Consistency: Partial. Review/notes and PN agree strongly on the 40S structural + RQC scaffold core (integral 40S protein, collision sensing, ZNF598-dependent RPS2/3/20 ubiquitylation, GO:0072344, GO:0016567, GO:0043022). Two PN rows are absent from the review/notes: (a) ribosome biogenesis / pre-40S placement, and (b) the ATG5/autophagy regulator role (PN Notes cite the RACK1-ATG5 paper). GOA confirms NO biogenesis, pre-40S, GO:0042254, GO:0030688, GO:0016236 or ATG terms. So PN asserts two roles the review neither covers nor refutes.
PN story / NEW pressure:GO:0042254 ribosome biogenesis and GO:0030688 preribosome SSU precursor (both verified real) are genuinely new and NOT in review/GOA. RACK1 is incorporated late into pre-40S particles, so a biogenesis/pre-40S association is biologically plausible — but the review's stance is that RACK1's ribosomal role is structural/translational/RQC, not assembly. This is a candidate ADD that needs literature support before projection (the review did not assess it). GO:0072344 already captured (IMP+IBA). GO:0006515 broader/redundant with GO:0072344.
Mapping strategy:RACK1 is a ribosomal scaffold/collision sensor, not a biogenesis factor by the review's framing; projecting GO:0042254/GO:0030688 from the pre-40S node risks the TRAPP-like/biogenesis over-propagation the dossier itself warns about. Recommend these stay gene-curated, not auto-projected, until verified. RQC-group→GO:0006515 broader than the exact GO:0072344 already present.
Evidence alignment: PN row3 cites the RACK1-ATG5 autophagy paper (title only, no PMID); this paper is absent from the review references entirely. PN biogenesis rows cite nothing. Review RQC evidence (PMID:28132843, 23636399, 25901680) does not overlap PN's cited material. Divergence: autophagy + biogenesis literature uncited in review.
Verdict: Core RQC/40S consistent; PN biogenesis (GO:0042254/GO:0030688) and ATG5-autophagy stories are NOT in the review — candidate ADDs requiring verification, currently over-reaching as auto-projections.
Recommended edits: [YAML] Consider adding a note/annotation on the RACK1-ATG5 autophagy-regulator role (PN-cited) and the pre-40S/biogenesis association if literature supports — both are absent from the current review. [MAP] Do NOT auto-project GO:0042254/GO:0030688 to RACK1 from the biogenesis/pre-40S node without gene-level evidence (RACK1 framed as structural/RQC scaffold, not an assembly factor); GO:0006515 broader than the exact GO:0072344 already present. [REF] RACK1-ATG5 paper (resolve to a PMID) missing from review references.