Function
Optional R,R/meso carbon entry. PP0552 accepts R,R and meso substrates and showed no NADP(H)-linked activity in Table 2. The PQQ alternatives handle S,S entry under their metal conditions. Acetoin feeding bypasses all entry enzymes.
Lipoyl-dependent acetoin cleavage produces acetaldehyde and acetyl-CoA through an AcoA/AcoB E1 reaction, AcoC acetyl transfer and E3-mediated carrier regeneration. NAD-dependent R,R/meso oxidation and metal-dependent PQQ-mediated S,S-butanediol oxidation can supply acetoin upstream. The compared bacterial implementations differ in E2 architecture, availability of a dedicated E3 and strength of direct biochemical evidence. Native systems are kept separate; the bacterial envelope does not imply universal conservation.
The boundary is acetoin cleavage plus the explicitly characterized optional NAD/PQQ entry routes, not acetoin synthesis or downstream acetaldehyde assimilation. AcoX/PP0556 is reviewed as locus-associated context but is not asserted to catalyze a step. Regulatory AcoR and lipoylation biosynthesis remain outside the core. Exact native selectors prevent mixed-species complexes; family descriptors classify proteins rather than asserting substrate-specific function for every family member. PpG2 Adh/AcoC are comparative exemplars, not a completed fifth native route. Scope stays CONCRETE with four native bacterial implementations (KT2440, C. necator H16, Syntrophotalea carbinolica, B. subtilis 168), each a separate variant, because the characterized evidence is per-organism and the E2 and E3 architectures differ; a single species-neutral motif would hide those differences. Family grounding was revised on 2026-11-02: PedE/PedH use PTHR32303:SF20 and AcoB uses PTHR43257:SF3, both verified in PANTHER's member index; the KT2440/PpG2 and H16 AcoC descriptors are grounded on NCBIfam NF011457 alone, because PANTHER scatters these lipoyl/alpha-beta-hydrolase acetoin E2s across three hydrolase families (PTHR43194:SF2, PTHR43798:SF33, PTHR43689:SF8) whose other members are unrelated hydrolases. Those subfamilies were briefly carried in family_terms, which was reverted in review: it required each hydrolase family to adjudicate acetyl transfer, and the only scope the schema offers is subfamily-wide, which would have asserted the E2 activity for 87 non-E2 proteins. Each of the three families is still reviewed, and each records why it makes no acetyl-transfer assertion. The bdhA/Adh and B. subtilis AcoC descriptors assert no family id, because PTHR43161 is heterogeneous and PANTHER and UniProt disagree about O31550. Every PANTHER family a member protein belongs to is nevertheless reviewed under interpro/panther/.
All recommended fields populated.
✗ none found
No MODULE:bacterial_2_3_butanediol_acetoin_catabolism deep-research report alongside the module YAML.
2 leaf node(s) with no concrete protein grounding:
✓ every declared conforms_to bundle matches its template motif.
9 gene-function check(s) reflected in core functions · 0 conflict(s) · 6 evidence or coverage gap(s) (24 comparison(s))
Retained noncore functions are reported separately; they do not require promotion to core functions. Support from representative genes does not establish conservation across the whole family. Missing reviews or identifiers leave a claim unverified.
| Annoton | Participant | Function | Assessment |
|---|---|---|---|
| kt_bdh | bdhA (PSEPK) UniProtKB:Q88QE2 Gene |
(R,R)-butanediol dehydrogenase activity GO:0000721 |
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass). |
| kt_pedE | pedE (KT2440) UniProtKB:Q88JH5 Gene |
PQQ-dependent S,S-butanediol oxidation GO:0016614 |
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass). |
| kt_pedH | pedH (KT2440) UniProtKB:Q88JH0 Gene |
PQQ-dependent S,S-butanediol oxidation GO:0016614 |
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass). |
| kt_e1 | PROTEIN_COMPLEX Gene |
oxidoreductase activity, acting on the aldehyde or oxo group of donors, disulfide as acceptor GO:0016624 |
Participant Unchecked
No direct UniProt participant to compare. Abstract selectors and complex-wide activities cannot be inferred from donor or subunit gene reviews. |
| kt_e2 | acoC (PSEPK) UniProtKB:Q88QE1 Gene |
dihydrolipoyllysine-residue acetyltransferase activity GO:0004742 |
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass). |
| h16_e1 | PROTEIN_COMPLEX Gene |
oxidoreductase activity, acting on the aldehyde or oxo group of donors, disulfide as acceptor GO:0016624 |
Participant Unchecked
No direct UniProt participant to compare. Abstract selectors and complex-wide activities cannot be inferred from donor or subunit gene reviews. |
| h16_e2 | acoC (CUPNH) UniProtKB:P27747 Gene |
dihydrolipoyllysine-residue acetyltransferase activity GO:0004742 |
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass). |
| pc_e1 | PROTEIN_COMPLEX Gene |
oxidoreductase activity, acting on the aldehyde or oxo group of donors, disulfide as acceptor GO:0016624 |
Participant Unchecked
No direct UniProt participant to compare. Abstract selectors and complex-wide activities cannot be inferred from donor or subunit gene reviews. |
| pc_e2 | acoC (SYNCB) UniProtKB:Q59658 Gene |
dihydrolipoyllysine-residue acetyltransferase activity GO:0004742 |
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass). |
| pc_e3 | acoL (SYNCB) UniProtKB:Q60154 Gene |
dihydrolipoyl dehydrogenase (NADH) activity GO:0004148 |
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass). |
| bs_e1 | PROTEIN_COMPLEX Gene |
oxidoreductase activity, acting on the aldehyde or oxo group of donors, disulfide as acceptor GO:0016624 |
Participant Unchecked
No direct UniProt participant to compare. Abstract selectors and complex-wide activities cannot be inferred from donor or subunit gene reviews. |
| bs_e2 | acoC (BACSU) UniProtKB:O31550 Gene |
dihydrolipoyllysine-residue acetyltransferase activity GO:0004742 |
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass). |
| bs_e3 | acoL (BACSU) UniProtKB:O34324 Gene |
dihydrolipoyl dehydrogenase (NADH) activity GO:0004148 |
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass). |
| kt_bdh | R,R-butanediol dehydrogenase homologs Family |
(R,R)-butanediol dehydrogenase activity GO:0000721 |
Family Id Missing
The family has no identifier linking it to a curated family review. |
| kt_pedE | PQQ-dependent alcohol dehydrogenase family PANTHER:PTHR32303:SF20 Family |
PQQ-dependent S,S-butanediol oxidation GO:0016614 |
Family Supported
Family review supports GO:0052934 for PANTHER:PTHR32303:SF20. Cytochrome c-linked oxidation of primary and secondary alcohols is the function of the characterized SF20 type I alcohol dehydrogenases, whether calcium-dependent (PedE, ExaA) or lanthanide-dependent (PedH, ExaF). It is not safe for SF4, whose glucose, quinate and glycerol dehydrogenases reduce ubiquinone and whose methanol dehydrogenases are the distinct cytochrome cL-linked enzymes, nor for SF10 (BamB). The catalytic metal is not determined by subfamily, so this assessment does not license calcium- or lanthanide-specific claims. |
| kt_pedH | PQQ-dependent alcohol dehydrogenase family PANTHER:PTHR32303:SF20 Family |
PQQ-dependent S,S-butanediol oxidation GO:0016614 |
Family Supported
Family review supports GO:0052934 for PANTHER:PTHR32303:SF20. Cytochrome c-linked oxidation of primary and secondary alcohols is the function of the characterized SF20 type I alcohol dehydrogenases, whether calcium-dependent (PedE, ExaA) or lanthanide-dependent (PedH, ExaF). It is not safe for SF4, whose glucose, quinate and glycerol dehydrogenases reduce ubiquinone and whose methanol dehydrogenases are the distinct cytochrome cL-linked enzymes, nor for SF10 (BamB). The catalytic metal is not determined by subfamily, so this assessment does not license calcium- or lanthanide-specific claims. |
| kt_e2 | Proteobacterial lipoyl-domain and alpha/beta-hydrolase AcoC proteins NCBIfam:NF011457 Family |
dihydrolipoyllysine-residue acetyltransferase activity GO:0004742 |
Family Review Missing
No supported structured family review is available for NCBIfam:NF011457. |
| kt_e3 | Native acetoin-compatible dihydrolipoyl dehydrogenase lineage, identity unresolved Family |
dihydrolipoyl dehydrogenase (NADH) activity GO:0004148 |
Family Id Missing
The family has no identifier linking it to a curated family review. |
| h16_e2 | Proteobacterial lipoyl-domain and alpha/beta-hydrolase AcoC proteins NCBIfam:NF011457 Family |
dihydrolipoyllysine-residue acetyltransferase activity GO:0004742 |
Family Review Missing
No supported structured family review is available for NCBIfam:NF011457. |
| h16_e3 | Native acetoin-compatible dihydrolipoyl dehydrogenase lineage, identity unresolved Family |
dihydrolipoyl dehydrogenase (NADH) activity GO:0004148 |
Family Id Missing
The family has no identifier linking it to a curated family review. |
| pc_e2 | Lipoyl-bearing acetoin-system AcoC proteins PANTHER:PTHR23151:SF90 Family |
dihydrolipoyllysine-residue acetyltransferase activity GO:0004742 |
Family Supported
Family review supports GO:0004742 for PANTHER:PTHR23151:SF90. Catalytic E2 subfamilies, as pyruvate_metabolism asserts on the base family. Human PDHX in SF90 is a member exception. |
| pc_e3 | Acetoin-associated dihydrolipoyl dehydrogenases PANTHER:PTHR22912:SF151 Family |
dihydrolipoyl dehydrogenase (NADH) activity GO:0004148 |
Family Supported
Family review supports GO:0004148 for PANTHER:PTHR22912:SF151. The E3 subfamilies, not the divergent SthA transhydrogenase. SF219 is included on the basis of its independently mapped AcoL representative, the native sequence-based E3 assignment in PMID:10368162 and the conserved catalytic architecture. This extends chemistry scope, not a requirement that all E3 paralogs serve the same physiological complexes. No new PAINT node is inferred. |
| bs_e2 | Canonical lipoyl E2 acyltransferases of 2-oxoacid dehydrogenase-type complexes Family |
dihydrolipoyllysine-residue acetyltransferase activity GO:0004742 |
Family Id Missing
The family has no identifier linking it to a curated family review. |
| bs_e3 | Acetoin-associated dihydrolipoyl dehydrogenases PANTHER:PTHR22912:SF219 Family |
dihydrolipoyl dehydrogenase (NADH) activity GO:0004148 |
Family Supported
Family review supports GO:0004148 for PANTHER:PTHR22912:SF219. The E3 subfamilies, not the divergent SthA transhydrogenase. SF219 is included on the basis of its independently mapped AcoL representative, the native sequence-based E3 assignment in PMID:10368162 and the conserved catalytic architecture. This extends chemistry scope, not a requirement that all E3 paralogs serve the same physiological complexes. No new PAINT node is inferred. |
19 complete review(s) · 3 with deep research · 0 missing review · 16 reviewed but lacking deep research
| Gene | Review | Complete | Deep research |
|---|---|---|---|
| acoA O31404 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| acoA P27745 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| acoA Q57102 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| acoA Q88QD9 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| acoB O34591 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| acoB P27746 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| acoB Q57041 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| acoB Q88QE0 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| acoC O31550 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| acoC P27747 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| acoC Q59658 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| acoC Q59695 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| acoC Q88QE1 | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| acoL O34324 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| acoL Q60154 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| adh Q59696 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| bdhA Q88QE2 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| pedE Q88JH5 | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| pedH Q88JH0 | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
Native carbon utilization and locus evidence; optional NAD-BDH and metal-dependent PQQ entry pathways account for the three butanediol stereoisomers. E2 transfer is inferred and the E3 paralog is unknown.
Optional R,R/meso carbon entry. PP0552 accepts R,R and meso substrates and showed no NADP(H)-linked activity in Table 2. The PQQ alternatives handle S,S entry under their metal conditions. Acetoin feeding bypasses all entry enzymes.
Calcium-dependent PedE available; native expression favored under low usable lanthanide conditions. Native substrate phenotypes and purified quinoprotein chemistry support participation. Protein presence alone is insufficient without metal, expression and electron-transfer competence.
Usable lanthanide supports PedH catalysis; native expression is favored by lanthanides. La availability in the 2021 growth experiment demonstrates this route, not all lanthanide ions. Native substrate phenotypes and purified quinoprotein chemistry support participation. Protein presence alone is insufficient without metal, expression and electron-transfer competence.
TPP-dependent cleavage releases acetaldehyde and reductively acetylates the lipoyl carrier. GO:0016624 names the assembled physiological redox class. Acetoin dehydrogenase (NAD+) GO:0019152 instead names acetoin/diacetyl interconversion and is not used. DCPIP assay activity is distinguished from native lipoyl chemistry.
Transfers lipoyl-bound acetyl to CoA. Pelobacter has purified component/reconstitution support. H16 and Pseudomonas carry a distinct alpha/beta-hydrolase architecture and their exact E2 chemistry remains a curated inference. Bacillus has canonical E2 motifs and native pathway evidence; no isolated Bacillus transfer assay is claimed.
Regenerates the oxidized lipoyl carrier. AcoL is experimentally linked to Pelobacter and inferred from sequence/locus in Bacillus; the KT2440 and H16 native protein identities remain unassigned.
Purified native E1 and fast-migrating AcoC protein; E2 chemistry is inferred and the E3 paralog remains unassigned.
TPP-dependent cleavage releases acetaldehyde and reductively acetylates the lipoyl carrier. GO:0016624 names the assembled physiological redox class. Acetoin dehydrogenase (NAD+) GO:0019152 instead names acetoin/diacetyl interconversion and is not used. DCPIP assay activity is distinguished from native lipoyl chemistry.
Transfers lipoyl-bound acetyl to CoA. Pelobacter has purified component/reconstitution support. H16 and Pseudomonas carry a distinct alpha/beta-hydrolase architecture and their exact E2 chemistry remains a curated inference. Bacillus has canonical E2 motifs and native pathway evidence; no isolated Bacillus transfer assay is claimed.
Regenerates the oxidized lipoyl carrier. AcoL is experimentally linked to Pelobacter and inferred from sequence/locus in Bacillus; the KT2440 and H16 native protein identities remain unassigned.
Purified native components reconstitute the pathway. Historical sequence records are species-level taxon 19; the source strain is Gra Bd 1.
TPP-dependent cleavage releases acetaldehyde and reductively acetylates the lipoyl carrier. GO:0016624 names the assembled physiological redox class. Acetoin dehydrogenase (NAD+) GO:0019152 instead names acetoin/diacetyl interconversion and is not used. DCPIP assay activity is distinguished from native lipoyl chemistry.
Transfers lipoyl-bound acetyl to CoA. Pelobacter has purified component/reconstitution support. H16 and Pseudomonas carry a distinct alpha/beta-hydrolase architecture and their exact E2 chemistry remains a curated inference. Bacillus has canonical E2 motifs and native pathway evidence; no isolated Bacillus transfer assay is claimed.
Regenerates the oxidized lipoyl carrier. AcoL is experimentally linked to Pelobacter and inferred from sequence/locus in Bacillus; the KT2440 and H16 native protein identities remain unassigned.
Native strain 168 pathway genetics plus sequence-supported component chemistry. The paper reports small AcoC C-terminal differences from the later reference sequence.
TPP-dependent cleavage releases acetaldehyde and reductively acetylates the lipoyl carrier. GO:0016624 names the assembled physiological redox class. Acetoin dehydrogenase (NAD+) GO:0019152 instead names acetoin/diacetyl interconversion and is not used. DCPIP assay activity is distinguished from native lipoyl chemistry.
Transfers lipoyl-bound acetyl to CoA. Pelobacter has purified component/reconstitution support. H16 and Pseudomonas carry a distinct alpha/beta-hydrolase architecture and their exact E2 chemistry remains a curated inference. Bacillus has canonical E2 motifs and native pathway evidence; no isolated Bacillus transfer assay is claimed.
Regenerates the oxidized lipoyl carrier. AcoL is experimentally linked to Pelobacter and inferred from sequence/locus in Bacillus; the KT2440 and H16 native protein identities remain unassigned.