Root ground-tissue radial patterning by the SHORT-ROOT-SCARECROW-BIRD module

Radial patterning of the Arabidopsis root ground tissue is organised by a mobile GRAS-domain transcriptional regulator. SHORT-ROOT (SHR) is transcribed in the stele but the protein moves through plasmodesmata into the single adjacent cell layer (endodermis, cortex/endodermis initial (CEI) and quiescent centre (QC)). There it is captured in the nucleus by the related GRAS protein SCARECROW (SCR), with which it forms a head-to-head heterodimer, and by BIRD/INDETERMINATE-DOMAIN (IDD) C2H2 zinc-finger transcription factors such as JACKDAW (JKD/IDD10) and MAGPIE (MGP/IDD3). The BIRD zinc fingers ZF1-ZF3 contact DNA while ZF3-ZF4 dock into a groove on SHR, so the SHR-SCR heterodimer acts as a transcriptional coregulator brought to target promoters by BIRD proteins. Nuclear retention limits SHR movement to one layer, and the SHR-SCR-BIRD complex activates SCR itself (a positive feedback loop), MGP and other BIRDs (a feed-forward loop), and the D-type cyclin CYCD6;1. CYCD6;1 binds and activates CDKB1 kinases that phosphorylate RETINOBLASTOMA-RELATED (RBR), relieving RBR repression of SCR; this nested feed-forward loop triggers the formative asymmetric periclinal division of the CEI daughter that produces separate endodermis and cortex layers. SHR-SCR also specify endodermal identity, and SCR is required cell-autonomously for QC identity, providing the niche context in which the QC transcription factor WOX5 maintains the surrounding stem cells. Middle-cortex formation later in development reuses the SHR-SCR-CYCD6;1 module.

MODULE:root_radial_patterning_shr_scrDRAFTCONCRETEDevelopmental Processmodules/root_radial_patterning_shr_scr.yaml
root radial pattern formationGO:0090057 asymmetric cell divisionGO:0008356
PMID:28211915
Structure of the SHR-SCR heterodimer bound to the BIRD/IDD transcriptional factor JKD.
SHR-SCR is a transcriptional cofactor docked on the zinc fingers of BIRD/IDD DNA-binding factors.
SHR-SCR function as transcription cofactors by binding to the third and fourth ZFs, (ZF3-ZF4) of JKD
PMID:17446396
An evolutionarily conserved mechanism delimiting SHR movement defines a single layer of endodermis in plants.
SCR sequesters SHR in the nucleus, restricting SHR movement to one cell layer.
SCARECROW (SCR) blocks SHR movement by sequestering it into the nucleus through protein-protein interaction
PMID:20596025
Spatiotemporal regulation of cell-cycle genes by SHORTROOT links patterning and growth.
SHR and SCR directly activate CYCD6;1 at the onset of the formative division.
Coincident with the onset of a specific formative division, SHR and SCR directly activate a D-type cyclin
PMID:22921914
A bistable circuit involving SCARECROW-RETINOBLASTOMA integrates cues to inform asymmetric stem cell division.
CYCD6;1-CDKB1 phosphorylation of RBR and the SCR-RBR interaction form nested feed-forward loops positioning the asymmetric division.
We demonstrate that this interaction, together with the activity of the RBR regulator CYCD6;1, defines the precise position of ACDs in the stem cell area through two nested feedforward loops
PMID:26494755
Transcriptional control of tissue formation throughout root development.
BIRDs (JKD, BIB, MGP, NUC, BLJ) retain SHR in the nucleus and are required for formative divisions.
JKD and BALD-IBIS regulate SHR movement by promoting its nuclear retention, and cooperatively with MAGPIE (MGP) and NUTCRACKER (NUC) are required for the formative divisions that pattern the ground tissue into cortex and endodermis
PMID:17785527
Arabidopsis JACKDAW and MAGPIE zinc finger proteins delimit asymmetric cell division and stabilize tissue boundaries by restricting SHORT-ROOT action.
JKD and MGP act in a SHR-dependent feed-forward loop that regulates the range of SHR/SCR action.
JACKDAW and MAGPIE genes, which encode members of a plant-specific family of zinc finger proteins, act in a SHR-dependent feed-forward loop to regulate the range of action of SHORT-ROOT and SCARECROW

CONCRETE Arabidopsis module. All members are grounded as GENE_PRODUCT selectors by UniProtKB accession taken from the gene folders (SHR Q9SZF7, SCR Q9M384, JKD Q700D2, MGP Q9ZWA6, CYCD6;1 Q9ZR04, WOX5 Q8H1D2). No PANTHER family ids are asserted: UniProt assigns the BIRD/IDD proteins to PTHR10593, whose official family name ("SERINE/THREONINE-PROTEIN KINASE RIO") is dominated by an unrelated member, so a family descriptor would mislead. For reference, UniProt places JKD in subfamily PTHR10593:SF231 ("PROTEIN INDETERMINATE-DOMAIN 13-RELATED") and MGP in PTHR10593:SF148 ("ZINC FINGER PROTEIN MAGPIE"), and CYCD6;1 in PTHR10177 ("CYCLINS"). These are recorded here only and are not asserted as family descriptors. Other BIRDs (BIB/IDD9, NUC/IDD8, BLJ/IDD1, IME/IDD2) and CDKB1;1/1;2 and RBR participate but have no gene reviews yet; they are named in prose only. WOX5 is modelled as an optional context part for QC identity, not as a core step of ground-tissue patterning. No GO-CAM models in gocams/index.tsv contain these proteins. SHR intercellular movement is described in the SHR gene review (proposed new term) and is represented here only in prose and as the first part. Process granularity differs between annotons on purpose. The SHR annoton reuses GO:0009956 radial pattern formation from the existing SHR review, because SHR also acts in shoot tissues (its review covers leaf development), so the general term is kept there. The JKD and MGP annotons use the root-specific child GO:0090057 root radial pattern formation, because their documented roles are confined to the root. Both SCR and JKD nuclear-capture annotons use GO:0051457 maintenance of protein location in nucleus, because both retain SHR that has already entered the nucleus.

6Nodes
5Parts
0Variant Sets
0Variants
9Annotons
5Connections

Derived QC

Recommended-field compliance

100.0% recommended fields populated

All recommended fields populated.

Module deep research

✗ none found

No MODULE:root_radial_patterning_shr_scr deep-research report alongside the module YAML.

Leaf nodes lacking representative members

✓ every leaf node grounds to a representative protein.

Template conformance

✓ every declared conforms_to bundle matches its template motif.

Reaction chaining (advisory)

✓ every PRECEDES step chains, or its break is acknowledged via chaining_status.

  • shr_mobile_signal → shr_nuclear_capture [NOT_CHECKED]

Function consistency and core coverage

9 gene-function check(s) reflected in core functions · 0 conflict(s) · 0 evidence or coverage gap(s) (9 comparison(s))

Retained noncore functions are reported separately; they do not require promotion to core functions. Support from representative genes does not establish conservation across the whole family. Missing reviews or identifiers leave a claim unverified.

AnnotonParticipantFunctionAssessment
shr_coregulator SHR
UniProtKB:Q9SZF7
Gene
transcription coregulator activity
GO:0003712
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass).
scr_capture SCR
UniProtKB:Q9M384
Gene
protein domain specific binding
GO:0019904
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass).
jkd_capture JKD
UniProtKB:Q700D2
Gene
transcription coregulator binding
GO:0001221
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass).
mgp_capture MGP
UniProtKB:Q9ZWA6
Gene
transcription coregulator binding
GO:0001221
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass).
jkd_tf JKD
UniProtKB:Q700D2
Gene
DNA-binding transcription factor activity
GO:0003700
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass).
mgp_tf MGP
UniProtKB:Q9ZWA6
Gene
DNA-binding transcription factor activity
GO:0003700
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass).
scr_coregulator SCR
UniProtKB:Q9M384
Gene
transcription coregulator activity
GO:0003712
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass).
cycd6_1_cdk_regulator CYCD6;1
UniProtKB:Q9ZR04
Gene
cyclin-dependent protein serine/threonine kinase regulator activity
GO:0016538
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass).
wox5_qc_repressor WOX5
UniProtKB:Q8H1D2
Gene
DNA-binding transcription repressor activity
GO:0001217
Core Supported
The GO molecular function is reflected in core_functions (exact term or a reviewed subclass).

Gene-review completeness (6/6 grounded genes reviewed)

6 complete review(s) · 3 with deep research · 0 missing review · 3 reviewed but lacking deep research

Gene Review Complete Deep research
CYCD6-1 Q9ZR04 ✓ ✓ ✗
JKD Q700D2 ✓ ✓ ✗
MGP Q9ZWA6 ✓ ✓ ✗
SCR Q9M384 ✓ ✓ ✓
SHR Q9SZF7 ✓ ✓ ✓
WOX5 Q8H1D2 ✓ ✓ ✓

Details

Context
Arabidopsis thalianaNCBITaxon:3702
SHR-SCR-BIRD root ground-tissue radial patterningDevelopmental Processroot_radial_patterning_shr_scr
root radial pattern formationGO:0090057 asymmetric cell divisionGO:0008356
Context
Arabidopsis thalianaNCBITaxon:3702

Connections

SHR protein that has moved into the adjacent layer is captured in the nucleus.
The assembled SHR-SCR-BIRD complex activates target transcription.
SHR-SCR-BIRD activation of SCR and MGP reinforces SHR capture (positive feedback/feed-forward loops).
PMID:21935722
JKD directly regulates SCR and MGP with SHR, SCR and MGP.
Our findings suggest that JKD directly regulates SCR and MGP expression in cooperation with SHR, SCR and MGP
SHR-SCR directly activate CYCD6;1 transcription at the onset of the formative division.
PMID:20596025
SHR and SCR directly activate a D-type cyclin.
Coincident with the onset of a specific formative division, SHR and SCR directly activate a D-type cyclin
CYCD6;1-CDKB1 phosphorylation of RBR relieves RBR inhibition of SCR (nested feed-forward loop).
PMID:22921914
Nested feed-forward loops of SCR-RBR and CYCD6;1 position the asymmetric division.
We demonstrate that this interaction, together with the activity of the RBR regulator CYCD6;1, defines the precise position of ACDs in the stem cell area through two nested feedforward loops
Part 1: mobile SHR signal from stele to adjacent layer
SHR movement from stele and nuclear entry in the endodermis/QC layerRegulatory Stepshr_mobile_signal

SHR is transcribed in the stele and moves one cell layer outward, acting as a positional transcriptional coregulator in the endodermis, CEI and QC.

Annotons

SHR: mobile GRAS transcription coregulator
shr_coregulator
Participant: Gene Product: SHR
Gene Product:

Function

transcription coregulator activityGO:0003712

Processes

radial pattern formationGO:0009956

Locations

nucleusGO:0005634

Non-cell-autonomous positional signal; in the adjacent layer it forms a heterodimer with SCR and is recruited to promoters by BIRD/IDD factors.

PMID:28211915
SHR-SCR are cofactors recruited via BIRD zinc fingers.
SHR-SCR function as transcription cofactors by binding to the third and fourth ZFs, (ZF3-ZF4) of JKD
Part 2: nuclear capture of SHR and assembly of the SHR-SCR-BIRD complex
Nuclear capture of SHR by SCR and BIRD/IDD proteinsRegulatory Stepshr_nuclear_capture

SCR heterodimerizes with SHR through the GRAS alpha-helical caps and BIRD zinc fingers ZF3-ZF4 dock into the SHR groove; together they retain SHR in the nucleus and confine it to a single layer. JKD and MGP bind SHR-SCR mutually exclusively.

Annotons

SCR: binds SHR GRAS domain, retaining SHR in the nucleus
scr_capture
Participant: Gene Product: SCR
Gene Product:

Function

protein domain specific bindingGO:0019904

Processes

maintenance of protein location in nucleusGO:0051457

Locations

nucleusGO:0005634
PMID:17446396
SCR sequesters SHR in the nucleus.
SCARECROW (SCR) blocks SHR movement by sequestering it into the nucleus through protein-protein interaction
JKD: docks SHR-SCR on ZF3-ZF4 and retains SHR in the nucleus
jkd_capture
Participant: Gene Product: JKD
Gene Product:

Function

transcription coregulator bindingGO:0001221

Processes

maintenance of protein location in nucleusGO:0051457

Locations

nucleusGO:0005634
PMID:26494755
JKD promotes SHR nuclear retention.
JKD and BALD-IBIS regulate SHR movement by promoting its nuclear retention
MGP: docks SHR-SCR on ZF3-ZF4
mgp_capture
Participant: Gene Product: MGP
Gene Product:

Function

transcription coregulator bindingGO:0001221

Locations

nucleusGO:0005634
PMID:28211915
SHR-SCR binds MGP ZF3-ZF4 with high affinity, exclusive of JKD.
relatively high affinity of the SHR-SCR complex to MGP ZF3-ZF4 (the KD value of 36 nM) and JKD ZF3-ZF4 (124 nM)
Part 3: SHR-SCR-BIRD transcriptional activation of target genes
SHR-SCR-BIRD activation of SCR, MGP and CYCD6;1Regulatory Stepshr_scr_bird_activation

BIRD zinc fingers ZF1-ZF3 bind IDD motifs in target promoters and the docked SHR-SCR coregulator activates transcription. Targets include SCR (positive feedback that reinforces SHR capture), MGP and other BIRDs (feed-forward), and CYCD6;1 in the CEI/CEI daughter.

Annotons

JKD: IDD DNA-binding transcription factor
jkd_tf
Participant: Gene Product: JKD
Gene Product:

Function

DNA-binding transcription factor activityGO:0003700

Processes

root radial pattern formationGO:0090057

Locations

nucleusGO:0005634
PMID:21935722
JKD activates SCR and MGP promoters in protoplasts, enhanced by SHR and SCR.
Transient expression of LUC reporter genes with the proximal sequences upstream from the ATG codon of SCR and MGP in protoplasts were activated by JKD
MGP: IDD DNA-binding transcription factor (SHR-SCR target)
mgp_tf
Participant: Gene Product: MGP
Gene Product:

Function

DNA-binding transcription factor activityGO:0003700

Processes

root radial pattern formationGO:0090057

Locations

nucleusGO:0005634
PMID:28211915
MGP zinc fingers bind the IDD consensus with high affinity.
Our DNA binding assay using this consensus sequence with ZFs of MGP showed high affinity (KD value of 50 nM) for ZF1-4 (all four ZFs)
SCR: GRAS transcription coregulator partner of SHR
scr_coregulator
Participant: Gene Product: SCR
Gene Product:

Function

transcription coregulator activityGO:0003712

Locations

nucleusGO:0005634

Forms the SHR-SCR coregulator; also bound and inhibited by RBR, which is released by CYCD6;1-CDKB1 phosphorylation.

PMID:20596025
SHR and SCR bind and activate the CYCD6;1 promoter.
We found significant enrichment for both SHR and SCR binding around 1 kilo-base (kb) upstream of the CYCD6;1 promoter
Part 4: formative asymmetric division of the CEI daughter
CYCD6;1-CDKB1-driven formative periclinal divisionBiological Processcycd6_formative_division

CYCD6;1 binds and activates CDKB1;1/1;2; the kinase phosphorylates RBR, releasing SCR from RBR inhibition and executing the asymmetric periclinal division that separates endodermis and cortex. The same module later drives middle-cortex formation from the endodermis.

periclinal cell divisionGO:0090511

Annotons

CYCD6;1: D-type cyclin regulatory subunit of CDKB1
cycd6_1_cdk_regulator
Participant: Gene Product: CYCD6;1
Gene Product:

Function

cyclin-dependent protein serine/threonine kinase regulator activityGO:0016538

Processes

periclinal cell divisionGO:0090511 asymmetric cell divisionGO:0008356

Locations

nucleusGO:0005634
PMID:22921914
CYCD6;1 with CDKB1 phosphorylates RBR.
Based on our genetic and biochemical data, RBR phosphorylation is carried out by a complex of CYCD6;1 with either CDKB1;1 or CDKB1;2
PMID:20596025
CYCD6;1 is specific to formative divisions.
These results indicate that CYCD6;1 is not required for proliferative cell divisions but is specifically involved in formative divisions needed for proper ground tissue patterning
Part 5: quiescent centre identity (stem cell niche context) (optional)
QC identity and stem-cell niche context (SCR, WOX5)Regulatory Stepqc_identity_context

SHR and SCR are also required for QC specification; in the QC, WOX5 acts as a transcriptional repressor that maintains the surrounding columella and other stem cells. Included as niche context for the CEI; WOX5 is not part of the ground-tissue patterning mechanism itself.

Annotons

WOX5: QC homeodomain transcription repressor
wox5_qc_repressor
Participant: Gene Product: WOX5
Gene Product:

Function

DNA-binding transcription repressor activityGO:0001217

Locations

nucleusGO:0005634

Context only; see the WOX5 gene review.