Function
NAD-dependent forward reaction of the exact Q59104 enzyme. Growth-supporting flux is established in selected/expressing Cupriavidus backgrounds, not inferred from genome presence alone.
Two consecutive non-CoA reactions oxidize 4-hydroxybutyrate to succinate: NAD-dependent Gbd forms succinate semialdehyde, and a nonacylating succinate-semialdehyde dehydrogenase forms succinate. The experimentally supported implementation is grounded in selected or experimentally expressing Cupriavidus necator backgrounds. Pseudomonas putida candidates and a distinct 3-hydroxybutyrate enzyme provide comparative context without establishing a complete native free-acid route. Uptake, upstream diol oxidation, GABA supply, CoA-dependent beta-oxidation, PHA synthesis and reverse succinate degradation are outside the boundary.
One experimentally grounded species-level route is required; optional Pseudomonas comparisons cannot complete it, even when mixed with a single Cupriavidus enzyme. Exact selectors preserve all original accessions while avoiding a broad family-wide activity claim. Selected-strain expression and actual flux are not computed from sequence presence by the Boolean compiler. No claim is made that these proteins form a stable complex, that both Cupriavidus enzymes were jointly purified/reconstituted, or that the named Sad candidates exhaust all SSA enzymes. Every SSA-oxidation annoton uses the cofactor-general GO:0009013, following one convention for dual-acceptor succinate-semialdehyde dehydrogenases across this module and its member reviews. One active site running one reaction with either nicotinamide acceptor is stated with the parent term, which is what its definition says, and the cofactor-specific children are kept as annotations at their measured weights rather than as separate core functions. So the Cupriavidus GabD core is GO:0009013 with NADP as the measured major branch and NAD the minor one, the E. coli Sad core is GO:0009013 with the preference reversed, and for the optional Pseudomonas Sad candidates the acceptor preference is simply unresolved. This is not an assertion of cofactor exclusivity in any of the four cases. On taxonomic scope, the second reaction is kept species-neutral and sampled in three genera, because it is broadly distributed and experimentally settled outside Cupriavidus, with Escherichia coli Sad added as a characterized exemplar. The first reaction is not generalized. Free-acid 4HB oxidation is experimentally grounded only in selected Cupriavidus backgrounds, the Pseudomonas candidate for it rests on an unchecked submitter name that its gene review marks as an over-annotation, and E. coli has no demonstrated 4HB dehydrogenase. The module therefore stays CONCRETE, with a bacterial envelope and named exemplars, rather than asserting a conserved pan-bacterial route.
All recommended fields populated.
✓ present
✓ every leaf node grounds to a representative protein.
✓ every declared conforms_to bundle matches its template motif.
7 gene-function check(s) reflected in core functions · 0 conflict(s) · 1 evidence or coverage gap(s) (14 comparison(s))
Retained noncore functions are reported separately; they do not require promotion to core functions. Support from representative genes does not establish conservation across the whole family. Missing reviews or identifiers leave a claim unverified.
| Annoton | Participant | Function | Assessment |
|---|---|---|---|
| cupne_gbd_4hb_oxidation | gbd (Cupriavidus necator) UniProtKB:Q59104 Gene |
4-hydroxybutyrate dehydrogenase activity GO:0047577 |
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass). |
| cupne_gabd_ssa_oxidation | gabD (Cupriavidus necator) UniProtKB:Q9RBF6 Gene |
succinate-semialdehyde dehydrogenase [NAD(P)+] activity GO:0009013 |
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass). |
| psepk_gbd_class | gbd (Pseudomonas putida KT2440) UniProtKB:Q88JJ9 Gene |
alcohol dehydrogenase (NAD+) activity GO:0004022 |
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass). |
| psepk_sad_I_ssa | sad-I (Pseudomonas putida KT2440) UniProtKB:Q88K05 Gene |
succinate-semialdehyde dehydrogenase [NAD(P)+] activity GO:0009013 |
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass). |
| psepk_sad_II_ssa | sad-II (Pseudomonas putida KT2440) UniProtKB:Q88I50 Gene |
succinate-semialdehyde dehydrogenase [NAD(P)+] activity GO:0009013 |
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass). |
| ecoli_sad_ssa | sad (Escherichia coli K-12) UniProtKB:P76149 Gene |
succinate-semialdehyde dehydrogenase [NAD(P)+] activity GO:0009013 |
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass). |
| psepk_pp2049_3hb | PP_2049 (Pseudomonas putida KT2440) UniProtKB:Q88L86 Gene |
3-hydroxybutyrate dehydrogenase activity GO:0003858 |
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass). |
| cupne_gbd_4hb_oxidation | Classification of this exact protein PANTHER:PTHR11496:SF102 Family |
4-hydroxybutyrate dehydrogenase activity GO:0047577 |
Family Supported
Family review supports GO:0047577 for PANTHER:PTHR11496:SF102. The term the bacterial 4-hydroxybutyrate oxidation module requires of this family. It is established for Cupriavidus necator GHBDH (Q59104) in SF102, whose recombinant enzyme was assayed in the alcohol-to-aldehyde direction with NAD and whose Fe2+ chelators and candidate general base were mutated individually. As with GO:0120542, SF102 is a mixed subfamily that PANTHER does not split, so the term is safe only for the GHBDH-type clade within it and not for every SF102 member; a member needs its own substrate evidence, since group III Fe-ADH architecture alone does not pick out 4-hydroxybutyrate. Not safe for SF83, SF94, SF104, SF106 or SF107 as subfamilies. |
| cupne_gabd_ssa_oxidation | Classification of this exact protein PANTHER:PTHR43353:SF5 Family |
succinate-semialdehyde dehydrogenase [NAD(P)+] activity GO:0009013 |
Family Supported
Family review supports GO:0009013 for PANTHER:PTHR43353:SF5. Asserted by gaba_shunt; accepted by ALDH5A1, UGA2, ssd1 and ssd2. |
| psepk_gbd_class | Classification of this exact protein PANTHER:PTHR11496:SF102 Family |
alcohol dehydrogenase (NAD+) activity GO:0004022 |
Family Function Unreviewed
Family review leaves GO:0120542 UNRESOLVED. Positive support is retained for the ADH4/AdhB enzymes in SF102 and for Salmonella LT2 EutG P41795 in SF94. The latter has native physiological evidence for acetaldehyde reduction and NAD recycling, not purified target kinetics. The official tree places P41795 and E. coli P76553 in SF94, but the former SF102-only restriction wrongly excluded this positive member. SF102 itself mixes substrate specificities, and no whole-SF94 kinetic or residue-level conservation claim is made. Thus neither a family-wide nor an exhaustive whole-subfamily grant expresses the experimentally bounded scope. The exact prior judgment and complete original review are archived in source-analysis/ethanolamine-scope-reassessment.json; this uncertainty concerns scope, not rejection of the positive members. |
| psepk_sad_I_ssa | Classification of this exact protein PANTHER:PTHR43217:SF2 Family |
succinate-semialdehyde dehydrogenase [NAD(P)+] activity GO:0009013 |
Family Supported
Family review supports GO:0009013 for PANTHER:PTHR43217:SF2. The cofactor-general term that modules selecting this family should use. It is safe for both subfamilies, which between them cover every curated member: direct assays establish it for E. coli Sad in SF1, and the InterPro GABD/Sad-like integration plus the uniform curated naming of the remaining members support it for the rest. It is stated at subfamily resolution rather than family-wide because one member of SF1, Paenarthrobacter nicotinovorans Q8GAK7, is curated only as a generic aldehyde dehydrogenase, and because the family's 9604 unreviewed members have no member-level evidence; a member not assigned to SF1 or SF2 is outside this judgement. |
| psepk_sad_II_ssa | Classification of this exact protein PANTHER:PTHR43217:SF1 Family |
succinate-semialdehyde dehydrogenase [NAD(P)+] activity GO:0009013 |
Family Supported
Family review supports GO:0009013 for PANTHER:PTHR43217:SF1. The cofactor-general term that modules selecting this family should use. It is safe for both subfamilies, which between them cover every curated member: direct assays establish it for E. coli Sad in SF1, and the InterPro GABD/Sad-like integration plus the uniform curated naming of the remaining members support it for the rest. It is stated at subfamily resolution rather than family-wide because one member of SF1, Paenarthrobacter nicotinovorans Q8GAK7, is curated only as a generic aldehyde dehydrogenase, and because the family's 9604 unreviewed members have no member-level evidence; a member not assigned to SF1 or SF2 is outside this judgement. |
| ecoli_sad_ssa | Classification of this exact protein PANTHER:PTHR43217:SF1 Family |
succinate-semialdehyde dehydrogenase [NAD(P)+] activity GO:0009013 |
Family Supported
Family review supports GO:0009013 for PANTHER:PTHR43217:SF1. The cofactor-general term that modules selecting this family should use. It is safe for both subfamilies, which between them cover every curated member: direct assays establish it for E. coli Sad in SF1, and the InterPro GABD/Sad-like integration plus the uniform curated naming of the remaining members support it for the rest. It is stated at subfamily resolution rather than family-wide because one member of SF1, Paenarthrobacter nicotinovorans Q8GAK7, is curated only as a generic aldehyde dehydrogenase, and because the family's 9604 unreviewed members have no member-level evidence; a member not assigned to SF1 or SF2 is outside this judgement. |
| psepk_pp2049_3hb | Classification of this exact protein PANTHER:PTHR11496:SF102 Family |
3-hydroxybutyrate dehydrogenase activity GO:0003858 |
Family Supported
Family review supports GO:0003858 for PANTHER:PTHR11496:SF102. The comparative activity the same module records for P. putida KT2440 PP_2049 (Q88L86), also in SF102, whose purified protein was assayed on (R)-3-hydroxybutyrate with NAD and shown by deletion to be the main route to acetoacetate, ahead of the canonical SDR-family HbdH (PP_3073). The SF102 caveat applies here too: the subfamily mixes substrate specificities, so this is the safe scope boundary rather than a property of all SF102 members, and 3-hydroxybutyrate and 4-hydroxybutyrate specificity are separate claims that must each be evidenced per member. The classical bacterial 3-hydroxybutyrate dehydrogenases are short-chain dehydrogenases outside this family altogether, which is why this is not a family-wide expectation. |
7 complete review(s) · 2 with deep research · 0 missing review · 5 reviewed but lacking deep research
| Gene | Review | Complete | Deep research |
|---|---|---|---|
| gabD Q9RBF6 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| gbd Q59104 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| gbd Q88JJ9 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| PP_2049 Q88L86 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| sad P76149 | ✓ | ✓ | ✗ |
| sad-I Q88K05 | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| sad-II Q88I50 | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
Bacterial chemistry envelope, sampled by one supported Cupriavidus implementation and Pseudomonas comparative candidates; not a claim of pan-bacterial conservation.
Bacterial chemistry envelope, sampled by one supported Cupriavidus implementation and Pseudomonas comparative candidates; not a claim of pan-bacterial conservation.
The historical studies include HF39-derived SK4040 and the published SHF3 clone. This is a selected-strain species-level biochemical implementation, not proof of unchanged wild-type H16 growth or a single purified two-enzyme reconstitution.
NAD-dependent forward reaction of the exact Q59104 enzyme. Growth-supporting flux is established in selected/expressing Cupriavidus backgrounds, not inferred from genome presence alone.
The published SHF3 GabD clone supplies the nonacylating SSADH reaction of this step. Both acceptors were measured on the exact clone, with substantially higher NADP-supported activity at pH 11 and 30°C per BRENDA, so this annoton uses the cofactor-general term, which is also the single core function of the member review; the cofactor-specific children remain as separate rows there, the NAD-specific one non-core at its measured weight. This asserts neither exclusivity nor a physiological cofactor ratio. The family review for PTHR43353 scopes both the general term and its NADP child to this subfamily. Proton stoichiometry depends on the chosen chemical representation and is not encoded by these entity lists.
Original submitted Gbd candidate. Broad Fe-alcohol-dehydrogenase architecture does not prove 4HB specificity. Q88JJ9 is PP_2650, not the genetically tested PP_2049; this optional comparator cannot satisfy the required Cupriavidus oxidation step.
Cofactor-general succinate-semialdehyde oxidation is supported by the exact target substrate-family classifications. Sad-I has competing NAD-FunFam and NADP-named PANTHER classifications. NAD capacity remains a qualified gene-review inference, not a measured acceptor preference. No physiological pairing with PP_2650/PP_2049 is established; this optional comparator cannot satisfy the native core.
Cofactor-general succinate-semialdehyde oxidation is supported by the exact target substrate-family classifications. Sad-II has an NAD-FunFam assignment compatible with its broad NAD(P)-named PANTHER subgroup. NAD capacity remains a qualified gene-review inference, not a measured acceptor preference. No physiological pairing with PP_2650/PP_2049 is established; this optional comparator cannot satisfy the native core.
Directly assayed, purified exemplar of the second reaction in a third genus, included so the SSA-oxidation step is not read as a Cupriavidus or Pseudomonas peculiarity. Purified Sad oxidizes succinate semialdehyde with either acceptor, preferring NAD. It is optional and cannot complete this module, because E. coli has no demonstrated free-acid 4HB dehydrogenase for the upstream step and its own succinate semialdehyde comes from GABA transamination, which is outside the boundary.
Direct NAD-dependent R-3HB oxidation produces acetoacetate. This is not 4HB oxidation to succinate semialdehyde. Native 4HB-growth dependence establishes relevance but not the missing free-acid reaction; failed 2020 extract assays do not prove absence.