ELOC EP300 EPAS1 HIF1A HIF1AN HIF3A OS9 RACK1 RBX1 SAT1 SAT2 VHL).
  All 20 are modelled here. The mapped GO process GO:0097411 is the module's core concept and
  the broader GO:0071456 is kept as prose; both mappings come from the project's curated SSSOM
  file. The fly counterpart is modules/dmel_hif_complex.yaml, which models only the Sima-Tgo
  heterodimer (the FlyBase HIF gene group) and explicitly leaves the oxygen sensor Fatiga (Hph)
  and the VHL ligase out as regulators; this mammalian module takes the opposite boundary,
  because the RGD pathway is the sensing-and-degradation switch and the heterodimer is one step
  inside it. Nothing is duplicated between the two: the fly module is referenced here only in
  prose, since cross-species inclusion by module_ref would assert an identity between the fly
  complex and the human one that this module does not need.

  Molecular functions were taken from each protein's experimental GO annotations in QuickGO
  (checked 2026-10-28) and, where a gene review exists, cross-checked against its core
  functions. EGLN1, EGLN2 and EGLN3 all carry GO:0160082 hypoxia-inducible factor-proline
  dioxygenase activity (EGLN1 EXP/IDA and the core function of the completed EGLN1 review;
  EGLN2 and EGLN3 EXP), whose definition and Rhea xref RHEA:48400 are exactly the reaction this
  module's first step performs; the parent GO:0031545 peptidyl-proline 4-dioxygenase activity
  was not used for the HIF reaction, although it is the term the Reactome HIF reactions map to
  and the term the EGLN3 GO-CAM uses for its GPX4 substrate. HIF1AN carries GO:0036140
  [protein]-asparagine 3-dioxygenase activity (IDA/IMP; RHEA:54260). VHL carries GO:1990756
  ubiquitin-like ligase-substrate adaptor activity (IDA), ELOC GO:0030674
  protein-macromolecule adaptor activity (IBA; core in the ELOC review), ELOB GO:0031625
  ubiquitin protein ligase binding (IDA; core in the ELOB review), CUL2 GO:0160072 ubiquitin
  ligase complex scaffold activity (IDA) and RBX1 GO:0061630 ubiquitin protein ligase activity
  (IDA; core in the RBX1 review). The alpha subunits carry GO:0000981 DNA-binding transcription
  factor activity, RNA polymerase II-specific (HIF1A IDA, HIF3A IDA, EPAS1 IBA/ISA), the term
  both human HIF1A GO-CAMs use; the more specific GO:0001228 DNA-binding transcription
  activator activity, RNA polymerase II-specific is available for HIF1A (IDA/IMP) but not
  experimentally for EPAS1 or HIF3A, and HIF3A's IPAS variant is a repressor, so the shared
  parent is used across the variant set. ARNT and ARNT2 carry GO:0046982 protein
  heterodimerization activity (both IDA; core in the ARNT review) — the beta subunit's role
  here is to provide the dimerisation partner and the composite DNA-binding surface, and its
  own GO:0000981 annotation is contributes_to (IDA) rather than enables. EP300 and CREBBP carry
  GO:0003713 transcription coactivator activity (IDA; core in both reviews).

  Boundary decisions. (1) Target genes are out of scope. VEGFA and EPO are the outputs the
  pathway acts on, not participants: they bind no HIF, hydroxylate nothing and carry no
  signalling activity, exactly the substrate-versus-participant distinction CLAUDE.md requires.
  RGD draws them behind a single "Hif target genes" sub-page link rather than as genes, and
  neither is in the PW:0000360 gene list. (2) OS9, SAT2, RACK1 and SAT1 are modelled as
  regulatory parts rather than relegated to context, because each has a primary paper with
  gain- and loss-of-function evidence placing it in a physical complex with HIF-1alpha and with
  a named component of the degradation machinery (OS-9 with the prolyl hydroxylases,
  PMID:15721254; SSAT2 with VHL and Elongin C, PMID:17558023; RACK1 with Elongin C,
  PMID:17244529; SSAT1 with RACK1, PMID:17875644). None of the four has a GO molecular function
  that describes this role: OS9's only experimental MF is GO:0140032 glycosylation-dependent
  protein binding (IDA), from its ERAD lectin function; SAT1 and SAT2 carry only their
  polyamine acetyltransferase activity GO:0004145 (and SAT2 also a NOT|enables GO:0004145 IDA
  row, reflecting the dispute over whether it acetylates spermidine at all), which is not the
  activity at work here; RACK1's adaptor role is captured only by the broad GO:0060090
  molecular adaptor activity (TAS; core in the RACK1 review, which already records HIF1A as a
  client). Their annotons therefore carry a preferred_term and evidence but no GO identifier,
  except RACK1 where the broad adaptor term is used, rather than asserting a plausible-looking
  term the ontology does not support. This is a candidate for proposed new terms once the
  scaffolding roles are better characterised. (3) The oxygen-independent arm (RACK1 + SAT1) is
  marked optional: it operates on the same substrate but is not required for the oxygen switch,
  and it was defined largely through HSP90 inhibition. (4) HIF3A is modelled as a third alpha
  variant rather than as a separate inhibitory module. Its full-length product is a
  hydroxylation-regulated, ARNT-dimerising transcription factor (GO:0000981 IDA, GO:0000978
  IDA) that lacks a C-terminal transactivation domain, and its short IPAS splice variant is a
  dominant-negative that sequesters HIF-1alpha (PMID:11734856). Both readings are recorded on
  the annoton; splitting the locus into two modules would overstate how well the isoform
  repertoire is resolved. (5) HSP90, which competes with RACK1 for the PAS-A domain, is left
  out: it is a general chaperone whose involvement is shown mainly through inhibitor treatment,
  and including it would pull the HSP90 cycle into the module. The same applies to the HIF
  target-gene feedback on EGLN1 (PHD2 is itself HIF-inducible) and to the 2-oxoglutarate and
  ascorbate supply that all four dioxygenases need. (6) The Elongin B/C module is modelled as
  two explicit annotons, not folded into a complex descriptor, because both ELOB and ELOC have
  completed gene reviews whose core functions are exactly these adaptor activities, and because
  the same module serves CRL5 ligases elsewhere (see modules/reelin_signaling.yaml, whose
  CRL5(SOCS7) part omits Elongin B/C following its GO-CAM). The generic cullin-RING machinery
  is not re-modelled here: neddylation, the CAND1/CSN cycle and the proteasome itself are
  outside the boundary, and the 26S proteasome step is recorded as a process term on the ligase
  annotons rather than as a part.

  GO-CAM and GOA observations for upstream review. No production GO-CAM covers the oxygen
  sensor: gocams/index.tsv (October 2026) has no model containing VHL, HIF1AN, EGLN1, EGLN2,
  ELOB, ELOC, EPAS1, HIF3A, OS9, SAT1 or SAT2, and the two HIF1A models
  (gomodel:689e7a5d00004061, gomodel:689e7a5d00004412) use HIF1A only as the transcription
  factor downstream of COXFA4L2. This is the largest curation gap the module reveals. In GOA,
  GO:0097411 hypoxia-inducible factor-1alpha signaling pathway is carried in human, mouse and
  rat by CYBB, PDK1, PDK3, mouse Hif1a and miR-210, but by none of EGLN1-3, VHL, HIF1AN, ARNT,
  EP300 or CREBBP; EGLN1 and mouse Vhl instead carry the regulatory term GO:1902072 negative
  regulation of hypoxia-inducible factor-1alpha signaling pathway, which is the convention this
  module follows (the hydroxylase and the ligase regulate the pathway rather than being part of
  it), so no NEW pathway annotations are proposed for them here. SAT2's human GOA carries both
  enables and NOT|enables GO:0004145 by IDA from different references, which is worth an
  upstream look. Gene reviews exist for ARNT, EGLN1, ELOB, ELOC, RBX1, EP300, CREBBP, RACK1 and
  SAT1; HIF1A, EPAS1, HIF3A, ARNT2, VHL, EGLN2, EGLN3, HIF1AN, CUL2, OS9 and SAT2 have none,
  and PANTHER family ids and PTNs are deliberately not asserted.
module:
  id: hif_oxygen_sensing
  label: HIF oxygen-sensing switch
  module_type: SIGNALING_PATHWAY
  concepts:
    - preferred_term: hypoxia-inducible factor-1alpha signaling pathway
      term:
        id: GO:0097411
        label: hypoxia-inducible factor-1alpha signaling pathway
      description: >-
        The signalling pathway mapped to PW:0000360. The GO term names HIF-1alpha, while this
        module covers all three alpha subunits; the extra coverage is recorded in the alpha
        variant set rather than by using a broader term.
  context:
    taxa:
      - preferred_term: Homo sapiens
        term:
          id: NCBITaxon:9606
          label: Homo sapiens
    cellular_components:
      - preferred_term: cytosol
        term:
          id: GO:0005829
          label: cytosol
        description: >-
          Where the prolyl hydroxylases (PHD2 is predominantly cytoplasmic) and the CRL2(VHL)
          ligase act on the alpha subunit.
      - preferred_term: nucleus
        term:
          id: GO:0005634
          label: nucleus
        description: >-
          Where the stabilised alpha subunit dimerises with ARNT, binds hypoxia response
          elements and recruits p300/CBP. Both compartments are listed because the switch is
          spatially split, not because one is a refinement of the other.
  parts:
    - order: 1
      role: oxygen-dependent prolyl hydroxylation of the HIF-alpha degradation domain
      node:
        id: hif_prolyl_hydroxylation
        label: Prolyl hydroxylation of HIF-alpha by PHD1-3 (EGLN2/EGLN1/EGLN3)
        module_type: REACTION
        description: >-
          Fe(II)- and 2-oxoglutarate-dependent dioxygenases hydroxylate two prolines in the
          oxygen-dependent degradation domain of HIF-alpha (Pro402 and Pro564 of HIF-1alpha),
          consuming O2 and 2-oxoglutarate and releasing succinate and CO2. Because O2 is a
          cosubstrate with a Km near the physiological range, the rate of this reaction is the
          cell's oxygen reading. The three paralogues catalyse the same chemistry and differ in
          abundance, localisation and site preference; PHD2 (EGLN1) sets the normoxic
          steady-state level of HIF-1alpha.
        concepts:
          - preferred_term: peptidyl-proline hydroxylation to 4-hydroxy-L-proline
            term:
              id: GO:0018401
              label: peptidyl-proline hydroxylation to 4-hydroxy-L-proline
        evidence:
          - source_id: PMID:11292861
            statement: >-
              Hydroxylation of HIF-1alpha Pro564 by a prolyl hydroxylase regulates the pVHL
              interaction.
            supporting_text: Here we show that the interaction between human pVHL and a specific domain of the HIF-1alpha subunit is regulated through hydroxylation of a proline residue (HIF-1alpha P564) by an enzyme we have termed HIF-alpha prolyl-hydroxylase (HIF-PH).
          - source_id: PMID:11598268
            statement: >-
              The hydroxylases form a conserved family (the EGLN/PHD proteins) that is an
              essential component of the oxygen-sensing pathway.
            supporting_text: We identified a conserved family of HIF prolyl hydoxylase (HPH) enzymes that appear to be responsible for this posttranslational modification.
          - source_id: RHEA:48400
            statement: >-
              L-prolyl-[hypoxia-inducible factor alpha subunit] + 2-oxoglutarate + O2 =
              trans-4-hydroxy-L-prolyl-[hypoxia-inducible factor alpha subunit] + succinate +
              CO2; the Rhea xref of GO:0160082 and EC 1.14.11.29.
        variant_sets:
          - id: phd_paralog
            label: HIF prolyl hydroxylase paralogue
            axis: enzyme paralogue (PHD1/PHD2/PHD3, differing in abundance, localisation and site preference)
            selection: ONE_OR_MORE
            variants:
              - id: egln1_phd2_variant
                label: PHD2 (EGLN1) — the dominant normoxic sensor
                module_type: REACTION
                annotons:
                  - id: egln1_hif_prolyl_hydroxylase
                    label: EGLN1 (PHD2) hypoxia-inducible factor-proline dioxygenase activity
                    participant:
                      selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
                      gene_product:
                        preferred_term: EGLN1 (PHD2)
                        term:
                          id: UniProtKB:Q9GZT9
                          label: Egl nine homolog 1
                    function:
                      preferred_term: hypoxia-inducible factor-proline dioxygenase activity
                      term:
                        id: GO:0160082
                        label: hypoxia-inducible factor-proline dioxygenase activity
                      substrates:
                        - preferred_term: L-prolyl-[HIF alpha subunit]
                          term:
                            id: CHEBI:50342
                            label: L-proline residue
                        - preferred_term: 2-oxoglutarate
                          term:
                            id: CHEBI:16810
                            label: 2-oxoglutarate(2-)
                        - preferred_term: O2
                          term:
                            id: CHEBI:15379
                            label: dioxygen
                      products:
                        - preferred_term: trans-4-hydroxy-L-prolyl-[HIF alpha subunit]
                          term:
                            id: CHEBI:61965
                            label: trans-4-hydroxy-L-proline residue
                        - preferred_term: succinate
                          term:
                            id: CHEBI:30031
                            label: succinate(2-)
                        - preferred_term: CO2
                          term:
                            id: CHEBI:16526
                            label: carbon dioxide
                      targets:
                        - preferred_term: HIF-1alpha
                          term:
                            id: UniProtKB:Q16665
                            label: Hypoxia-inducible factor 1-alpha
                        - preferred_term: HIF-2alpha (EPAS1)
                          term:
                            id: UniProtKB:Q99814
                            label: Endothelial PAS domain-containing protein 1
                    processes:
                      - preferred_term: negative regulation of hypoxia-inducible factor-1alpha signaling pathway
                        term:
                          id: GO:1902072
                          label: negative regulation of hypoxia-inducible factor-1alpha signaling pathway
                    locations:
                      - preferred_term: cytosol
                        term:
                          id: GO:0005829
                          label: cytosol
                    role_description: >-
                      The non-redundant oxygen sensor in cultured cells: silencing PHD2 alone
                      stabilises and activates HIF-1alpha in normoxia, while silencing PHD1 or
                      PHD3 does not. Its core function in the completed EGLN1 gene review is
                      this activity, with GO:1902072 as the process.
                    evidence:
                      - source_id: PMID:12912907
                        statement: PHD2 knockdown alone is sufficient to stabilise HIF-1alpha in normoxia.
                        supporting_text: Here we show that specific 'silencing' of PHD2 with short interfering RNAs is sufficient to stabilize and activate HIF-1alpha in normoxia in all the human cells investigated.
                      - source_id: PMID:12912907
                        statement: PHD1 and PHD3 knockdown has no such effect, so the paralogues are not interchangeable.
                        supporting_text: "'Silencing' of PHD1 and PHD3 has no effect on the stability of HIF-1alpha either in normoxia or upon re-oxygenation of cells briefly exposed to hypoxia."
              - id: egln2_phd1_variant
                label: PHD1 (EGLN2)
                module_type: REACTION
                annotons:
                  - id: egln2_hif_prolyl_hydroxylase
                    label: EGLN2 (PHD1) hypoxia-inducible factor-proline dioxygenase activity
                    participant:
                      selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
                      gene_product:
                        preferred_term: EGLN2 (PHD1)
                        term:
                          id: UniProtKB:Q96KS0
                          label: Prolyl hydroxylase EGLN2
                    function:
                      preferred_term: hypoxia-inducible factor-proline dioxygenase activity
                      term:
                        id: GO:0160082
                        label: hypoxia-inducible factor-proline dioxygenase activity
                      targets:
                        - preferred_term: HIF-1alpha
                          term:
                            id: UniProtKB:Q16665
                            label: Hypoxia-inducible factor 1-alpha
                    locations:
                      - preferred_term: nucleus
                        term:
                          id: GO:0005634
                          label: nucleus
                    role_description: >-
                      Predominantly nuclear paralogue, oestrogen-inducible, with a preference
                      for the N-terminal degradation site. Dispensable for the normoxic
                      set-point in cultured cells.
                    evidence:
                      - source_id: PMID:11598268
                        statement: >-
                          Forced expression of an HPH family member attenuates normoxic
                          HIF-1alpha accumulation, the assay that defines the family's activity.
                        supporting_text: In cultured mammalian cells, inappropriate accumulation of HIF caused by forced expression of the HIF-1alpha subunit under normoxic conditions was attenuated by coexpression of HPH.
              - id: egln3_phd3_variant
                label: PHD3 (EGLN3)
                module_type: REACTION
                annotons:
                  - id: egln3_hif_prolyl_hydroxylase
                    label: EGLN3 (PHD3) hypoxia-inducible factor-proline dioxygenase activity
                    participant:
                      selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
                      gene_product:
                        preferred_term: EGLN3 (PHD3)
                        term:
                          id: UniProtKB:Q9H6Z9
                          label: Prolyl hydroxylase EGLN3
                    function:
                      preferred_term: hypoxia-inducible factor-proline dioxygenase activity
                      term:
                        id: GO:0160082
                        label: hypoxia-inducible factor-proline dioxygenase activity
                      targets:
                        - preferred_term: HIF-1alpha
                          term:
                            id: UniProtKB:Q16665
                            label: Hypoxia-inducible factor 1-alpha
                        - preferred_term: HIF-2alpha (EPAS1)
                          term:
                            id: UniProtKB:Q99814
                            label: Endothelial PAS domain-containing protein 1
                    locations:
                      - preferred_term: cytosol
                        term:
                          id: GO:0005829
                          label: cytosol
                    role_description: >-
                      Strongly hypoxia-inducible paralogue with a preference for the C-terminal
                      degradation site and a marked preference for HIF-2alpha; also hydroxylates
                      non-HIF substrates, which is what the only EGLN3 GO-CAM
                      (gomodel:680ad14200007201, GPX4) models.
                    evidence:
                      - source_id: PMID:11598268
                        statement: >-
                          The family was defined by the ability of its members to oppose normoxic
                          HIF accumulation, and loss of the fly orthologue derepresses a
                          hypoxia-inducible gene.
                        supporting_text: Suppression of HPH in cultured Drosophila melanogaster cells by RNA interference resulted in elevated expression of a hypoxia-inducible gene (LDH, encoding lactate dehydrogenase) under normoxic conditions.
    - order: 2
      role: scaffolding that promotes hydroxylation (oxygen-independent)
      optional: true
      node:
        id: os9_hydroxylation_scaffold
        label: OS-9 scaffolding of HIF-1alpha with the prolyl hydroxylases
        module_type: REGULATORY_STEP
        description: >-
          OS-9 binds both HIF-1alpha and the prolyl hydroxylases and raises the efficiency of
          hydroxylation and hence of VHL capture. It does not sense oxygen itself; removing it
          raises HIF-1alpha levels and HIF target-gene expression in non-hypoxic cells.
        annotons:
          - id: os9_scaffold
            label: OS-9 scaffold for HIF-1alpha prolyl hydroxylation
            participant:
              selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
              gene_product:
                preferred_term: OS9
                term:
                  id: UniProtKB:Q13438
                  label: Protein OS-9
            function:
              preferred_term: HIF-1alpha prolyl hydroxylase scaffold (no GO molecular function term)
              description: >-
                No GO molecular function describes this role. OS9's only experimental MF is
                GO:0140032 glycosylation-dependent protein binding (IDA), from its ERAD lectin
                function, which is a different activity; no identifier is asserted rather than
                choosing a plausible-looking term.
              targets:
                - preferred_term: HIF-1alpha
                  term:
                    id: UniProtKB:Q16665
                    label: Hypoxia-inducible factor 1-alpha
                - preferred_term: EGLN1 (PHD2)
                  term:
                    id: UniProtKB:Q9GZT9
                    label: Egl nine homolog 1
            role_description: >-
              Multiprotein-complex component that couples the substrate to the sensor; its loss
              is a gain of HIF signalling, not a loss.
            evidence:
              - source_id: PMID:15721254
                statement: OS-9 binds both HIF-1alpha and the HIF-1alpha prolyl hydroxylases.
                supporting_text: Here, we demonstrate that OS-9, the protein product of a widely expressed gene, interacts with both HIF-1alpha and HIF-1alpha prolyl hydroxylases.
              - source_id: PMID:15721254
                statement: OS-9 gain of function promotes hydroxylation, VHL binding and degradation.
                supporting_text: OS-9 gain-of-function promotes HIF-1alpha hydroxylation, VHL binding, proteasomal degradation of HIF-1alpha, and inhibition of HIF-1-mediated transcription.
    - order: 3
      role: recognition of hydroxyproline and ubiquitination by CRL2(VHL)
      node:
        id: crl2_vhl_degradation
        label: CRL2(VHL) recognition and ubiquitination of hydroxylated HIF-alpha
        module_type: REGULATORY_STEP
        description: >-
          pVHL binds the hydroxyprolyl degradation domain through a single hydroxyproline pocket
          in its beta-domain, with an affinity three orders of magnitude higher than for the
          unmodified peptide, while its alpha-domain (VHL-box) binds the Elongin B/C module.
          Elongin C bridges to the CUL2 scaffold, which carries the RING subunit RBX1; RBX1
          recruits a ubiquitin-charged E2 and the alpha subunit is polyubiquitinated and
          degraded by the 26S proteasome.
        concepts:
          - preferred_term: VCB complex
            term:
              id: GO:0030891
              label: VCB complex
          - preferred_term: Cul2-RING ubiquitin ligase complex
            term:
              id: GO:0031462
              label: Cul2-RING ubiquitin ligase complex
          - preferred_term: proteasome-mediated ubiquitin-dependent protein catabolic process
            term:
              id: GO:0043161
              label: proteasome-mediated ubiquitin-dependent protein catabolic process
        evidence:
          - source_id: PMID:11292862
            statement: pVHL binding requires the hydroxylated proline, making hydroxylation the recognition mark.
            supporting_text: We found that human pVHL binds to a short HIF-derived peptide when a conserved proline residue at the core of this peptide is hydroxylated.
          - source_id: PMID:12050673
            statement: >-
              The VCB (pVHL-elongin C-elongin B) structure shows one conserved hydroxyproline
              pocket that discriminates hydroxylated from unmodified prolyl residues.
            supporting_text: The crystal structure of a hydroxylated HIF-1 alpha peptide bound to VCB (pVHL, elongins C and B) and solution binding assays reveal a single, conserved hydroxyproline-binding pocket in pVHL.
          - source_id: PMID:12004076
            statement: The hydroxyproline inserts into a gap in the pVHL hydrophobic core that is a tumour-mutation hotspot.
            supporting_text: The hydroxyproline inserts into a gap in the pVHL hydrophobic core, at a site that is a hotspot for tumorigenic mutations, with its 4-hydroxyl group recognized by buried serine and histidine residues.
        annotons:
          - id: vhl_substrate_adaptor
            label: VHL substrate receptor for hydroxylated HIF-alpha
            participant:
              selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
              gene_product:
                preferred_term: VHL
                term:
                  id: UniProtKB:P40337
                  label: von Hippel-Lindau disease tumor suppressor
            function:
              preferred_term: ubiquitin-like ligase-substrate adaptor activity
              term:
                id: GO:1990756
                label: ubiquitin-like ligase-substrate adaptor activity
              targets:
                - preferred_term: hydroxyprolyl HIF-1alpha
                  term:
                    id: UniProtKB:Q16665
                    label: Hypoxia-inducible factor 1-alpha
                - preferred_term: hydroxyprolyl HIF-2alpha (EPAS1)
                  term:
                    id: UniProtKB:Q99814
                    label: Endothelial PAS domain-containing protein 1
            processes:
              - preferred_term: proteasome-mediated ubiquitin-dependent protein catabolic process
                term:
                  id: GO:0043161
                  label: proteasome-mediated ubiquitin-dependent protein catabolic process
            locations:
              - preferred_term: cytosol
                term:
                  id: GO:0005829
                  label: cytosol
            role_description: >-
              The oxygen-dependent substrate receptor of the ligase: it reads the
              hydroxyproline mark with its beta-domain and delivers the alpha subunit to the
              cullin. Its loss, in VHL disease and clear-cell renal carcinoma, gives
              constitutive HIF activity.
            evidence:
              - source_id: PMID:10878807
                statement: pVHL binds HIF directly through its beta-domain and targets it for ubiquitination, acting like an F-box substrate receptor.
                supporting_text: Here we show that pVHL, through its beta-domain, binds directly to hypoxia-inducible factor (HIF), thereby targeting HIF for ubiquitination in an alpha-domain-dependent manner.
              - source_id: PMID:10878807
                statement: The function of pVHL in this complex is to recruit the substrate to the ubiquitination machinery.
                supporting_text: Furthermore, we provide the first direct evidence that pVHL has a function analogous to that of an F-box protein, namely, to recruit substrates to a ubiquitination machine.
          - id: eloc_adaptor
            label: Elongin C (ELOC) adaptor bridging VHL to CUL2
            participant:
              selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
              gene_product:
                preferred_term: ELOC
                term:
                  id: UniProtKB:Q15369
                  label: Elongin-C
            function:
              preferred_term: protein-macromolecule adaptor activity
              term:
                id: GO:0030674
                label: protein-macromolecule adaptor activity
            processes:
              - preferred_term: protein ubiquitination
                term:
                  id: GO:0016567
                  label: protein ubiquitination
            locations:
              - preferred_term: cytosol
                term:
                  id: GO:0005829
                  label: cytosol
            role_description: >-
              SKP1-like adaptor that binds the VHL-box and the CUL2 N-terminal domain; this
              adaptor activity is the core function of the completed ELOC gene review, which
              names the VHL-ELOB/ELOC-CUL2-RBX1 ligase explicitly.
            evidence:
              - source_id: PMID:9122164
                statement: CUL2 association requires an intact trimeric pVHL-elongin B-C complex, so Elongin C is the bridge.
                supporting_text: The pVHL-Hs-CUL-2 association is strictly dependent on the integrity of the trimeric VBC complex.
          - id: elob_adaptor
            label: Elongin B (ELOB) ubiquitin-like partner of Elongin C
            participant:
              selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
              gene_product:
                preferred_term: ELOB
                term:
                  id: UniProtKB:Q15370
                  label: Elongin-B
            function:
              preferred_term: ubiquitin protein ligase binding
              term:
                id: GO:0031625
                label: ubiquitin protein ligase binding
            processes:
              - preferred_term: protein ubiquitination
                term:
                  id: GO:0016567
                  label: protein ubiquitination
            locations:
              - preferred_term: cytosol
                term:
                  id: GO:0005829
                  label: cytosol
            role_description: >-
              Ubiquitin-like subunit that stabilises Elongin C and is part of the crystallised
              VCB complex; this ligase-binding activity is the core function of the completed
              ELOB gene review.
            evidence:
              - source_id: PMID:9122164
                statement: pVHL forms a stable complex with elongin B and elongin C, the trimer that CUL2 then joins.
                supporting_text: The VHL protein (pVHL) has been shown to form a stable complex with elongin B and elongin C, two factors that stabilize and activate the transcription elongation factor elongin A.
          - id: cul2_scaffold
            label: CUL2 ubiquitin ligase complex scaffold
            participant:
              selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
              gene_product:
                preferred_term: CUL2
                term:
                  id: UniProtKB:Q13617
                  label: Cullin-2
            function:
              preferred_term: ubiquitin ligase complex scaffold activity
              term:
                id: GO:0160072
                label: ubiquitin ligase complex scaffold activity
            processes:
              - preferred_term: proteasome-mediated ubiquitin-dependent protein catabolic process
                term:
                  id: GO:0043161
                  label: proteasome-mediated ubiquitin-dependent protein catabolic process
            locations:
              - preferred_term: cytosol
                term:
                  id: GO:0005829
                  label: cytosol
            role_description: >-
              Cullin scaffold that holds the VHL-Elongin B/C substrate-receptor module at one
              end and RBX1 at the other.
            evidence:
              - source_id: PMID:9122164
                statement: CUL2 associates specifically with the pVHL-elongin B-C complex in vitro and in vivo.
                supporting_text: Here, Hs-CUL-2, a member of the recently identified multigene family, the cullins, is shown to specifically associate with the trimeric pVHL-elongin B-C (VBC) complex in vitro and in vivo.
            gocam_associations:
              - model: gomodel:63f809ec00000611
                activity: gomodel:63f809ec00000611/63f809ec00000619
                title: CUL2 ubiquitin ligase complex scaffold activity (GO:0160072) in a curated human CRL2 complex
                description: >-
                  Grounds the CUL2 scaffold activity in a production GO-CAM. That model's
                  substrate receptor is KLHDC10, not VHL, so it grounds the scaffold role and
                  not the substrate choice.
          - id: rbx1_ring_ligase
            label: RBX1 RING ubiquitin ligase activity on HIF-alpha
            participant:
              selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
              gene_product:
                preferred_term: RBX1
                term:
                  id: UniProtKB:P62877
                  label: E3 ubiquitin-protein ligase RBX1
            function:
              preferred_term: ubiquitin protein ligase activity
              term:
                id: GO:0061630
                label: ubiquitin protein ligase activity
              targets:
                - preferred_term: hydroxyprolyl HIF-1alpha
                  term:
                    id: UniProtKB:Q16665
                    label: Hypoxia-inducible factor 1-alpha
            processes:
              - preferred_term: proteasome-mediated ubiquitin-dependent protein catabolic process
                term:
                  id: GO:0043161
                  label: proteasome-mediated ubiquitin-dependent protein catabolic process
            locations:
              - preferred_term: cytosol
                term:
                  id: GO:0005829
                  label: cytosol
            role_description: >-
              RING subunit that positions the ubiquitin-charged E2 over the substrate; this
              activity, with proteasomal degradation as its process, is a core function of the
              completed RBX1 gene review.
            evidence:
              - source_id: PMID:10353251
                statement: >-
                  The alpha subunits are rapidly destroyed by the proteasome in oxygenated cells
                  and the VHL complex is required for that destruction.
                supporting_text: The alpha subunits of HIF are rapidly degraded by the proteasome under normal conditions, but are stabilized by hypoxia.
            gocam_associations:
              - model: gomodel:63f809ec00000611
                activity: gomodel:63f809ec00000611/63f809ec00000627
                title: RBX1 ubiquitin protein ligase activity (GO:0061630) in a curated human CRL2 complex
                description: >-
                  As for CUL2: grounds the RING activity within a CRL2 complex whose substrate
                  receptor is KLHDC10 rather than VHL.
    - order: 4
      role: stabilisation of the VHL-Elongin C interaction (oxygen-independent)
      optional: true
      node:
        id: sat2_vhl_stabilisation
        label: SSAT2 (SAT2) stabilisation of the VHL-Elongin C interaction
        module_type: REGULATORY_STEP
        description: >-
          SSAT2 makes multivalent contacts with HIF-1alpha, VHL and Elongin C and stabilises the
          VHL-Elongin C interaction, which is needed for the very rapid ubiquitination of the
          hydroxylated alpha subunit seen in oxygenated cells. Its polyamine
          acetyltransferase activity is not the activity at work here.
        annotons:
          - id: sat2_complex_stabiliser
            label: SSAT2 (SAT2) stabiliser of the VHL-Elongin C interaction
            participant:
              selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
              gene_product:
                preferred_term: SAT2 (SSAT2)
                term:
                  id: UniProtKB:Q96F10
                  label: Thialysine N-epsilon-acetyltransferase
            function:
              preferred_term: VHL-Elongin C interaction stabiliser (no GO molecular function term)
              description: >-
                No GO molecular function describes this role; SAT2's annotated activity is
                GO:0004145 diamine N-acetyltransferase activity, which is a different activity
                (and itself carries a NOT|enables IDA row in human GOA). No identifier is
                asserted.
              targets:
                - preferred_term: VHL
                  term:
                    id: UniProtKB:P40337
                    label: von Hippel-Lindau disease tumor suppressor
                - preferred_term: ELOC
                  term:
                    id: UniProtKB:Q15369
                    label: Elongin-C
            role_description: >-
              Accessory subunit of the ubiquitination complex in oxygenated cells; acts on the
              oxygen-dependent route, in contrast to its paralogue SSAT1.
            evidence:
              - source_id: PMID:17558023
                statement: SSAT2 binds HIF-1alpha, VHL and Elongin C and stabilises the VHL-Elongin C interaction.
                supporting_text: SSAT2 binds to HIF-1alpha, VHL, and Elongin C and promotes ubiquitination of hydroxylated HIF-1alpha by stabilizing the interaction of VHL and Elongin C.
              - source_id: PMID:17558023
                statement: The multivalent contacts are proposed to make complex formation efficient enough for the observed degradation rate.
                supporting_text: Multivalent interactions by SSAT2 provide a mechanism to ensure efficient complex formation, which is necessary for the extremely rapid ubiquitination and degradation of HIF-1alpha that is observed in oxygenated cells.
    - order: 5
      role: oxygen-dependent asparaginyl hydroxylation that silences the transactivation domain
      node:
        id: fih_asparaginyl_hydroxylation
        label: Asparaginyl hydroxylation of the HIF-alpha C-TAD by FIH (HIF1AN)
        module_type: REACTION
        description: >-
          FIH hydroxylates a conserved asparagine (Asn803 of HIF-1alpha, Asn851 of HIF-2alpha)
          in the C-terminal transactivation domain, using O2 and 2-oxoglutarate as cosubstrates
          like the prolyl hydroxylases. 3-Hydroxyasparagine prevents the C-TAD from binding the
          CH1 domain of p300/CBP, so the alpha subunit that escapes degradation is still
          transcriptionally silent. The two hydroxylations are independent, and the alpha subunit
          becomes fully active only when both fail. FIH is not part of a feedback loop: like the
          prolyl hydroxylases it is a constitutive enzyme whose rate is set by oxygen
          availability.
        concepts:
          - preferred_term: protein hydroxylation
            term:
              id: GO:0018126
              label: protein hydroxylation
        evidence:
          - source_id: PMID:12080085
            statement: FIH-1 is the asparaginyl hydroxylase, an Fe(II)-dependent enzyme using molecular O2.
            supporting_text: Like known hydroxylase enzymes, FIH-1 is an Fe(II)-dependent enzyme that uses molecular O(2) to modify its substrate.
          - source_id: RHEA:54260
            statement: >-
              L-asparaginyl-[protein] + 2-oxoglutarate + O2 = (3S)-3-hydroxy-L-asparaginyl-[protein]
              + succinate + CO2; a Rhea xref of GO:0036140 and EC 1.14.11.30.
        annotons:
          - id: hif1an_asparaginyl_hydroxylase
            label: HIF1AN (FIH) [protein]-asparagine 3-dioxygenase activity
            participant:
              selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
              gene_product:
                preferred_term: HIF1AN (FIH-1)
                term:
                  id: UniProtKB:Q9NWT6
                  label: Hypoxia-inducible factor 1-alpha inhibitor
            function:
              preferred_term: '[protein]-asparagine 3-dioxygenase activity'
              term:
                id: GO:0036140
                label: '[protein]-asparagine 3-dioxygenase activity'
              substrates:
                - preferred_term: L-asparaginyl-[HIF alpha C-TAD]
                  term:
                    id: CHEBI:50347
                    label: L-asparagine residue
                - preferred_term: 2-oxoglutarate
                  term:
                    id: CHEBI:16810
                    label: 2-oxoglutarate(2-)
                - preferred_term: O2
                  term:
                    id: CHEBI:15379
                    label: dioxygen
              products:
                - preferred_term: (3S)-3-hydroxy-L-asparaginyl-[HIF alpha C-TAD]
                  term:
                    id: CHEBI:138107
                    label: (3S)-3-hydroxy-L-asparagine residue
                - preferred_term: succinate
                  term:
                    id: CHEBI:30031
                    label: succinate(2-)
                - preferred_term: CO2
                  term:
                    id: CHEBI:16526
                    label: carbon dioxide
              targets:
                - preferred_term: HIF-1alpha C-terminal transactivation domain
                  term:
                    id: UniProtKB:Q16665
                    label: Hypoxia-inducible factor 1-alpha
                - preferred_term: HIF-2alpha (EPAS1) C-terminal transactivation domain
                  term:
                    id: UniProtKB:Q99814
                    label: Endothelial PAS domain-containing protein 1
            processes:
              - preferred_term: negative regulation of hypoxia-inducible factor-1alpha signaling pathway
                term:
                  id: GO:1902072
                  label: negative regulation of hypoxia-inducible factor-1alpha signaling pathway
            locations:
              - preferred_term: nucleus
                term:
                  id: GO:0005634
                  label: nucleus
            role_description: >-
              The transactivation-domain oxygen sensor. Unlike the prolyl hydroxylases it does
              not change the alpha subunit's abundance, only its ability to recruit
              coactivators; it also carries a transcription corepressor activity annotation
              (GO:0003714, IDA) consistent with that role.
            evidence:
              - source_id: PMID:11823643
                statement: Hypoxic induction of the C-TAD works by abolishing hydroxylation of a conserved asparagine in it.
                supporting_text: We now show that hypoxic induction of the COOH-terminal transactivation domain (CAD) of HIF occurs through abrogation of hydroxylation of a conserved asparagine in the CAD.
              - source_id: PMID:11823643
                statement: Blocking the dioxygenase lets the C-TAD bind p300, and an Asn-to-Ala substitution makes the interaction constitutive.
                supporting_text: Inhibitors of Fe(II)- and 2-oxoglutarate-dependent dioxygenases prevented hydroxylation of the Asn, thus allowing the CAD to interact with the p300 transcription coactivator.
    - order: 6
      role: HIF-alpha/ARNT dimerisation and hypoxia response element binding
      node:
        id: hif_dimerisation
        label: HIF-alpha/ARNT heterodimer binding hypoxia response elements
        module_type: REGULATORY_STEP
        description: >-
          When hydroxylation fails, the alpha subunit escapes the ligase, accumulates and enters
          the nucleus, where its bHLH and PAS domains pair with those of the constitutive beta
          subunit. The heterodimer binds the hypoxia response element (RCGTG core) of target
          genes; neither subunit binds productively alone, so sequence-specific DNA binding is a
          property of the dimer. The beta subunit is shared with other bHLH-PAS factors,
          including the aryl hydrocarbon receptor, and is not oxygen-regulated.
        concepts:
          - preferred_term: RNA polymerase II transcription regulator complex
            term:
              id: GO:0090575
              label: RNA polymerase II transcription regulator complex
          - preferred_term: positive regulation of transcription by RNA polymerase II
            term:
              id: GO:0045944
              label: positive regulation of transcription by RNA polymerase II
        evidence:
          - source_id: PMID:7539918
            statement: Both subunits are bHLH-PAS proteins, and the alpha subunit is the oxygen-regulated one.
            supporting_text: We show that both HIF-1 subunits are basic-helix-loop-helix proteins containing a PAS domain, defined by its presence in the Drosophila Per and Sim proteins and in the mammalian ARNT and AHR proteins.
        variant_sets:
          - id: hif_alpha_subunit
            label: HIF alpha subunit
            axis: oxygen-regulated alpha subunit paralogue (expression pattern and target repertoire)
            selection: ONE_OR_MORE
            variants:
              - id: hif1a_variant
                label: HIF-1alpha (HIF1A)
                module_type: REGULATORY_STEP
                annotons:
                  - id: hif1a_transcription_factor
                    label: HIF1A DNA-binding transcription factor activity
                    participant:
                      selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
                      gene_product:
                        preferred_term: HIF1A (HIF-1alpha)
                        term:
                          id: UniProtKB:Q16665
                          label: Hypoxia-inducible factor 1-alpha
                    function:
                      preferred_term: DNA-binding transcription factor activity, RNA polymerase II-specific
                      term:
                        id: GO:0000981
                        label: DNA-binding transcription factor activity, RNA polymerase II-specific
                    processes:
                      - preferred_term: cellular response to hypoxia
                        term:
                          id: GO:0071456
                          label: cellular response to hypoxia
                    locations:
                      - preferred_term: nucleus
                        term:
                          id: GO:0005634
                          label: nucleus
                    role_description: >-
                      The broadly expressed alpha subunit and the one the pathway is named for;
                      it carries the two hydroxylated prolines and the hydroxylated asparagine,
                      so it is both the sensor's substrate and the dimer's activator.
                    evidence:
                      - source_id: PMID:7539918
                        statement: HIF-1 alpha and beta protein levels track oxygen tension, consistent with HIF-1 mediating the hypoxic transcriptional response.
                        supporting_text: HIF-1 alpha and HIF-1 beta (ARNT) RNA and protein levels were induced in cells exposed to 1% O2 and decayed rapidly upon return of the cells to 20% O2, consistent with the role of HIF-1 as a mediator of transcriptional responses to hypoxia.
                    gocam_associations:
                      - model: gomodel:689e7a5d00004061
                        activity: gomodel:689e7a5d00004061/689e7a5d00004268
                        title: HIF1A DNA-binding transcription factor activity, RNA polymerase II-specific (GO:0000981), part of GO:0071456 cellular response to hypoxia
                      - model: gomodel:689e7a5d00004412
                        activity: gomodel:689e7a5d00004412/689e7a5d00004413
                        title: HIF1A DNA-binding transcription factor activity, RNA polymerase II-specific (GO:0000981) in the lactate/COXFA4L2 model
              - id: epas1_variant
                label: HIF-2alpha (EPAS1)
                module_type: REGULATORY_STEP
                annotons:
                  - id: epas1_transcription_factor
                    label: EPAS1 (HIF-2alpha) DNA-binding transcription factor activity
                    participant:
                      selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
                      gene_product:
                        preferred_term: EPAS1 (HIF-2alpha)
                        term:
                          id: UniProtKB:Q99814
                          label: Endothelial PAS domain-containing protein 1
                    function:
                      preferred_term: DNA-binding transcription factor activity, RNA polymerase II-specific
                      term:
                        id: GO:0000981
                        label: DNA-binding transcription factor activity, RNA polymerase II-specific
                    processes:
                      - preferred_term: cellular response to hypoxia
                        term:
                          id: GO:0071456
                          label: cellular response to hypoxia
                    locations:
                      - preferred_term: nucleus
                        term:
                          id: GO:0005634
                          label: nucleus
                    role_description: >-
                      The restricted-expression alpha subunit (endothelium, kidney interstitium,
                      carotid body, hepatocytes), regulated by the same hydroxylations but with
                      a partly distinct target repertoire including EPO; gain-of-function
                      mutations in its degradation domain cause erythrocytosis and
                      paraganglioma.
                    evidence:
                      - source_id: PMID:9000051
                        statement: EPAS1 binds and activates a hypoxia response element and is stimulated by hypoxia.
                        supporting_text: Activation by both HIF-1alpha and EPAS1 is stimulated by hypoxic conditions.
                      - source_id: PMID:9000051
                        statement: EPAS1 heterodimerises with ARNT before activating transcription.
                        supporting_text: EPAS1 forms a heterodimeric complex with the aryl hydrocarbon nuclear transporter prior to transcriptional activation of target genes.
              - id: hif3a_variant
                label: HIF-3alpha (HIF3A), including the inhibitory IPAS variant
                module_type: REGULATORY_STEP
                annotons:
                  - id: hif3a_transcription_factor
                    label: HIF3A DNA-binding transcription factor activity and IPAS dominant-negative role
                    participant:
                      selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
                      gene_product:
                        preferred_term: HIF3A (HIF-3alpha / IPAS)
                        term:
                          id: UniProtKB:Q9Y2N7
                          label: Hypoxia-inducible factor 3-alpha
                    function:
                      preferred_term: DNA-binding transcription factor activity, RNA polymerase II-specific
                      term:
                        id: GO:0000981
                        label: DNA-binding transcription factor activity, RNA polymerase II-specific
                    locations:
                      - preferred_term: nucleus
                        term:
                          id: GO:0005634
                          label: nucleus
                    role_description: >-
                      The least understood alpha locus, and the only one whose products act in
                      both directions. Full-length HIF-3alpha dimerises with ARNT and binds
                      hypoxia response elements (GO:0000981 and GO:0000978 by IDA) but lacks a
                      C-terminal transactivation domain, so it is a weak activator; the short
                      splice variant IPAS has no transactivation function and acts as a
                      dominant-negative on HIF-mediated gene expression. Modelled as one annoton
                      with both readings rather than as a separate module, because the isoform
                      repertoire is not resolved.
                    evidence:
                      - source_id: PMID:11734856
                        statement: The IPAS splice variant of this locus is a dominant-negative regulator of HIF-driven transcription.
                        supporting_text: IPAS contains no endogenous transactivation function but demonstrates dominant negative regulation of HIF-mediated control of gene expression.
                      - source_id: PMID:11734856
                        statement: Ectopic IPAS selectively impairs hypoxic induction of HIF target genes such as VEGF.
                        supporting_text: Ectopic expression of IPAS in hepatoma cells selectively impairs induction of genes involved in adaptation to a hypoxic environment, notably the vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) gene, and results in retarded tumour growth and tumour vascular density in vivo.
          - id: hif_beta_subunit
            label: HIF beta subunit (ARNT family)
            axis: constitutive bHLH-PAS partner paralogue (tissue distribution)
            selection: ONE_OR_MORE
            variants:
              - id: arnt_variant
                label: ARNT (HIF-1beta)
                module_type: REGULATORY_STEP
                annotons:
                  - id: arnt_heterodimer
                    label: ARNT protein heterodimerization activity with HIF-alpha
                    participant:
                      selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
                      gene_product:
                        preferred_term: ARNT (HIF-1beta)
                        term:
                          id: UniProtKB:P27540
                          label: Aryl hydrocarbon receptor nuclear translocator
                    function:
                      preferred_term: protein heterodimerization activity
                      term:
                        id: GO:0046982
                        label: protein heterodimerization activity
                      targets:
                        - preferred_term: HIF-1alpha
                          term:
                            id: UniProtKB:Q16665
                            label: Hypoxia-inducible factor 1-alpha
                        - preferred_term: HIF-2alpha (EPAS1)
                          term:
                            id: UniProtKB:Q99814
                            label: Endothelial PAS domain-containing protein 1
                    processes:
                      - preferred_term: response to hypoxia
                        term:
                          id: GO:0001666
                          label: response to hypoxia
                    locations:
                      - preferred_term: nucleus
                        term:
                          id: GO:0005634
                          label: nucleus
                    role_description: >-
                      The constitutive, non-oxygen-regulated partner. Its heterodimerization
                      activity is a core function of the completed ARNT review, which also keeps
                      the hypoxia-response annotations; the same subunit serves the aryl
                      hydrocarbon receptor, so ARNT is not specific to this module.
                    evidence:
                      - source_id: PMID:7539918
                        statement: The beta subunit is an ARNT gene product that can dimerise with HIF-1alpha or with AHR.
                        supporting_text: HIF-1 beta is a series of ARNT gene products, which can thus heterodimerize with either HIF-1 alpha or AHR.
              - id: arnt2_variant
                label: ARNT2
                module_type: REGULATORY_STEP
                annotons:
                  - id: arnt2_heterodimer
                    label: ARNT2 protein heterodimerization activity
                    participant:
                      selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
                      gene_product:
                        preferred_term: ARNT2
                        term:
                          id: UniProtKB:Q9HBZ2
                          label: Aryl hydrocarbon receptor nuclear translocator 2
                    function:
                      preferred_term: protein heterodimerization activity
                      term:
                        id: GO:0046982
                        label: protein heterodimerization activity
                      targets:
                        - preferred_term: HIF-1alpha
                          term:
                            id: UniProtKB:Q16665
                            label: Hypoxia-inducible factor 1-alpha
                    locations:
                      - preferred_term: nucleus
                        term:
                          id: GO:0005634
                          label: nucleus
                    role_description: >-
                      Second beta subunit, expressed mainly in brain and kidney, with
                      overlapping but not identical partner specificity. Modelled as an
                      alternative beta variant on the strength of its own experimental
                      heterodimerization and HRE-binding annotations (GO:0046982 IDA,
                      GO:0000981 IDA, GO:1990837 IDA) and the RGD record's statement that a
                      second beta subunit with possibly overlapping functions exists; how much
                      of the hypoxic response in those tissues runs through ARNT2 rather than
                      ARNT is a knowledge gap.
    - order: 7
      role: coactivator recruitment and transactivation
      node:
        id: coactivator_recruitment
        label: Recruitment of p300 (EP300) and CBP (CREBBP) by the HIF-alpha C-TAD
        module_type: REGULATORY_STEP
        description: >-
          The unhydroxylated C-terminal transactivation domain of the alpha subunit binds the
          CH1/TAZ1 domain of the paralogous acetyltransferase coactivators p300 and CBP, which
          bridge to the RNA polymerase II machinery and acetylate chromatin at hypoxia response
          elements. This is the step the FIH arm blocks, and it is where the switch becomes
          transcription.
        concepts:
          - preferred_term: positive regulation of transcription by RNA polymerase II
            term:
              id: GO:0045944
              label: positive regulation of transcription by RNA polymerase II
        annotons:
          - id: ep300_coactivator
            label: EP300 (p300) transcription coactivator activity for HIF
            participant:
              selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
              gene_product:
                preferred_term: EP300 (p300)
                term:
                  id: UniProtKB:Q09472
                  label: Histone acetyltransferase p300
            function:
              preferred_term: transcription coactivator activity
              term:
                id: GO:0003713
                label: transcription coactivator activity
              targets:
                - preferred_term: HIF-1alpha
                  term:
                    id: UniProtKB:Q16665
                    label: Hypoxia-inducible factor 1-alpha
            processes:
              - preferred_term: positive regulation of transcription by RNA polymerase II
                term:
                  id: GO:0045944
                  label: positive regulation of transcription by RNA polymerase II
            locations:
              - preferred_term: nucleus
                term:
                  id: GO:0005634
                  label: nucleus
            role_description: >-
              The coactivator originally cloned as a HIF-1alpha partner; its coactivator
              activity is a core function of the completed EP300 review, whose
              response-to-hypoxia annotations are kept as non-core, matching the treatment here
              of p300 as a shared coactivator recruited by this pathway rather than a dedicated
              component.
            evidence:
              - source_id: PMID:8917528
                statement: Hypoxia produces a DNA-binding complex containing HIF-1alpha and p300/CBP.
                supporting_text: Hypoxic conditions lead to the formation of a DNA binding complex containing both HIF-1 alpha and p300/CBP.
              - source_id: PMID:8917528
                statement: >-
                  p300 is limiting for hypoxic transcription; ectopic p300 enhances it and E1A
                  sequestration inhibits it.
                supporting_text: Hypoxia-induced transcription from the Epo promoter was specifically enhanced by ectopic p300 and inhibited by E1A binding to p300/CBP.
          - id: crebbp_coactivator
            label: CREBBP (CBP) transcription coactivator activity for HIF
            participant:
              selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
              gene_product:
                preferred_term: CREBBP (CBP)
                term:
                  id: UniProtKB:Q92793
                  label: CREB-binding protein
            function:
              preferred_term: transcription coactivator activity
              term:
                id: GO:0003713
                label: transcription coactivator activity
              targets:
                - preferred_term: HIF-1alpha
                  term:
                    id: UniProtKB:Q16665
                    label: Hypoxia-inducible factor 1-alpha
            processes:
              - preferred_term: positive regulation of transcription by RNA polymerase II
                term:
                  id: GO:0045944
                  label: positive regulation of transcription by RNA polymerase II
            locations:
              - preferred_term: nucleus
                term:
                  id: GO:0005634
                  label: nucleus
            role_description: >-
              Paralogue of p300, largely redundant with it for HIF transactivation and assayed
              together with it in the original work; coactivator activity is a core function of
              the completed CREBBP review.
            evidence:
              - source_id: PMID:8917528
                statement: p300 and CBP are homologous coactivators assayed together as p300/CBP in the hypoxic response.
                supporting_text: p300 and CBP are homologous transcription adapters targeted by the E1A oncoprotein.
    - order: 8
      role: oxygen-independent HIF-1alpha turnover (RACK1 route)
      optional: true
      node:
        id: oxygen_independent_turnover
        label: RACK1/SSAT1-dependent, VHL-independent ubiquitination of HIF-1alpha
        module_type: REGULATORY_STEP
        description: >-
          A second route to the same Elongin B/C ligase does not read hydroxyproline at all.
          RACK1 competes with HSP90 for the PAS-A domain of HIF-1alpha and, when bound, recruits
          the Elongin C ubiquitin-ligase complex, so HIF-1alpha is degraded independently of
          oxygen, of the prolyl hydroxylases and of VHL. SSAT1 stabilises the HIF-1alpha-RACK1
          interaction, mirroring what its paralogue SSAT2 does for VHL-Elongin C. Marked
          optional: this arm modulates the set-point but is not required for the oxygen switch,
          and much of the evidence comes from HSP90 inhibition.
        annotons:
          - id: rack1_eloc_adaptor
            label: RACK1 adaptor recruiting Elongin C to HIF-1alpha
            participant:
              selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
              gene_product:
                preferred_term: RACK1
                term:
                  id: UniProtKB:P63244
                  label: Small ribosomal subunit protein RACK1
            function:
              preferred_term: molecular adaptor activity
              term:
                id: GO:0060090
                label: molecular adaptor activity
              targets:
                - preferred_term: HIF-1alpha
                  term:
                    id: UniProtKB:Q16665
                    label: Hypoxia-inducible factor 1-alpha
                - preferred_term: ELOC
                  term:
                    id: UniProtKB:Q15369
                    label: Elongin-C
            processes:
              - preferred_term: proteasome-mediated ubiquitin-dependent protein catabolic process
                term:
                  id: GO:0043161
                  label: proteasome-mediated ubiquitin-dependent protein catabolic process
            locations:
              - preferred_term: cytosol
                term:
                  id: GO:0005829
                  label: cytosol
            role_description: >-
              Functional analogue of VHL on this route: it occupies the substrate-receptor
              position without recognising a hydroxyproline, and its Elongin C-binding site
              resembles VHL's. The broad GO:0060090 molecular adaptor activity is the only term
              that fits; it is a core function of the completed RACK1 review, which already
              records HIF1A as a degradation client. RACK1's main cellular role is ribosomal,
              so this is a peripheral activity for the protein but a real part of this module.
            evidence:
              - source_id: PMID:17244529
                statement: RACK1 binds Elongin C and promotes HIF-1alpha ubiquitination.
                supporting_text: RACK1 binds to Elongin-C and promotes ubiquitination of HIF-1alpha.
              - source_id: PMID:17244529
                statement: >-
                  The route is independent of oxygen, the prolyl hydroxylases and VHL, and works
                  by competition with HSP90 for the PAS-A domain.
                supporting_text: Thus, RACK1 is an essential component of an O(2)/PHD/VHL-independent mechanism for regulating HIF-1alpha stability through competition with HSP90 and recruitment of the Elongin-C/B ubiquitin ligase complex.
          - id: sat1_rack1_stabiliser
            label: SSAT1 (SAT1) stabiliser of the HIF-1alpha-RACK1 interaction
            participant:
              selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
              gene_product:
                preferred_term: SAT1 (SSAT1)
                term:
                  id: UniProtKB:P21673
                  label: Diamine acetyltransferase 1
            function:
              preferred_term: HIF-1alpha-RACK1 interaction stabiliser (no GO molecular function term)
              description: >-
                No GO molecular function describes this role; SAT1's annotated and reviewed core
                activity is GO:0004145 diamine N-acetyltransferase activity in polyamine
                catabolism, a different activity. No identifier is asserted.
              targets:
                - preferred_term: HIF-1alpha
                  term:
                    id: UniProtKB:Q16665
                    label: Hypoxia-inducible factor 1-alpha
                - preferred_term: RACK1
                  term:
                    id: UniProtKB:P63244
                    label: Small ribosomal subunit protein RACK1
            role_description: >-
              Paralogue-mirrored accessory role: SSAT1 serves the oxygen-independent route as
              SSAT2 serves the oxygen-dependent one.
            evidence:
              - source_id: PMID:17875644
                statement: SSAT1 binds HIF-1alpha and promotes its degradation by stabilising the HIF-1alpha-RACK1 interaction.
                supporting_text: However, in contrast to SSAT2, SSAT1 acts by stabilizing the interaction of HIF-1alpha with RACK1.
              - source_id: PMID:17875644
                statement: The two paralogues are complementary, one oxygen-independent and one oxygen-dependent.
                supporting_text: Thus, the paralogs SSAT1 and SSAT2 play complementary roles in promoting O(2)-independent and O(2)-dependent degradation of HIF-1alpha.
  connections:
    - source: hif_prolyl_hydroxylation
      target: crl2_vhl_degradation
      connection_type: PROVIDES_INPUT_FOR
      description: >-
        trans-4-Hydroxyproline in the oxygen-dependent degradation domain is the mark that pVHL
        reads; without it the ligase does not engage the alpha subunit.
      chaining_status: NOT_APPLICABLE
      chaining_note: >-
        The intermediate is a modified protein residue, not a CoA thioester, so the CoA
        continuity check does not apply. The continuity that matters here is
        trans-4-hydroxy-L-proline residue (CHEBI:61965), the product of RHEA:48400 and the
        ligand of the pVHL hydroxyproline pocket.
    - source: os9_hydroxylation_scaffold
      target: hif_prolyl_hydroxylation
      connection_type: POSITIVELY_REGULATES
      description: OS-9 brings the substrate and the hydroxylases together, raising hydroxylation efficiency.
    - source: sat2_vhl_stabilisation
      target: crl2_vhl_degradation
      connection_type: POSITIVELY_REGULATES
      description: SSAT2 stabilises the VHL-Elongin C interaction and so the assembled ligase.
    - source: crl2_vhl_degradation
      target: hif_dimerisation
      connection_type: NEGATIVELY_REGULATES
      description: >-
        Polyubiquitination and proteasomal destruction of the alpha subunit prevent dimer
        formation; this is the normoxic off-state of the pathway.
    - source: hif_dimerisation
      target: coactivator_recruitment
      connection_type: PROVIDES_INPUT_FOR
      description: >-
        The DNA-bound heterodimer presents the C-terminal transactivation domain that p300/CBP
        bind.
    - source: fih_asparaginyl_hydroxylation
      target: coactivator_recruitment
      connection_type: NEGATIVELY_REGULATES
      description: >-
        3-Hydroxyasparagine in the C-TAD blocks the CH1 interaction, silencing the alpha subunit
        that escaped degradation. This is the second, independent oxygen-sensing arm.
    - source: oxygen_independent_turnover
      target: hif_dimerisation
      connection_type: NEGATIVELY_REGULATES
      description: >-
        RACK1/SSAT1-driven ubiquitination lowers HIF-1alpha levels without reading oxygen,
        setting the amount of alpha subunit available in either condition.
knowledge_gaps:
  - gap_statement: >-
      What the HIF3A locus does physiologically is unresolved. Its products range from a
      full-length ARNT-dimerising factor without a C-terminal transactivation domain to the
      dominant-negative IPAS, the splice repertoire and its tissue distribution are incompletely
      mapped, and no target-gene programme has been established for the activating form.
    boundary: >-
      HIF3A is modelled as a third variant of the alpha subunit in hif_alpha_subunit, carrying
      both the weak-activator and the dominant-negative readings on one annoton, rather than as
      a separate inhibitory module.
    gap_kind:
      - BIOLOGY
    status: OPEN
    significance: >-
      Whether HIF-3alpha is mainly a weak activator, a decoy that titrates ARNT away from
      HIF-1alpha and HIF-2alpha, or both in different tissues decides whether the module's alpha
      variant set is three parallel activators or two activators plus a competitive inhibitor,
      which changes the predicted dose-response of the whole switch.
    resolution: >-
      Isoform-resolved knock-ins at the Hif3a locus (full-length versus IPAS-only versus null)
      with matched ChIP-seq and RNA-seq in a tissue that expresses both, plus quantification of
      ARNT occupancy by each alpha subunit.
    provenance:
      - reference_id: file:projects/RGD_PATHWAY_ONTOLOGY/pathways/PW_0000360.yaml
        supporting_text: "the 3alpha gene is not well characterized - a splice variant appears to exert inhibitory roles"
  - gap_statement: >-
      How much of the hypoxic transcriptional response runs through ARNT2 rather than ARNT is
      unknown. ARNT2 dimerises with HIF-1alpha and binds DNA in assays and is expressed in brain
      and kidney, but no study has measured the HIF target-gene programme in ARNT2-null tissue
      with ARNT intact.
    boundary: >-
      ARNT2 is modelled as an alternative beta-subunit variant with the same
      heterodimerization activity as ARNT, not as a tissue-restricted replacement for it.
    gap_kind:
      - BIOLOGY
    status: OPEN
    significance: >-
      If ARNT2 carries a substantial share of the response in brain or kidney, the beta variant
      set is a genuine either/or in those tissues rather than a redundancy, and ARNT-targeted
      perturbations would under-report the hypoxic response there.
    resolution: >-
      Conditional Arnt2 deletion with Arnt intact (and the reciprocal) in brain and kidney,
      scoring canonical HIF targets under graded hypoxia, with subunit-resolved ChIP.
    provenance:
      - reference_id: file:projects/RGD_PATHWAY_ONTOLOGY/pathways/PW_0000360.yaml
        supporting_text: "A second beta subunit Arnt2 has been identified with possibly overlapping functions."
  - gap_statement: >-
      The molecular activities of the four oxygen-independent regulators (OS-9, SSAT1, SSAT2 and
      RACK1 in this role) are described only as interactions. Whether any of them changes the
      catalytic parameters of the hydroxylases or only the local concentration of substrate and
      enzyme, whether the acetyltransferase activity of SSAT1/SSAT2 is needed at all for their
      effect on HIF-1alpha, and what their stoichiometry in the complexes is are all open.
    boundary: >-
      These four are modelled as regulatory parts whose annotons carry a preferred_term and
      evidence but, except for RACK1's broad molecular adaptor activity, no GO molecular
      function identifier.
    gap_kind:
      - BIOLOGY
    status: OPEN
    significance: >-
      Until the activity is defined, no GO molecular function can be asserted for these proteins
      in this pathway, and it cannot be said whether they are catalytic accessories, scaffolds
      or stoichiometric subunits of the ligase and sensor complexes.
    resolution: >-
      Reconstituted hydroxylation and ubiquitination kinetics with and without each regulator,
      using catalytically dead SSAT1/SSAT2 point mutants to separate the acetyltransferase
      activity from the scaffolding role, plus quantitative native mass spectrometry of the
      assembled complexes.
  - gap_statement: >-
      The division of labour between PHD1, PHD2 and PHD3 in vivo is only partly understood.
      Knockdown shows PHD2 sets the normoxic HIF-1alpha level in cultured cells, but the
      site-, substrate- and tissue-preferences that make PHD1 and PHD3 non-redundant in whole
      animals, and the Km values for O2 that would say which of them reports graded hypoxia at
      physiological tensions, are not established.
    boundary: >-
      The three paralogues are modelled as a ONE_OR_MORE variant set over the same reaction
      (GO:0160082, RHEA:48400), with their differences recorded in role descriptions rather than
      as separate steps.
    gap_kind:
      - BIOLOGY
    status: OPEN
    significance: >-
      Which paralogue is the physiological oxygen sensor at a given tension determines whether
      the module behaves as one graded sensor or as a set of sensors with different thresholds,
      and it is the basis on which PHD inhibitors used for renal anaemia are judged selective.
    resolution: >-
      Steady-state kinetics of all three enzymes against both degradation-domain peptides across
      the physiological O2 range, with tissue-specific single and compound knockouts scored for
      HIF-1alpha and HIF-2alpha stabilisation.
    provenance:
      - reference_id: file:projects/RGD_PATHWAY_ONTOLOGY/pathways/PW_0000360.yaml
        supporting_text: "Of the three modifying prolyl hydrolases, Egln1 known as Phd2 appears to be essential for the hypoxic response."
