id: MODULE:retinoic_acid_metabolism
title: All-trans-retinoic acid metabolism — RBP4/STRA6 retinol delivery, CRBP1 binding, RDH10/DHRS3 retinol-retinal
  interconversion, ALDH1A1-3 retinal oxidation, CRABP1/2 binding and CYP26A1/B1/C1 catabolism
description: >-
  All-trans-retinoic acid (atRA), the most potent vitamin A metabolite, is made on demand inside
  target cells from circulating retinol and is cleared by oxidative catabolism, so that its tissue
  level is set by the balance of local synthesis and local destruction. Retinol travels in plasma
  bound to retinol-binding protein 4 (RBP4), which circulates as a complex with the transthyretin
  (TTR) tetramer. The multi-pass membrane receptor STRA6 binds holo-RBP4 and moves retinol into the
  cell, where it is bound by cellular retinol-binding protein 1 (CRBP1, RBP1). The first and
  rate-limiting step of synthesis is the reversible, membrane-associated oxidation of all-trans-retinol
  to all-trans-retinal by the short-chain dehydrogenase/reductase RDH10. RDH10 works together with
  the retinaldehyde reductase DHRS3: the two proteins activate each other, and DHRS3 reduces
  retinal back to retinol, so the pair sets the flux of retinal toward acid. Cytosolic medium-chain
  alcohol dehydrogenases can also oxidise retinol. The second step, the oxidation of retinal to atRA,
  is irreversible and is catalysed by the NAD+-dependent retinaldehyde dehydrogenases ALDH1A1,
  ALDH1A2 and ALDH1A3, whose distinct tissue patterns define where atRA is produced in the embryo.
  Cellular retinoic acid-binding proteins bind atRA in the cytosol: CRABP2 delivers it to the
  nuclear retinoic acid receptors, and CRABP1 sequesters it and favours its catabolism. atRA is
  inactivated by the cytochrome P450 retinoic acid hydroxylases CYP26A1, CYP26B1 and CYP26C1, which
  form 4-hydroxy-, 4-oxo- and 18-hydroxy-atRA in the endoplasmic reticulum; CYP26A1 and DHRS3 are
  induced by atRA, giving negative feedback on its own level. Retinol not used for synthesis can be
  stored as retinyl esters, made by LRAT and hydrolysed back to retinol by retinyl ester hydrolases
  such as the carboxylesterase CES1. Loss of RDH10 or ALDH1A2 in mouse abolishes embryonic atRA
  synthesis, CYP26B1 deficiency causes craniosynostosis and skeletal anomalies, and STRA6 and RBP4
  defects cause microphthalmia and coloboma.
status: DRAFT
scope: CONCRETE
evidence:
- source_id: PW:0001004
  title: retinoic acid metabolic pathway
  statement: >-
    The module boundary follows the RGD Pathway Ontology record and diagram for this term. The diagram
    draws circulating retinol associated with Rbp4 and Ttr, Rbp4 associated with Stra6, cellular retinol
    bound to Rbp1 and reversibly converted to retinal, retinal irreversibly converted to all-trans retinoic
    acid, atRA associated with Crabp1, Crabp2 and Fabp5 and feeding the atRA CYPs and the retinoic acid
    signaling pathway (PW:0001014), and retinol exchanged with the retinyl ester pool (Lrat, CES1, apo-Rbp1).
    The RGD human gene set is ALDH1A1, ALDH1A2, ALDH1A3, CES1, CRABP1, CRABP2, CYP26A1, CYP26B1, CYP26C1,
    DHRS9, FABP5, LRAT, RBP1, RBP4, RDH10, RDH16, STRA6 and TTR. Derived through projects/RGD_PATHWAY_ONTOLOGY
    (pathways/PW_0001004.yaml).
- source_id: file:projects/RGD_PATHWAY_ONTOLOGY/pathways/PW_0001004.yaml
  title: RGD PW:0001004 record text (project snapshot)
  statement: >-
    The RGD record places the reversible retinol-retinal step before the irreversible retinal dehydrogenase
    step that commits retinal to atRA.
  supporting_text: In other cells, retinal is the substrate for retinal dehydrogenases that irreversible
    convert it to all-trans retinoic acid (atRA) and other derivatives with atRA being the most potent molecule.
- source_id: file:projects/RGD_PATHWAY_ONTOLOGY/pathways/PW_0001004.yaml
  title: RGD PW:0001004 record text (project snapshot)
  statement: >-
    The RGD record assigns CRABP2 to delivery of atRA to the RARs and CRABP1 to atRA catabolism.
  supporting_text: Crabp1 on the other hand, relates to the processing and catabolism of retinoic acid.
- source_id: GO:0042573
  title: retinoic acid metabolic process
  statement: >-
    The skos:closeMatch GO mapping of PW:0001004 (RGD page GO xref, PW definition xref and lexical match;
    projects/RGD_PATHWAY_ONTOLOGY/data/module_seeds.yaml). Used as the module-level concept; its children
    GO:0002138 retinoic acid biosynthetic process and GO:0034653 retinoic acid catabolic process are placed
    on the synthesis and catabolism steps.
- source_id: PMID:17473173
  title: RDH10 is essential for synthesis of embryonic retinoic acid and is required for limb, craniofacial,
    and organ development.
  statement: >-
    Genetic evidence that retinol oxidation by RDH10, not redundant cytosolic alcohol dehydrogenases, is the
    first and critical step of embryonic atRA synthesis.
  supporting_text: Thus, we show that the first oxidative step of Vitamin A metabolism, which is catalyzed
    in large part by the retinol dehydrogenase RDH10, is critical for the spatiotemporal synthesis of RA.
- source_id: PMID:9228017
  title: cDNA cloning of human retinoic acid-metabolizing enzyme (hP450RAI) identifies a novel family of
    cytochromes P450.
  statement: >-
    The atRA-inducible CYP26A1 hydroxylase closes a negative feedback loop on atRA level.
  supporting_text: We conclude that this enzyme plays a key role in RA metabolism, functioning in a feedback
    loop where RA levels are controlled in an autoregulatory manner.
module:
  id: retinoic_acid_metabolism
  label: All-trans-retinoic acid metabolism
  module_type: METABOLIC_PATHWAY
  concepts:
  - preferred_term: retinoic acid metabolic process
    term:
      id: GO:0042573
      label: retinoic acid metabolic process
    description: >-
      The closeMatch of PW:0001004. Covers both the synthesis and the catabolism of atRA, which this
      module models as one life cycle because the two arms together set the local atRA level.
  context:
    taxa:
    - preferred_term: Homo sapiens
      term:
        id: NCBITaxon:9606
        label: Homo sapiens
    cellular_components:
    - preferred_term: endoplasmic reticulum membrane
      term:
        id: GO:0005789
        label: endoplasmic reticulum membrane
      description: >-
        Where the membrane-bound steps act: retinol oxidation by RDH10 with DHRS3, and atRA hydroxylation
        by the CYP26 enzymes.
    - preferred_term: cytosol
      term:
        id: GO:0005829
        label: cytosol
      description: >-
        Where the soluble steps act: CRBP1 retinol binding, retinal oxidation by the ALDH1A enzymes and
        atRA binding by the CRABPs. Listed beside the ER membrane because the pathway alternates between
        the two compartments, not as a refinement of one by the other.
  parts:
  - order: 1
    role: plasma retinol delivery and receptor-mediated uptake
    node:
      id: retinol_delivery_uptake
      label: RBP4-TTR transport of retinol and STRA6-mediated uptake
      module_type: TRANSPORT_STEP
      description: >-
        Holo-RBP4 carries all-trans-retinol in plasma as a complex with the TTR tetramer, which keeps the
        small RBP4 from glomerular filtration. STRA6 at the plasma membrane binds holo-RBP4 and transfers
        retinol into the cell. The visual cycle module starts from retinol already in the RPE and does not
        model this step, so it is modelled here rather than referenced.
      concepts:
      - preferred_term: retinol transport
        term:
          id: GO:0034633
          label: retinol transport
      evidence:
      - source_id: PMID:17255476
        statement: STRA6 is the RBP receptor that takes up vitamin A from the vitamin A-RBP complex.
        supporting_text: STRA6 binds to RBP with high affinity and has robust vitamin A uptake activity
          from the vitamin A-RBP complex.
      annotons:
      - id: rbp4_retinol_carrier
        label: RBP4 plasma retinol carrier
        participant:
          selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
          gene_product:
            preferred_term: RBP4
            term:
              id: UniProtKB:P02753
              label: Retinol-binding protein 4
        function:
          preferred_term: molecular carrier activity
          term:
            id: GO:0140104
            label: molecular carrier activity
          substrates:
          - preferred_term: all-trans-retinol
            term:
              id: CHEBI:17336
              label: all-trans-retinol
        processes:
        - preferred_term: retinol transport
          term:
            id: GO:0034633
            label: retinol transport
        locations:
        - preferred_term: extracellular region
          term:
            id: GO:0005576
            label: extracellular region
        role_description: >-
          Lipocalin that binds one all-trans-retinol (retinol binding, GO:0019841, IDA in human GOA) and
          carries it from liver to peripheral tissues. The carrier activity follows the mouse GO-CAM
          that models Rbp4 this way.
        evidence:
        - source_id: PMID:571335
          statement: Human RBP4 exists as apo and holo forms that differ by bound retinol and binds prealbumin
            (transthyretin).
          supporting_text: The anodal of the two bands was therefore probably the apo form and the cathodal
            the holo form of the same retinol-binding protein.
        gocam_associations:
        - model: gomodel:67086be200001721
          activity: gomodel:67086be200001721/67086be200001793
          title: Retinoid Metabolic Process 2 (Mouse)
          description: >-
            Mouse Rbp4 GO:0140104 molecular carrier activity in the extracellular region, downstream of
            Pnpla2 retinyl ester hydrolysis in hepatic stellate cells.
      - id: ttr_rbp4_partner
        label: TTR stabilisation of circulating holo-RBP4
        participant:
          selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
          gene_product:
            preferred_term: TTR
            term:
              id: UniProtKB:P02766
              label: Transthyretin
        function:
          preferred_term: molecular sequestering activity
          term:
            id: GO:0140313
            label: molecular sequestering activity
        locations:
        - preferred_term: extracellular region
          term:
            id: GO:0005576
            label: extracellular region
        role_description: >-
          The thyroxine-carrying tetramer that binds holo-RBP4 and so retains it in plasma. Retinol is
          not its own ligand; TTR is an accessory of the RBP4 carrier. The function term follows the mouse
          GO-CAM and the Reactome-derived human annotation (TAS); TTR has no experimental molecular function
          in human GOA other than self-association.
        evidence:
        - source_id: PMID:571335
          statement: Most urinary RBP binds prealbumin (transthyretin) in vitro.
          supporting_text: More than 85% of the retinol-binding protein in the urine bound to prealbumin-Sephrose.
        gocam_associations:
        - model: gomodel:67086be200001721
          activity: gomodel:67086be200001721/67086be200001792
          title: Retinoid Metabolic Process 2 (Mouse)
          description: Mouse Ttr GO:0140313 molecular sequestering activity in the retinoid metabolic process.
      - id: stra6_retinol_uptake
        label: STRA6 retinol transmembrane transporter (RBP4 receptor)
        participant:
          selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
          gene_product:
            preferred_term: STRA6
            term:
              id: UniProtKB:Q9BX79
              label: Receptor for retinol uptake STRA6
        function:
          preferred_term: retinol transmembrane transporter activity
          term:
            id: GO:0034632
            label: retinol transmembrane transporter activity
          substrates:
          - preferred_term: all-trans-retinol (from holo-RBP4)
            term:
              id: CHEBI:17336
              label: all-trans-retinol
        processes:
        - preferred_term: retinol transport
          term:
            id: GO:0034633
            label: retinol transport
        locations:
        - preferred_term: plasma membrane
          term:
            id: GO:0005886
            label: plasma membrane
        role_description: >-
          Multi-pass membrane receptor for holo-RBP4 that transfers retinol into the cell (GO:0034632, IDA,
          PMID:21901792). Uptake is coupled to intracellular acceptors, CRBP1 and LRAT, which drain the
          retinol; the uptake is bidirectional in vitro.
        evidence:
        - source_id: PMID:21901792
          statement: A disease-associated STRA6 mutant is mislocalised and has reduced vitamin A uptake, and
            the eye phenotype is reproduced by inhibiting RA synthesis.
          supporting_text: We have shown that the G304K mutant STRA6 protein is mislocalized and has severely
            reduced vitamin A uptake activity.
  - order: 2
    role: intracellular retinol binding
    node:
      id: cellular_retinol_binding
      label: CRBP1 (RBP1) binding of cellular all-trans-retinol
      module_type: TRANSPORT_STEP
      description: >-
        CRBP1 binds incoming retinol with nanomolar affinity, protects it from non-specific oxidation and
        presents it to the membrane-bound enzymes, both the RDH10 dehydrogenase and LRAT. The ratio of apo- to
        holo-CRBP1 steers retinol between atRA synthesis and retinyl ester storage, which is why the
        RGD diagram draws apo-Rbp1 inhibiting Lrat and favouring ester hydrolysis.
      annotons:
      - id: rbp1_retinol_binding
        label: CRBP1 all-trans-retinol binding
        participant:
          selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
          gene_product:
            preferred_term: RBP1 (CRBP1)
            term:
              id: UniProtKB:P09455
              label: Retinol-binding protein 1
        function:
          preferred_term: all-trans-retinol binding
          term:
            id: GO:1904768
            label: all-trans-retinol binding
        locations:
        - preferred_term: cytosol
          term:
            id: GO:0005829
            label: cytosol
        role_description: >-
          Intracellular lipocalin-fold (FABP family) retinol chaperone. GO:1904768 is its experimental
          molecular function (IDA, PMID:28057518) and the activity the mouse GO-CAMs use.
        evidence:
        - source_id: PMID:28057518
          statement: Apo-CRBP1 binds retinol stoichiometrically with nanomolar affinity.
          supporting_text: An approximately stoichiometric binding of retinol to wild type apo-CRBP1
            (Kd∼4.5nM)
        gocam_associations:
        - model: gomodel:66f5faaa00001204
          activity: gomodel:66f5faaa00001204/66f5faaa00001307
          title: Retinoid Metabolic Process 1 (Mouse)
          description: Mouse Rbp1 GO:1904768 all-trans-retinol binding, part of retinoid metabolic process.
  - order: 3
    role: reversible retinol-retinal interconversion (rate-limiting step of synthesis)
    node:
      id: retinol_retinal_interconversion
      label: RDH10-DHRS3 retinol dehydrogenase/retinaldehyde reductase pair
      module_type: REACTION
      description: >-
        RDH10 oxidises all-trans-retinol to all-trans-retinal at the ER and lipid-droplet membrane. DHRS3
        reduces all-trans-retinal back to retinol. The two SDRs activate each other when co-expressed: DHRS3
        reaches its full reductase activity only with RDH10 present, and RDH10 retinol dehydrogenase activity
        rises with DHRS3, with neither needing to be catalytically active to activate the other. Because DHRS3
        is induced by atRA, the pair forms a feedback loop that limits retinal supply. No GO cellular component
        term exists for the RDH10-DHRS3 association, so it is modelled as two annotons in one node rather
        than as a named complex.
      concepts:
      - preferred_term: retinol metabolic process
        term:
          id: GO:0042572
          label: retinol metabolic process
      evidence:
      - source_id: PMID:24733397
        statement: DHRS3 needs RDH10 for full reductase activity and RDH10 is reciprocally activated by DHRS3.
        supporting_text: This study demonstrates that DHRS3 requires the presence of retinol dehydrogenase
          10 (RDH10) to display its full catalytic activity.
      - source_id: PMID:24733397
        statement: The mutual activation does not depend on the catalytic activity of the activating partner.
        supporting_text: Neither RDH10 nor DHRS3 has to be itself catalytically active to activate each other.
      annotons:
      - id: rdh10_retinol_dehydrogenase
        label: RDH10 all-trans-retinol dehydrogenase
        participant:
          selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
          gene_product:
            preferred_term: RDH10
            term:
              id: UniProtKB:Q8IZV5
              label: Retinol dehydrogenase 10
        function:
          preferred_term: all-trans-retinol dehydrogenase (NAD+) activity
          term:
            id: GO:0004745
            label: all-trans-retinol dehydrogenase (NAD+) activity
          substrates:
          - preferred_term: all-trans-retinol
            term:
              id: CHEBI:17336
              label: all-trans-retinol
          - preferred_term: NAD+
            term:
              id: CHEBI:57540
              label: NAD(1-)
          products:
          - preferred_term: all-trans-retinal
            term:
              id: CHEBI:17898
              label: all-trans-retinal
          - preferred_term: NADH
            term:
              id: CHEBI:57945
              label: NADH(2-)
        processes:
        - preferred_term: retinoic acid biosynthetic process
          term:
            id: GO:0002138
            label: retinoic acid biosynthetic process
        locations:
        - preferred_term: endoplasmic reticulum membrane
          term:
            id: GO:0005789
            label: endoplasmic reticulum membrane
        role_description: >-
          The main retinol dehydrogenase for atRA synthesis; the mouse trex mutant lacks retinol oxidase
          activity and dies at midgestation with RA deficiency. GO:0004745 is its experimental GOA
          function (IDA, PMID:12407145 and PMID:19458327). Cofactor use is not settled: the first
          characterisation reported a preference for NADP, while later work found NAD+ more effective;
          the GOA term is kept.
        evidence:
        - source_id: PMID:12407145
          statement: Recombinant human RDH10 oxidises all-trans-retinol to all-trans-retinal.
          supporting_text: Human RDH10 expressed in COS cells oxidized all-trans retinol to all-trans retinal.
        - source_id: PMID:19458327
          statement: RDH10 uses both NAD+ and NADP+, with NAD+ giving more robust activity (11-cis substrate).
          supporting_text: RDH10 can use both NAD(+) and NADP(+) as cofactors for 11-cis-RDH activity, although
            NAD(+) cofactor confers more robust activity.
        - source_id: PMID:17473173
          statement: The trex RDH10 mutant cannot oxidise retinol and gives insufficient RA signalling.
          supporting_text: we determined that RDH10(trex) mutant protein lacks the ability to oxidize retinol
            to retinal, resulting in insufficient RA signaling.
      - id: dhrs3_retinaldehyde_reductase
        label: DHRS3 all-trans-retinaldehyde reductase (RDH10-activated)
        participant:
          selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
          gene_product:
            preferred_term: DHRS3
            term:
              id: UniProtKB:O75911
              label: Short-chain dehydrogenase/reductase 3
        function:
          preferred_term: all-trans-retinol dehydrogenase (NADP+) activity
          term:
            id: GO:0052650
            label: all-trans-retinol dehydrogenase (NADP+) activity
          substrates:
          - preferred_term: all-trans-retinal
            term:
              id: CHEBI:17898
              label: all-trans-retinal
          - preferred_term: NADPH
            term:
              id: CHEBI:57783
              label: NADPH(4-)
          products:
          - preferred_term: all-trans-retinol
            term:
              id: CHEBI:17336
              label: all-trans-retinol
          - preferred_term: NADP+
            term:
              id: CHEBI:58349
              label: NADP(3-)
        locations:
        - preferred_term: endoplasmic reticulum membrane
          term:
            id: GO:0005789
            label: endoplasmic reticulum membrane
        role_description: >-
          NADPH-dependent reductase working in the reverse direction to RDH10; this activity is the core
          function in the completed human DHRS3 review. The same DHRS3 role is also drawn, as retinoid
          buffering, in modules/retinoid_visual_cycle.yaml (node retinoid_buffering); here it is modelled
          with its RDH10 partner because the mutual activation is what makes it a control point of atRA synthesis.
          The substrates and products are written in the reduction direction it works in here, although GO
          names GO:0052650 in the oxidation (dehydrogenase) direction; GO activity terms cover both
          directions of a reversible reaction, and GOA uses this term for the reductase.
        evidence:
        - source_id: file:human/DHRS3/DHRS3-ai-review.yaml
          statement: Core function GO:0052650, NADPH-dependent all-trans-retinaldehyde reductase buffering
            retinaldehyde supply for atRA synthesis.
        - source_id: PMID:24733397
          statement: RDH10-activated DHRS3 reduces retinaldehyde back to retinol and slows atRA synthesis.
          supporting_text: The RDH10-activated DHRS3 acts as a robust high affinity all-trans-retinaldehyde-specific
            reductase that effectively converts retinaldehyde back to retinol, decreasing the rate of retinoic
            acid biosynthesis.
        gocam_associations:
        - model: gomodel:67086be200002705
          activity: gomodel:67086be200002705/67086be200002846
          title: Retinoid Metabolic Process 4 (Mouse)
          description: Mouse Dhrs3 GO:0052650 all-trans-retinol dehydrogenase (NADP+) activity.
  - order: 4
    role: irreversible oxidation of retinal to all-trans-retinoic acid
    node:
      id: retinal_oxidation
      label: Retinaldehyde dehydrogenases ALDH1A1, ALDH1A2 and ALDH1A3
      module_type: REACTION
      description: >-
        Cytosolic NAD+-dependent class 1 aldehyde dehydrogenases oxidise all-trans-retinal to atRA through a
        catalytic cysteine. The reaction is irreversible and commits retinal to atRA. The three paralogues
        catalyse the same reaction and differ in tissue and developmental expression (ALDH1A2 is the main
        embryonic and testicular enzyme, ALDH1A1 is abundant in liver and also oxidises other aldehydes,
        ALDH1A3 acts in the developing eye and nasal region), so they are modelled as variants.
      concepts:
      - preferred_term: retinoic acid biosynthetic process
        term:
          id: GO:0002138
          label: retinoic acid biosynthetic process
      variant_sets:
      - id: raldh_paralog
        label: Retinaldehyde dehydrogenase paralogue
        axis: enzyme paralogue (ALDH1A1/ALDH1A2/ALDH1A3, differing in tissue and developmental expression)
        selection: ONE_OR_MORE
        variants:
        - id: aldh1a2_variant
          label: ALDH1A2 (RALDH2)
          module_type: REACTION
          annotons:
          - id: aldh1a2_retinal_dehydrogenase
            label: ALDH1A2 retinal dehydrogenase (NAD+)
            participant:
              selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
              gene_product:
                preferred_term: ALDH1A2 (RALDH2)
                term:
                  id: UniProtKB:O94788
                  label: Retinal dehydrogenase 2
            function:
              preferred_term: retinal dehydrogenase (NAD+) activity
              term:
                id: GO:0001758
                label: retinal dehydrogenase (NAD+) activity
              substrates:
              - preferred_term: all-trans-retinal
                term:
                  id: CHEBI:17898
                  label: all-trans-retinal
              - preferred_term: NAD+
                term:
                  id: CHEBI:57540
                  label: NAD(1-)
              products:
              - preferred_term: all-trans-retinoate
                term:
                  id: CHEBI:35291
                  label: all-trans-retinoate
              - preferred_term: NADH
                term:
                  id: CHEBI:57945
                  label: NADH(2-)
            processes:
            - preferred_term: retinoic acid biosynthetic process
              term:
                id: GO:0002138
                label: retinoic acid biosynthetic process
            locations:
            - preferred_term: cytosol
              term:
                id: GO:0005829
                label: cytosol
            role_description: >-
              The dominant embryonic and spermatogenic atRA-synthesising enzyme. GO:0001758 is its
              experimental GOA function (IDA, PMID:29240402).
            evidence:
            - source_id: PMID:29240402
              statement: ALDH1A2 is the primary RA-synthesising enzyme in mammalian spermatogenesis.
              supporting_text: ALDH1A2 is the primary RA-synthesizing enzyme in mammalian spermatogenesis
                and is therefore considered a viable drug target for male contraceptive development.
        - id: aldh1a1_variant
          label: ALDH1A1 (RALDH1)
          module_type: REACTION
          annotons:
          - id: aldh1a1_retinal_dehydrogenase
            label: ALDH1A1 retinal dehydrogenase (NAD+)
            participant:
              selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
              gene_product:
                preferred_term: ALDH1A1 (RALDH1)
                term:
                  id: UniProtKB:P00352
                  label: Aldehyde dehydrogenase 1A1
            function:
              preferred_term: retinal dehydrogenase (NAD+) activity
              term:
                id: GO:0001758
                label: retinal dehydrogenase (NAD+) activity
              substrates:
              - preferred_term: all-trans-retinal
                term:
                  id: CHEBI:17898
                  label: all-trans-retinal
              - preferred_term: NAD+
                term:
                  id: CHEBI:57540
                  label: NAD(1-)
              products:
              - preferred_term: all-trans-retinoate
                term:
                  id: CHEBI:35291
                  label: all-trans-retinoate
              - preferred_term: NADH
                term:
                  id: CHEBI:57945
                  label: NADH(2-)
            locations:
            - preferred_term: cytosol
              term:
                id: GO:0005829
                label: cytosol
            role_description: >-
              Broad-specificity cytosolic aldehyde dehydrogenase, abundant in liver, that oxidises
              retinal to atRA. Its experimental GOA functions are the generic aldehyde dehydrogenase (NAD+)
              activity (GO:0004029) and 3-deoxyglucosone dehydrogenase activity; GO:0001758 rests on ISS and IEA
              in human GOA. The more specific term is used here because retinal oxidation is the activity
              the pathway needs and is a long-established activity of the enzyme, which the 3-deoxyglucosone
              paper itself states.
            evidence:
            - source_id: PMID:17175089
              statement: ALDH1A1 is a known retinaldehyde-to-RA enzyme that also oxidises 3-deoxyglucosone.
              supporting_text: aldehyde dehydrogenase 1A1 (ALDH1A1), an enzyme known to catalyze the oxidation
                of retinaldehyde to retinoic acid.
        - id: aldh1a3_variant
          label: ALDH1A3 (RALDH3)
          module_type: REACTION
          annotons:
          - id: aldh1a3_retinal_dehydrogenase
            label: ALDH1A3 retinal dehydrogenase (NAD+)
            participant:
              selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
              gene_product:
                preferred_term: ALDH1A3 (RALDH3)
                term:
                  id: UniProtKB:P47895
                  label: Retinaldehyde dehydrogenase 3
            function:
              preferred_term: retinal dehydrogenase (NAD+) activity
              term:
                id: GO:0001758
                label: retinal dehydrogenase (NAD+) activity
              substrates:
              - preferred_term: all-trans-retinal
                term:
                  id: CHEBI:17898
                  label: all-trans-retinal
              - preferred_term: NAD+
                term:
                  id: CHEBI:57540
                  label: NAD(1-)
              products:
              - preferred_term: all-trans-retinoate
                term:
                  id: CHEBI:35291
                  label: all-trans-retinoate
              - preferred_term: NADH
                term:
                  id: CHEBI:57945
                  label: NADH(2-)
            processes:
            - preferred_term: retinoic acid biosynthetic process
              term:
                id: GO:0002138
                label: retinoic acid biosynthetic process
            locations:
            - preferred_term: cytosol
              term:
                id: GO:0005829
                label: cytosol
            role_description: >-
              Retinal dehydrogenase of the developing eye and nasal region. GO:0001758 and GO:0002138 are both
              experimental in GOA (IDA, PMID:27759097), from the structure with bound NAD+ and atRA.
            evidence:
            - source_id: PMID:27759097
              statement: ALDH1A3 oxidises retinal to retinoic acid using NAD+.
              supporting_text: The aldehyde dehydrogenase family 1 member A3 (ALDH1A3) catalyzes the oxidation
                of retinal to the pleiotropic factor retinoic acid using NAD+.
  - order: 5
    role: cytosolic atRA binding (delivery or sequestration)
    node:
      id: retinoic_acid_binding
      label: Cellular retinoic acid-binding proteins CRABP1 and CRABP2
      module_type: TRANSPORT_STEP
      description: >-
        atRA in the cytosol is bound by two small FABP-family proteins with opposite effects on its fate.
        CRABP2 moves to the nucleus and hands atRA directly to the RARs, increasing signalling; CRABP1
        retains atRA in the cytosol and favours its CYP26 catabolism. They are modelled as variants along
        the axis of what happens to the bound atRA. FABP5, which RGD also draws, is not modelled (see notes).
      variant_sets:
      - id: crabp_paralog
        label: CRABP paralogue
        axis: fate of bound atRA (nuclear delivery to RARs versus cytosolic retention and catabolism)
        selection: ONE_OR_MORE
        variants:
        - id: crabp2_variant
          label: CRABP2 (delivery to RAR)
          module_type: TRANSPORT_STEP
          annotons:
          - id: crabp2_retinoic_acid_binding
            label: CRABP2 retinoic acid binding
            participant:
              selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
              gene_product:
                preferred_term: CRABP2
                term:
                  id: UniProtKB:P29373
                  label: Cellular retinoic acid-binding protein 2
            function:
              preferred_term: retinoic acid binding
              term:
                id: GO:0001972
                label: retinoic acid binding
            locations:
            - preferred_term: cytosol
              term:
                id: GO:0005829
                label: cytosol
            role_description: >-
              Binds atRA and channels it to RAR in the nucleus. GO:0001972 rests on IBA and IEA in human GOA;
              no experimental retinoic acid binding row exists, although binding is the defining property of the
              protein. The same protein appears, without the binding function, in the production part of
              modules/retinoic_acid_receptor_signaling.yaml.
            evidence:
            - source_id: file:projects/RGD_PATHWAY_ONTOLOGY/pathways/PW_0001004.yaml
              statement: RGD assigns CRABP2 delivery of atRA to the RARs.
              supporting_text: Crabp2 and Fabp5 deliver atRA to particular nuclear receptors such as retinoid
                acid receptors (RARs)
        - id: crabp1_variant
          label: CRABP1 (cytosolic retention, favours catabolism)
          module_type: TRANSPORT_STEP
          annotons:
          - id: crabp1_retinoic_acid_binding
            label: CRABP1 retinoic acid binding
            participant:
              selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
              gene_product:
                preferred_term: CRABP1
                term:
                  id: UniProtKB:P29762
                  label: Cellular retinoic acid-binding protein 1
            function:
              preferred_term: retinoic acid binding
              term:
                id: GO:0001972
                label: retinoic acid binding
            locations:
            - preferred_term: cytosol
              term:
                id: GO:0005829
                label: cytosol
            role_description: >-
              Binds atRA in the cytosol and, when overexpressed, raises the rate of atRA catabolism.
              GO:0001972 rests on IBA and IEA in human GOA.
            evidence:
            - source_id: file:projects/RGD_PATHWAY_ONTOLOGY/pathways/PW_0001004.yaml
              statement: RGD records that CRABP1 overexpression increases atRA catabolism.
              supporting_text: its overexpression increases the rate of atRA catabolism.
  - order: 6
    role: oxidative catabolism of atRA
    node:
      id: retinoic_acid_catabolism
      label: CYP26 retinoic acid hydroxylases (CYP26A1, CYP26B1, CYP26C1)
      module_type: REACTION
      description: >-
        ER cytochrome P450s hydroxylate atRA at C4 and C18, forming 4-OH-, 4-oxo- and 18-OH-atRA, which are
        far less active and are further oxidised and conjugated for elimination. The three enzymes share the
        chemistry and differ in tissue expression and kinetics: CYP26A1 has the highest capacity and is
        strongly atRA-inducible, CYP26B1 has the highest affinity and dominates in brain, and CYP26C1 also
        accepts 9-cis-RA.
      concepts:
      - preferred_term: retinoic acid catabolic process
        term:
          id: GO:0034653
          label: retinoic acid catabolic process
      variant_sets:
      - id: cyp26_paralog
        label: CYP26 paralogue
        axis: enzyme paralogue (CYP26A1/B1/C1, differing in tissue expression, kinetics and isomer range)
        selection: ONE_OR_MORE
        variants:
        - id: cyp26a1_variant
          label: CYP26A1
          module_type: REACTION
          annotons:
          - id: cyp26a1_ra_hydroxylase
            label: CYP26A1 retinoic acid 4-hydroxylase
            participant:
              selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
              gene_product:
                preferred_term: CYP26A1
                term:
                  id: UniProtKB:O43174
                  label: Cytochrome P450 26A1
            function:
              preferred_term: retinoic acid 4-hydroxylase activity
              term:
                id: GO:0008401
                label: retinoic acid 4-hydroxylase activity
              substrates:
              - preferred_term: all-trans-retinoate
                term:
                  id: CHEBI:35291
                  label: all-trans-retinoate
              - preferred_term: O2
                term:
                  id: CHEBI:15379
                  label: dioxygen
              - preferred_term: reduced [NADPH-hemoprotein reductase]
              products:
              - preferred_term: all-trans-4-hydroxyretinoate
                term:
                  id: CHEBI:134178
                  label: all-trans-4-hydroxyretinoate
            processes:
            - preferred_term: retinoic acid catabolic process
              term:
                id: GO:0034653
                label: retinoic acid catabolic process
            locations:
            - preferred_term: endoplasmic reticulum membrane
              term:
                id: GO:0005789
                label: endoplasmic reticulum membrane
            role_description: >-
              High-capacity, atRA-inducible atRA hydroxylase, dominant in liver. GO:0008401 is experimental
              in GOA (IDA, PMID:9228017, PMID:10823918 and others), as is all-trans retinoic acid
              18-hydroxylase activity (GO:0062183, IDA, PMID:22020119), which is recorded here in prose.
            evidence:
            - source_id: PMID:9228017
              statement: CYP26A1 generates 4-OH-RA, 4-oxo-RA and 18-OH-RA.
              supporting_text: We demonstrate that hP450RAI is responsible for generation of several hydroxylated
                forms of RA, including 4-OH-RA, 4-oxo-RA, and 18-OH-RA.
            - source_id: PMID:22020119
              statement: CYP26A1 has higher activity than CYP26B1 and seems to clear atRA in barrier tissues.
              supporting_text: CYP26A1 has higher catalytic activity than CYP26B1 and seems to be responsible
                for metabolism of atRA in tissues that function as a barrier for atRA exposure.
            gocam_associations:
            - model: gomodel:5fce9b7300001742
              activity: gomodel:5fce9b7300001742/5fce9b7300001846
              title: Strap in alternative splicing-mouse
              description: >-
                Mouse Cyp26a1 GO:0008401 retinoic acid 4-hydroxylase activity, part of GO:0034653 retinoic
                acid catabolic process. The activity matches this annoton; the model as a whole is about
                Strap and splicing, so it grounds only the CYP26A1 activity.
        - id: cyp26b1_variant
          label: CYP26B1
          module_type: REACTION
          annotons:
          - id: cyp26b1_ra_hydroxylase
            label: CYP26B1 retinoic acid 4-hydroxylase
            participant:
              selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
              gene_product:
                preferred_term: CYP26B1
                term:
                  id: UniProtKB:Q9NR63
                  label: Cytochrome P450 26B1
            function:
              preferred_term: retinoic acid 4-hydroxylase activity
              term:
                id: GO:0008401
                label: retinoic acid 4-hydroxylase activity
            processes:
            - preferred_term: retinoic acid catabolic process
              term:
                id: GO:0034653
                label: retinoic acid catabolic process
            locations:
            - preferred_term: endoplasmic reticulum membrane
              term:
                id: GO:0005789
                label: endoplasmic reticulum membrane
            role_description: >-
              High-affinity atRA hydroxylase that predominates in cerebellum and pons. GO:0008401 and GO:0034653
              are experimental in GOA (IDA, PMID:10823918).
            evidence:
            - source_id: PMID:10823918
              statement: CYP26B1 (P450RAI-2) converts atRA to 4-oxo-, 4-OH- and 18-OH-atRA.
              supporting_text: Transiently transfected P450RAI-2 can convert all-trans-RA to more polar metabolites
                including 4-oxo-, 4-OH-, and 18-OH-all-trans-RA.
            - source_id: PMID:22020119
              statement: CYP26B1 has a lower Km than CYP26A1 for 4-OH-RA formation.
              supporting_text: CYP26B1 had a lower K(m) (19nM) and V(max) (0.8 pmol/min/pmol) than CYP26A1
        - id: cyp26c1_variant
          label: CYP26C1
          module_type: REACTION
          annotons:
          - id: cyp26c1_ra_hydroxylase
            label: CYP26C1 retinoic acid 4-hydroxylase
            participant:
              selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
              gene_product:
                preferred_term: CYP26C1
                term:
                  id: UniProtKB:Q6V0L0
                  label: Cytochrome P450 26C1
            function:
              preferred_term: retinoic acid 4-hydroxylase activity
              term:
                id: GO:0008401
                label: retinoic acid 4-hydroxylase activity
            processes:
            - preferred_term: retinoic acid catabolic process
              term:
                id: GO:0034653
                label: retinoic acid catabolic process
            locations:
            - preferred_term: endoplasmic reticulum membrane
              term:
                id: GO:0005789
                label: endoplasmic reticulum membrane
            role_description: >-
              Third CYP26, with restricted adult expression, that metabolises both all-trans- and 9-cis-RA.
              GO:0008401 and GO:0034653 are experimental in GOA (IDA, PMID:14532297).
            evidence:
            - source_id: PMID:14532297
              statement: CYP26C1 prefers atRA but also metabolises 9-cis-RA.
              supporting_text: Specifically, CYP26C1 can also recognize and metabolize 9-cis-RA and is much
                less sensitive than the other CYP26 family members to the inhibitory effects of ketoconazole.
  - order: 7
    role: retinyl ester storage and mobilisation (buffer of the retinol pool)
    optional: true
    node:
      id: retinyl_ester_storage
      label: Retinyl ester formation (LRAT) and hydrolysis (CES1)
      module_type: METABOLIC_PATHWAY
      description: >-
        Optional side branch. Cellular retinol not oxidised by RDH10 can be esterified by LRAT and stored as
        retinyl esters, mainly in hepatic stellate cells, and the esters are hydrolysed back to retinol when
        needed. It is optional because it buffers the retinol supply rather than being a step on the
        route from retinol to atRA, and atRA is made in tissues without a large ester store.
      parts:
      - order: 1
        role: retinol esterification
        node:
          id: retinol_esterification_ref
          label: LRAT esterification of all-trans-retinol
          description: >-
            Included by reference to the LRAT step of the retinoid visual cycle module, which models
            phosphatidylcholine-retinol O-acyltransferase activity on the same all-trans-retinol substrate.
            The enzyme and reaction are the same in the RPE and in storage tissues, so the step is not re-modelled.
          module_ref: retinoid_visual_cycle#retinol_esterification
      - order: 2
        role: retinyl ester hydrolysis
        node:
          id: retinyl_ester_hydrolysis
          label: CES1 retinyl ester hydrolase
          module_type: REACTION
          annotons:
          - id: ces1_retinyl_ester_hydrolase
            label: CES1 retinyl-palmitate esterase
            participant:
              selector_type: GENE_PRODUCT
              gene_product:
                preferred_term: CES1
                term:
                  id: UniProtKB:P23141
                  label: Liver carboxylesterase 1
            function:
              preferred_term: retinyl-palmitate esterase activity
              term:
                id: GO:0050253
                label: retinyl-palmitate esterase activity
              substrates:
              - preferred_term: all-trans-retinyl palmitate
                term:
                  id: CHEBI:17616
                  label: all-trans-retinyl palmitate
              products:
              - preferred_term: all-trans-retinol
                term:
                  id: CHEBI:17336
                  label: all-trans-retinol
              - preferred_term: hexadecanoate
                term:
                  id: CHEBI:7896
                  label: hexadecanoate
            locations:
            - preferred_term: endoplasmic reticulum lumen
              term:
                id: GO:0005788
                label: endoplasmic reticulum lumen
            role_description: >-
              The human hepatic retinyl ester hydrolase drawn by RGD. Experimental GOA functions are generic
              carboxylesterase and sterol ester esterase activities; GO:0050253 rests on IBA. The enzyme
              purified as liver retinyl ester hydrolase is a non-specific carboxylesterase, and several other
              lipases and esterases (for example PNPLA2 in stellate cells, in the mouse GO-CAM) also hydrolyse
              retinyl esters, so CES1 is one representative hydrolase rather than the dedicated enzyme.
            evidence:
            - source_id: PMID:9490062
              statement: Hepatic retinyl ester hydrolase from pig and human liver is a non-specific carboxylesterase.
              supporting_text: Hepatic retinyl ester hydrolase (REH) activity was isolated from porcine and
                human liver and characterized
  connections:
  - source: retinol_delivery_uptake
    target: cellular_retinol_binding
    connection_type: PROVIDES_INPUT_FOR
    description: Retinol taken up through STRA6 is bound by CRBP1 in the cytosol.
  - source: cellular_retinol_binding
    target: retinol_retinal_interconversion
    connection_type: PROVIDES_INPUT_FOR
    description: Holo-CRBP1 retinol is the substrate of the membrane-bound RDH10.
  - source: retinol_retinal_interconversion
    target: retinal_oxidation
    connection_type: PROVIDES_INPUT_FOR
    description: The all-trans-retinal not reduced back by DHRS3 is oxidised to atRA by the ALDH1A enzymes.
  - source: retinal_oxidation
    target: retinoic_acid_binding
    connection_type: PROVIDES_INPUT_FOR
    description: Newly made atRA is bound by CRABP2 (delivery to RAR) or CRABP1 (retention).
  - source: retinoic_acid_binding
    target: retinoic_acid_catabolism
    connection_type: PROVIDES_INPUT_FOR
    description: Unbound and CRABP1-associated atRA is hydroxylated by the CYP26 enzymes.
  - source: cellular_retinol_binding
    target: retinyl_ester_storage
    connection_type: PROVIDES_INPUT_FOR
    description: Surplus holo-CRBP1 retinol is esterified by LRAT for storage.
  - source: retinyl_ester_storage
    target: cellular_retinol_binding
    connection_type: PROVIDES_INPUT_FOR
    description: Hydrolysis of stored retinyl esters returns retinol to the cellular pool.
notes: >-
  Derived from the RGD Pathway Ontology record and diagram PW:0001004 (retinoic acid metabolic pathway)
  through the RGD_PATHWAY_ONTOLOGY project's diagram->module route; GO mapping GO:0042573 retinoic acid
  metabolic process (skos:closeMatch). The 18-gene RGD human set and the diagram give the boundary: circulating
  retinol in, atRA made, bound and catabolised, with an output to the retinoic acid signaling pathway (PW:0001014).
  It is modelled as six required parts and one optional part: (1) RBP4/TTR transport and STRA6 uptake; (2)
  CRBP1 binding; (3) the RDH10-DHRS3 retinol dehydrogenase/retinaldehyde reductase pair; (4) a variant set
  of the ALDH1A1, ALDH1A2 and ALDH1A3 retinaldehyde dehydrogenases; (5) a variant set of CRABP2 and CRABP1;
  (6) a variant set of the CYP26A1, CYP26B1 and CYP26C1 hydroxylases; and (7, optional) retinyl ester storage,
  with LRAT esterification by module_ref and CES1 hydrolysis.

  Second RGD pathway considered, PW:0000141 (retinol metabolic pathway, GO:0042572), is NOT listed as an
  evidence source and is not claimed as covered. Its record and diagram describe dietary vitamin A absorption
  in the intestine: carotenoid uptake by SCARB1 and CD36, retinyl ester hydrolysis in the gut lumen by PNLIP,
  PNLIPRP2 and PLB1, central cleavage of beta-carotene to retinal by BCO1, reduction of retinal by AKR1B10,
  binding by RBP2 (CRBP2), re-esterification by LRAT, chylomicron secretion and ABCA1 efflux, with the ISX
  feedback on SCARB1 and BCO1. Of its 11 RGD human genes only LRAT (here by reference) and ALDH1A2 fall
  inside this module. Its content is enterocyte absorption and chylomicron packaging, a distinct module upstream
  of the plasma RBP4 pool, so it should get its own module rather than be counted as covered here.

  Boundary decisions. (a) Downstream signalling is not modelled: RAR/RXR activation and coregulator exchange
  are in modules/retinoic_acid_receptor_signaling.yaml (RGD PW:0001014). That module has a compact
  retinoic acid production and transport part, with ALDH1A2 and CRABP2 grounded by PAINT nodes, which overlaps
  parts 4 and 5 here; it could be replaced there by a module_ref to this module's retinal_oxidation and
  retinoic_acid_binding nodes (not edited here). (b) The retinoid visual cycle (modules/retinoid_visual_cycle.yaml)
  shares LRAT and DHRS3. LRAT is included by module_ref to its retinol_esterification node, since the reaction
  and enzyme are the same. DHRS3 is modelled again here, with its RDH10 partner, because the visual-cycle
  node treats it as a stand-alone buffer and has no RDH10; the activity term (GO:0052650) is the same in both.
  That module does not contain RBP4 or STRA6, so the plasma delivery step is modelled here. (c) Retinyl ester
  storage is optional: it buffers the retinol supply rather than being a step from retinol to atRA. CES1 is
  the RGD-drawn hydrolase; its GO:0050253 rests on IBA, and the purified liver retinyl ester hydrolase is a
  non-specific carboxylesterase, so it is a representative, not the dedicated enzyme. The mouse GO-CAM
  gomodel:67086be200001721 uses Pnpla2 for the same step in stellate cells. (d) Context, not participants:
  cytosolic medium-chain alcohol dehydrogenases (ADH1 class, ADH4, ADH7), which oxidise retinol in vitro and
  in mouse GO-CAMs gomodel:66f5faaa00001204 and gomodel:67086be200002705 (Adh1 GO:0004745), but whose
  redundancy RDH10 genetics argues against as the main embryonic route (PMID:17473173); and the other SDR
  retinol dehydrogenases in the RGD gene list, RDH16 and DHRS9, which have experimental GO:0004745 rows in
  human GOA but whose contribution to atRA synthesis in vivo is less clear than that of RDH10 and which also act
  on 3-alpha-hydroxysteroids. They could be added as an optional variant of part 3 if a curator judges the
  in vivo evidence sufficient. (e) FABP5 is drawn by RGD as delivering atRA to PPARD. It is a broad fatty
  acid-binding protein (GO:0005504 IDA), and the atRA-PPARD route is contested, so it is not a participant.
  (f) Not drawn by RGD and not modelled: BCO1 cleavage of beta-carotene (an alternative retinal source, in
  PW:0000141), RETSAT, the 9-cis-RA routes, and DHRS3/CYP26A1 transcriptional induction by atRA, which is the
  feedback recorded in the description but which acts through the RAR module and is not drawn as a connection.

  Molecular functions come from each protein's experimental GO annotations in QuickGO (checked 2026-11-05):
  RBP4 retinol binding GO:0019841 (IDA, PMID:571335), with GO:0140104 molecular carrier activity used as the
  annoton function after the mouse GO-CAM; STRA6 GO:0034632 (IDA, PMID:21901792); RBP1 GO:1904768 (IDA,
  PMID:28057518); RDH10 GO:0004745 (IDA, PMID:12407145, PMID:19458327); DHRS3 GO:0052650 (EXP, PMID:9705317;
  core function of the completed DHRS3 review); ALDH1A2 GO:0001758 (IDA, PMID:29240402); ALDH1A3 GO:0001758
  and GO:0002138 (IDA, PMID:27759097); CYP26A1 GO:0008401 (IDA) and GO:0062183 (IDA, PMID:22020119); CYP26B1
  and CYP26C1 GO:0008401 and GO:0034653 (IDA). Exceptions, used without experimental GOA support: ALDH1A1
  GO:0001758 (ISS/IEA; experimental rows are the parent GO:0004029); CRABP1 and CRABP2 GO:0001972 (IBA/IEA;
  CRABP2's only experimental MF row is cyclin binding); TTR GO:0140313 (TAS and mouse GO-CAM); CES1 GO:0050253
  (IBA). Possible upstream issue: the RDH10 GO:0004745 (NAD+) IDA row from PMID:12407145 cites a paper whose
  abstract reports a preference for NADP as cofactor, so the NAD+ term may need checking against the full text.
  Comparator check for processes: GO:0002138 is placed on RDH10 and the ALDH1A enzymes, which do the chemistry,
  and not on the binding proteins or STRA6; GO:0034653 only on the CYP26 enzymes.

  GO-CAM: gocams/index.tsv (checked 2026-11-05) has no human production model for any member. The seed's
  best_gocam lead is empty for PW:0001004. Mouse models are linked at activity level: Retinoid Metabolic
  Process 2 (gomodel:67086be200001721; Rbp4, Ttr), Retinoid Metabolic Process 1 (gomodel:66f5faaa00001204;
  Rbp1) and 4 (gomodel:67086be200002705; Dhrs3), and gomodel:5fce9b7300001742 for Cyp26a1, whose title is
  about Strap and splicing, so only the Cyp26a1 activity is relevant. These mouse models describe absorption,
  storage and mobilisation and contain no Rdh10, Aldh1a2/3 or Crabp activity, which is the main GO-CAM gap
  for this pathway. Gene reviews exist for DHRS3 and LRAT (and RDH11, not a member); the other members have
  none. PANTHER family ids and PTNs are deliberately not asserted. Most cited publications are abstract-only
  in the cache; PMID:21901792, PMID:24733397 (PMC), PMID:17473173 (PMC), PMID:29240402, PMID:27759097,
  PMID:17175089 and PMID:22020119 have full text or a PMC record.
